| Matter of Russo v New York City Dept. of Educ. |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 05032 [119 AD3d 416] |
| July 3, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1]
| 1 In the Matter of Anthony J. Russo,Appellant, v New York City Department of Education,Respondent. |
Anthony J. Russo, appellant pro se.
Jeffrey D. Friedlander, Acting Corporation Counsel, New York (Christina Chung ofcounsel), for respondent.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Geoffrey D. Wright, J.), entered January14, 2013, which, in this proceeding pursuant to Education Law § 3020-a (5)and CPLR 7511, to vacate an arbitration award finding petitioner guilty of incompetenceand imposing a penalty of termination, denied the petition and granted respondent's crossmotion to dismiss the petition, modified, on the law, to deny the cross motion, and togrant the petition to the extent of remanding the matter to respondent, New York CityDepartment of Education (DOE), for imposition of a lesser penalty, and otherwiseaffirmed, without costs.
Petitioner was a licensed common branches and special education teacher and hadbeen employed as such by respondent for more than 21 years when he was terminated in2011. In 2005, he was assigned to PS/IS 377 in Brooklyn. He received satisfactoryratings at that school for three years, as he had in his previous years as a teacher. In2008-2009, petitioner was assigned to a self-contained special education class comprisedof 12 students who were chronologically fourth, fifth, sixth, graders, but who werefunctioning at two and three years below grade level.
After 18 years of satisfactory ratings, in 2009, the principal of the school ratedpetitioner unsatisfactory. Petitioner asked to either be assigned to another class or beassigned an aide or assistant, as was the usual practice for classes of special educationstudents, but neither request was granted. Petitioner was assigned the same class with thesame group of students for three consecutive years, until the older students completed theeighth grade. Petitioner was rated as unsatisfactory all three years he taught this classbased in part on his inability to control the classroom and his inability to plan andeffectively execute certain lessons. While petitioner's requests to be assigned to adifferent class were repeatedly denied, various teachers and administrators purported toadvise him as to how to improve his performance.
At the disciplinary hearing, petitioner's principal and several other witnesses testifiedas to petitioner's deficiencies in preparing his classroom, planning and implementing thecurriculum, and managing the unruly students. Included among the specified chargeswere allowing students to eat in the classroom, not adequately controlling disruptivebehavior, and not engaging all of the students in the prescribed curriculum. Petitionerwas criticized for failing to [*2]follow the Teacher'sCollege Workshop Model lessons, even though the Workshop Model made no provisionsfor students with learning disabilities.
The Hearing Officer determined that petitioner was guilty of seven out of nine of thespecified charges spanning a three-year period. While the Hearing Officer acknowledgedthat petitioner had attempted to improve his performance by working with a mentor andparticipating in the Peer Intervention Plus Program (PIP Plus), which involved theassignment of an impartial teacher to assist petitioner, the Hearing Officer deemedpetitioner's performance to be unsatisfactory.
Petitioner avers that the remediation efforts were inadequate in that he never receivedorganized or consistent lessons from his peers and that they usually consisted of rushed,disorganized, and informal hallway meetings. Petitioner also contends that the assistancehe received from the assistant principals was uncoordinated and often contradictory. Inone instance petitioner sought help designing a lesson from one assistant principal butwhen a different assistant principal observed the lesson that the first assistant principalhad prepared with petitioner, the second one rated it as unsatisfactory because the lessonfailed to follow a specific structure established by written guidelines.
Petitioner also contends that the PIP Plus program was conducted in a haphazard andundirected manner, giving him little opportunity to improve his performance. Althoughthe PIP Plus professional concluded that petitioner's performance was unsatisfactory inthe core instructional responsibilities, the professional acknowledged that it was his firstassignment as a PIP Plus consultant. It was also his first time testifying. According topetitioner, the consultant also testified that he had never held any supervisory position,failed to follow PIP Plus protocols, and failed to inquire as to what resources wereavailable at the school to help petitioner. Despite the limited guidance that petitionerreceived through the program, the consultant testified and the Hearing Officer found thatpetitioner made progress in several areas, including reducing behavioral problems in theclassroom.
Petitioner further argues that his unblemished 18 years as a teacher prior to theassignment at issue should have been considered. Petitioner points out that he did notbegin receiving unsatisfactory evaluations until he was assigned the same special needsclass starting in 2008 for three consecutive years.
While we do not dispute the specific findings of the Hearing Officer concerningpetitioner's deficiencies in the management of this one special education class, we findthat under the circumstances presented here the penalty of termination shocks our senseof fairness (see Matter of Pell v Board of Educ. of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 ofTowns of Scarsdale & Mamaroneck, Westchester County, 34 NY2d 222, 234[1974]).
While the dissent finds that petitioner had a "long-term pattern of inadequateperformance," that "pattern" involves the same class from which petitioner sought atransfer. In actuality, petitioner had a lengthy unblemished record prior to being assignedthat class, which consisted of students at their most difficult age. Petitioner asked for atransfer, and at least for an aide to be assigned. His requests were ignored and instead hewas kept with the same students for three years without an aide, even though theprincipal found his ability to handle that specific group of students unsatisfactory. Thedissent notes that petitioner's spotless record for the previous 18 years is notdeterminative, but it is still an important factor to be considered (see Matter of Riley v City of NewYork, 84 AD3d 442 [1st Dept 2011] [termination disproportionate wherestudent was not injured and the petitioner had a 15-year unblemished record]). Moreover,[*3]remediation efforts that were made provedunsuccessful at least in part because the advice given was neither consistent noradequately targeted.
Although the dissent provides a litany of incidents in which petitioner failed tocontrol the class, most of these incidents occurred in petitioner's first year with the class.The remainder of the incidents occurred the second year, and there were no incidents inthe third year. Of the seven charges of which petitioner was found guilty, petitionerimproved his management of the class so that the types of incidents underlying six of thecharges did not recur in his final year with the class. His control of the class improveddramatically, as did the quality of his instruction and his compliance with DOEguidelines. The incident, of which petitioner was not aware, in which students wereobserving pornography on a computer in petitioner's classroom in the first year occurredbecause respondent's filters did not block the sites as petitioner had a right to expect. Wenote that all of petitioner's students were promoted after the 2008-2009 school year.
Respondent cites Matter of Curtis v Black (2012 NY Slip Op 30457[U] [SupCt, NY County 2012]) and Matter of Ebewo v New York City Dept. of Educ.(2011 NY Slip Op 32384[U] [Sup Ct, NY County 2011]) for the proposition thatincompetence can be the basis of termination. In Curtis the Hearing Officerdetermined that termination was necessary to ensure the students' safety because theteacher's courses involved dangerous tools and equipment. There is no evidence here thatpetitioner's continued employment would endanger the safety and well-being of hisstudents. In Ebewo the Hearing Officer determined that the teacher should beterminated because he was incompetent and was not making any improvements. Here,the Hearing Officer, PIP Plus professional, and others found that petitioner wasimproving despite the substantial challenges that his students presented.
In conclusion, we reiterate that it is troubling to see respondent's apparentdetermination to terminate petitioner, a 21-year veteran with 18 years of satisfactoryratings, because of his difficulty with one class in which he was kept for three years.
Accordingly, we find the Hearing Officer's decision to dismiss the teacher to bemanifestly disproportionate to petitioner's conduct and remand the matter for theimposition of a lesser penalty. Concur—Friedman, Saxe and Freedman, JJ.
Tom, J.P., and Sweeny, J., dissent in a memorandum by Sweeny, J., as follows: Themajority agrees that the Hearing Officer's determination that petitioner was guilty of theseven specified charges spanning a three-year period, was supported by adequateevidence (see Lackow vDepartment of Educ. [or "Board"] of City of N.Y., 51 AD3d 563, 567 [1st Dept2008]). However, because they find that the Hearing Officer's recommendation oftermination as a penalty for those offenses is disproportionate and remand forconsideration of a lesser penalty, I must dissent.
The majority credits petitioner's assertion that the assistance given to him by hissupervisors and colleagues was inadequate. The record reveals however, that petitionerappealed his unsatisfactory ratings for school years 2008-2009 and 2009-2010 and thoseappeals were denied. Petitioner received 14 observations from his principal and assistantprincipals containing recommendations for the improvement of his performance. Theschool's administration also prepared three different "Plans of Assistance" for him eachyear after he was warned that he was [*4]in danger ofreceiving an unsatisfactory rating. His principal recommended that petitioner participatein the Peer Intervention Plus Program, and a mentor was assigned to work withpetitioner.
The majority minimizes the nature and extent of petitioner's shortcomings. Thecharges that were sustained by the Hearing Officer, and not disputed by the majority,involved more than simply an inability to control his classroom in the face of a difficultgroup of students. They include allegations of neglect and disregard for student health,safety and well-being, failing to timely and/or properly manage his classroom, failing toproperly and/or adequately engage students in instruction, failure to attend mandatedfaculty meetings, failure to properly, adequately and/or effectively plan and/or executelessons, failure to timely, properly, adequately and/or effectively update, draft and/orimplement his students' Individualized Educational Plans (IEPs), and failure toimplement professional development recommendations. Significantly, petitioner did notdispute some of the more serious charges made by respondent. For example, he did nottestify regarding two incidents where students were entering and leaving the classroomwithout permission and where students were rolling around on the floor. Nor did hetestify regarding the allegation that he took no action when students were observed byanother teacher viewing pornographic material on a school computer, as well as anallegation that he failed to prepare his classroom properly because it lacked, among otherthings, bulletin boards, charts, information about reading and writing, and a dailyschedule. With respect to the other charges, the Hearing Officer found more thanadequate testimony, supported by contemporaneous records, to sustain those charges.Additionally, despite petitioner's claims to the contrary, the Hearing Officer found thathis colleagues repeatedly entered his classroom to assist with student instruction, controlstudent behavior, model lessons for him, and assist him with IEPs. The record does notsupport petitioner's claims that these remediation efforts were, as the majority finds,"neither consistent nor adequately targeted." In fact, the Hearing Officer's findings weresupported by evidence which showed, among other things, that petitioner receivedobservations, both formal and informal, beyond the required amount, which served toprovide him with guidance and feedback as to his performance, as well as suggestionsfor improvement. Importantly, he participated in pre-observation conferences duringwhich he was advised of his supervisors' expectations.
The Hearing Officer's credibility findings in favor of respondent's witnesses areentitled to deference and neither petitioner nor the majority has advanced any reason todisturb those findings (Matter ofColon v City of N.Y. Dept. of Educ., 94 AD3d 568 [1st Dept 2012]; Matter of Douglas v New YorkCity Bd./Dept. of Educ., 87 AD3d 856, 857 [1st Dept 2011]).
In determining the appropriate penalty, the Hearing Officer properly considered, atpetitioner's request, the efforts that respondent made to provide remediation, and hisconclusion that those efforts were adequate is supported by the record. Petitionerreceived feedback and suggestions for improvement through observation reports andpre-observation conferences, plans of assistance and support from his colleagues, and heparticipated in the Peer Intervention Plus Program (see Education Law§ 3020-a [4]).
The standard for reviewing a penalty imposed after a hearing pursuant to EducationLaw § 3020-a is whether the punishment of dismissal was sodisproportionate to the offenses as to be shocking to the court's sense of fairness(Matter of Harris v Mechanicville Cent. School Dist., 45 NY2d 279, 285 [1978];Matter of Pell v Board of Educ. of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 of Towns ofScarsdale & Mamaroneck, Westchester County, 34 NY2d 222, 233 [1974]).Contrary [*5]to the majority's conclusion, the record heresupports the Hearing Officer's determination that termination is appropriate.
While it is true that petitioner has an unblemished record prior to the 2008-2009school year, that factor alone is not determinative (see e.g. Matter of Ajeleye v New York City Dept. of Educ., 112AD3d 425, 425-426 [1st Dept 2013] [termination "does not shock one's sense offairness" where the petitioner was found guilty of insubordination, neglect of duty andconduct unbecoming his position, after a 14 year unblemished record]). In light of theHearing Officer's findings of a long-term pattern of inadequate performance by petitionerand that sufficient attempts at remediation had been unsuccessful, the penalty oftermination is not disproportionate to the offenses (see Lackow, 51 AD3d at569). "That reasonable minds might disagree over what the proper penalty should havebeen does not provide a basis for vacating the arbitral award or refashioning the penalty"(City School Dist. of the City ofN.Y. v McGraham, 17 NY3d 917, 920 [2011]).
I would therefore affirm the order and confirm the arbitration award.