| Fidelity Natl. Tit. Ins. Co. v Altshuler Shaham Provident FundsLtd. |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 06371 [120 AD3d 1135] |
| September 25, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1]
| Fidelity National Title Insurance Company,Plaintiff, v Altshuler Shaham Provident Funds Ltd, Formerly Known as PerfectProvident Fund Ltd, Defendant/Third-Party Plaintiff-Respondent. Jaeckle Fleischmann& Mugel LLP, Third-Party Defendant-Appellant. Perfect Provident Fund Ltd,Respondent, v Jaeckle Fleischmann & Mugel LLP,Appellant. |
Zdarsky, Sawicki & Agostinelli, LLP, Buffalo (Joseph E. Zdarsky of counsel),for appellant.
Milberg LLP, New York (Kent Andrew Bronson of counsel), for respondent.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Charles E. Ramos, J.), entered February21, 2013, which granted Altshuler Shaham Provident Funds Ltd.'s motion to transfer theErie County action to New York County, granted Altshuler's motion to consolidate theactions to the extent of consolidating the actions for discovery and other pretrialproceedings and deferring a determination as to whether to consolidate the actions fortrial until after the completion of discovery and the determination of any dispositivemotions, and denied Jaeckle Fleischmann & [*2]Mugel LLP's motion to dismiss the amended third-partycomplaint in the New York County action, unanimously reversed, on the law and thefacts, with costs, Altshuler's motion to transfer and consolidate denied, and Jaeckle'smotion to dismiss granted without prejudice to the continued prosecution of the ErieCounty action. The Clerk is directed to transfer the file in the Erie County action to the Clerk of Erie County and further directed to enter judgment dismissing the amendedthird-party complaint in the New York County action.
This action stems from a failed loan relating to commercial real estate in Syracuse,New York (see generallyAltshuler Shaham Provident Funds, Ltd. v GML Tower, LLC, 21 NY3d 352[2013]). Fidelity National Title Insurance Company issued a policy to Altshuler. In theNew York County action, plaintiff Fidelity seeks a declaration that it properly deniedcoverage to defendant Altshuler. In the amended third-party complaint against Jaeckle,Altshuler asserts that Jaeckle committed legal malpractice by failing to, among otherthings, obtain adequate title insurance. The amended third-party complaint should havebeen dismissed for failure to state a cause of action (CPLR 3211 [a] [7]), becauseFidelity did not make a claim against Altshuler for which Jaeckle "is or may be liable"(CPLR 1007; see Merchants Mut. Ins. Co. v Valilis, 11 AD2d 324, 326 [1st Dept1960]; Ainspan v City of Albany, 132 AD2d 911, 913 [3d Dept 1987]). Based onthe foregoing determination, it is unnecessary to reach Jaeckle's other arguments insupport of dismissal of the amended third-party complaint.
The motion court should have denied Altshuler's motion to consolidate the NewYork County and Erie County actions (see County of Westchester v White Plains Ave., LLC, 105AD3d 690, 691 [2d Dept 2013]). As we are dismissing the amended third-partycomplaint in the New York County action, the two actions no longer present commonquestions of law or fact (see CPLR 602 [a]). The issue in the New York Countyaction is whether Fidelity properly disclaimed coverage; this will turn on the wording ofthe policy, not whether Jaeckle committed malpractice by obtaining the wrong type ofpolicy. Concur—Sweeny, J.P., Moskowitz, DeGrasse, Manzanet-Daniels andClark, JJ.
[As corrected at the direction of the Appellate Division, First Department, Jan. 21, 2015.]