| Matter of Vescera v Stewart |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 05910 [120 AD3d 990] |
| August 20, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1](August 20, 2014)
| In the Matter of Frank Vescera et al., Appellants, vRussell Stewart et al., Commissioners of Oneida County Board of Elections, et al.,Respondents. |
Law Offices of James E. Walsh, Ballston Spa (James E. Walsh of counsel), forpetitioners-appellants.
Peter M. Rayhill, County Attorney, Utica (Harris J. Samuels of counsel), forrespondents-respondents Russell Stewart and Rose Grimaldi, Commissioners of OneidaCounty Board of Elections.
Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Oneida County (Norman I. Siegel, J.),entered August 8, 2014 in a proceeding pursuant to Election Law article 16. The order,insofar as appealed from, invalidated the designating petitions of petitioners.
It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.
Memorandum: Petitioners Frank Vescera and James Zecca filed designating petitionspurporting to nominate them as Democratic Party candidates for the respective publicoffices of president and member at large of the City of Utica Common Council. TheOneida County Board of Elections determined that the designating petitions did notcontain a sufficient number of valid signatures, and petitioners commenced thisproceeding to validate the designating petitions. Supreme Court concluded after ahearing that the designating petitions were invalid and, in effect, dismissed the petition.We affirm.
Election Law § 6-136 (2) provides that designating petitions fornon-statewide public office generally must be signed by five percent of the activeenrolled party members in the relevant political unit, but that the number of signatures"need not exceed" enumerated thresholds for specific public offices. At the hearing, theparties stipulated that five percent of the number of active enrolled Democrats in the Cityof Utica is 708, and that there are 653 valid signatures on the designating petitions.Petitioners contend, however, that only 500 signatures are required pursuant to section6-136 (2) (f) or, alternatively, pursuant to section 6-136 (2) (i) and (j).
We agree with the court that the citywide positions at issue are "to be filled by all thevoters of [a city] . . . containing more than twenty-five thousand and notmore than two hundred fifty thousand inhabitants" (Election Law § 6-136[2] [e]), rather than "all the voters of . . . a councilmanic district" (ElectionLaw § 6-136 [2] [f]). We note that the fact that the population of the City ofUtica exceeds 25,000 is "a proper subject of judicial notice" (Matter of Siwek vMahoney, 39 NY2d 159, 163 n 2 [1976]; see Scoville v Cicoria, 65 NY2d972, 974 n [1985]).
Election Law § 6-136 (2) (j) provides that the number of signaturesrequired "[f]or any office to be filled by all the voters of any political subdivision, exceptas herein otherwise provided, contained within another political subdivision, [need] not. . . exceed the number of signatures required for the larger subdivision."Petitioners therefore contend that their designating petitions require only 500 signaturesbecause the City of Utica is wholly within a [*2]singleassembly district (see Election Law § 6-136 [2] [i]). We agree withthe court, however, that the phrase "except as herein otherwise provided" modifies "anypolitical subdivision," such that section 6-136 (2) (j) has no application to public officesin political subdivisions for which a specific provision exists elsewhere in the statute(see generally Matter of Buffalo Columbus Hosp. v Axelrod, 165 AD2d 605, 608[1991]). Because section 6-136 (2) (e) applies to citywide public offices in the City ofUtica, section 6-136 (2) (j) does not apply. The applicable signature requirement istherefore the lesser of 1,000 or five percent of the number of enrolled Democrats in theCity of Utica. Here, the five percent figure, i.e., 708, is the lesser number, and the courtproperly determined that the designating petitions are invalid on the ground that they donot contain at least 708 valid signatures.
Petitioners' contention premised on the New York Constitution is raised for the firsttime on appeal, and we therefore do not consider it (see Matter of Scott v City of Buffalo, 67 AD3d 1393, 1394[2009], lv denied 14 NY3d 710 [2010]; see also Matter of McGee vKorman, 70 NY2d 225, 231-232 [1987]; Matter of Iocovozzi v Herkimer County Bd. of Elections, 76AD3d 797, 798 [2010]). Present— Scudder, P.J., Peradotto, Lindley,Valentino and Whalen, JJ.