| Lincoln Trust v Spaziano |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 04601 [118 AD3d 1399] |
| June 20, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1]
| Lincoln Trust, as Custodian for Daniel Elstein, M.D.,Rollover IRA, et al., Appellants, v Alfred D. Spaziano, Defendant, and AlbertM. Mercury et al., Respondents. |
Davidson Fink LLP, Rochester (David L. Rasmussen of counsel), forplaintiffs-appellants.
Connors & Vilardo, LLP, Buffalo (Lawrence J. Vilardo of counsel) and HarrisBeach PLLC, for defendants-respondents.
Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Onondaga County (Anthony J. Paris,J.), entered March 8, 2013. The order, among other things, granted the motion ofdefendants Albert M. Mercury and Phillips, Lytle, Hitchcock, Blaine and Huber, LLP,for summary judgment dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against them.
It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.
Memorandum: Plaintiffs commenced this legal malpractice action seeking damagesarising from the alleged negligence of Albert M. Mercury, Esq. (defendant), whorepresented Daniel Elstein (plaintiff) at the closing of a $750,000 loan that plaintiff madeto defendant Alfred D. Spaziano. The closing occurred on September 12, 2001, and theloan was secured by Spaziano's stock in Westview Commons Apartments, Inc. (WCA),which owned and operated an apartment complex (subject property) in the Town ofGates. John Hancock Mutual Insurance Company (John Hancock) held a first mortgageon the subject property while, unbeknownst to plaintiff, Monroe Funding held secondarymortgages, one of which was filed eight days before plaintiff closed on his loan toSpaziano.
The complaint alleges that defendant and his law firm (hereafter, defendants) werenegligent in, among other things, failing to notify plaintiff that John Hancock hadcommenced a foreclosure action in December 2001 with respect to the subject propertybecause Spaziano had failed to make his mortgage payments in October and Novemberof that year. Plaintiff did not learn of Spaziano's default on the John Hancock mortgageuntil January 2003, when Spaziano defaulted on the promissory note to plaintiff andWCA filed for bankruptcy. Based on Spaziano's default on the $750,000 promissorynote, plaintiff enforced his security interest in the WCA stock. Plaintiff thereafterpartnered with David Reidman, a real estate developer in Rochester, to purchase andmanage the subject property.
Plaintiff and Reidman formed Trason Westview, LLC (Trason), with plaintiffowning 75% and Reidman owning 25% of the company. Together, plaintiff andReidman secured financing from First Niagara Bank (First Niagara), purchased thesubject property with the approval of Bankruptcy Court, and satisfied the John Hancockand Monroe Funding mortgages. Specifically, John Hancock received approximately $11million to satisfy its mortgage, and Monroe Funding received $970,000 to satisfy itssecondary mortgages. As plaintiff explained at his deposition, Monroe Funding, asholder of the secondary mortgages, accepted a significantly lower amount of money thanthe amount owed due to the risk of receiving even less money after a foreclosuresale.
Prior to closing title, plaintiff obtained an appraisal of the subject property, whichwas valued at approximately $14 million, some $2 million less than plaintiff andReidman were expending to acquire the property. At the closing, plaintiff signed ageneral release in favor of Spaziano with respect to the unpaid promissory note. Plaintiffand Reidman thereafter sold the property for a profit, and plaintiffs commenced this legalmalpractice action.
The complaint requested damages of $750,000 plus interest as calculated in thepromissory note, and $3,000,000 in punitive damages. More than six years after theaction was commenced, plaintiffs alleged another theory of damages in their bill ofparticulars. Specifically, plaintiffs alleged that, if defendants had notified plaintiff in atimely fashion of Spaziano's default on the John Hancock mortgage, plaintiff would havebeen able to satisfy the John Hancock mortgage for $809,941.97 less than he had to payJohn Hancock 14 months later, and that defendants' negligence therefore cost plaintiffs$809,941.97. That figure was later reduced by plaintiffs to $703,435.80.
Defendants moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint against them,contending, inter alia, that, because plaintiffs had profited from the purchase and sale ofthe subject property, they had sustained no damages as a result of defendants' allegedmalpractice. Defendants also asserted that plaintiffs are not entitled to damages arisingfrom the unpaid promissory note because plaintiff had released Spaziano from liabilityon that loan. Plaintiffs opposed the motion and cross-moved for partial summaryjudgment with respect to several causes of action. Supreme Court granted the motion anddenied the cross motion. We now affirm.
To succeed on a claim of legal malpractice, a plaintiff must prove, inter alia, that theattorney's negligence was a proximate cause of a loss that resulted in actual andascertainable damages (seeLeder v Spiegel, 9 NY3d 836, 837 [2007], cert denied 552 US 1257[2008]; see also Hotaling v Sprock [appeal No. 2], 107 AD3d 1446, 1446-1447[2013]). Here, defendants met their initial burden of establishing that plaintiffs were notentitled to damages based on the unpaid promissory note inasmuch as the release given toSpaziano by plaintiff is valid and enforceable (see Appel v Ford Motor Co., 111AD2d 731, 732-733 [1985]; see also Gubitz v Security Mut. Life Ins. Co. ofN.Y., 262 AD2d 451, 451 [1999]; Matter of Garvin, 210 AD2d 332, 333[1994]) and, in opposition, plaintiffs failed to raise an issue of fact (see generallyZuckerman v City of New York, 49 NY2d 557, 562 [1980]).
With respect to plaintiffs' alternate theory of damages—that defendants' failureto notify plaintiff of Spaziano's default on the John Hancock mortgage cost plaintiff$703,435.80 in lost profits—we agree with the court that the theory is toospeculative to survive defendants' motion for summary judgment (see Bua v Purcell & Ingrao,P.C., 99 AD3d 843, 847-848 [2012], lv denied 20 NY3d 857 [2013];Perkins v Norwick, 257 AD2d 48, 51 [1999]; Sherwood Group v Dornbush,Mensch, Mandelstam & Silverman, 191 AD2d 292, 294-295 [1993]; Brownv Samalin & Bock, 168 AD2d 531, 531-532 [1990]). As defendants point out, itis not clear that plaintiff could have obtained the necessary funding from First Niagara orany other lender to purchase the property in November 2001, 14 months earlier than theactual purchase date. Moreover, it was not certain that Monroe Funding at that timewould have accepted a steep reduction in the amount that it was owed on the secondarymortgages, or that plaintiff and Reidman would have been able to sell the subjectproperty for the same price as they later did. In addition, plaintiff acknowledged at hisdeposition that he would not have purchased the subject property without Reidman, who,according to plaintiff, was vital to the success of the venture. Plaintiff did not meetReidman until after he learned of Spaziano's default on the John Hancock mortgage. Asthe court stated in its decision, there is no evidence that plaintiff "would have found aninvestor similar to Reidman at that time, or acceptable to Monroe Funding as the juniormortgage holder."
Finally, because plaintiffs sustained no actual damages and, in fact, profited from thesale of the subject property, we conclude that they are not entitled to an award of punitivedamages. Present—Centra, J.P., Fahey, Peradotto, Lindley and Valentino, JJ.