Matter of Miller v New York State Div. of HumanRights
2014 NY Slip Op 07742 [122 AD3d 431]
November 13, 2014
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 31, 2014


[*1]
 In the Matter of Jerald Miller,Appellant,
v
New York State Division of Human Rights,Respondent.

Jerald Miller, appellant pro se.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York (Andrew Kent of counsel), forrespondent.

Judgment, Supreme Court, Bronx County (Mitchell J. Danziger, J.), enteredDecember 6, 2012, denying the petition seeking to annul respondent's determination,dated June 21, 2012, which denied petitioner's request for disclosure of certaindocuments pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law (FOIL), and dismissing theproceeding brought pursuant to CPLR article 78, unanimously affirmed, withoutcosts.

The court properly denied the petition and dismissed the proceeding. Although thecourt reviewed respondent's determination under the "arbitrary and capricious" standard,instead of determining whether the denial "was affected by an error of law" (CPLR 7803[3]), the matter need not be remanded since respondent properly determined that FOILdoes not require disclosure of the requested materials (see Mulgrew v Board of Educ. ofthe City School Dist. of the City of N.Y., 87 AD3d 506, 507 [1st Dept 2011],lv denied 18 NY3d 806 [2012]).

Respondent properly withheld the four legal opinions requested by petitionerpursuant to the "intra-agency materials" exemption (see Public Officers Law§ 87 [2] [g]), since they are essentially "predecisional memoranda, preparedto assist the agency in its decision-making process and . . . are not finalagency determinations or policy" (Kheel v Ravitch, 93 AD2d 422, 427-428 [1stDept 1983], affd 62 NY2d 1 [1984]). Contrary to petitioner's argument, theopinions do not fall under the exceptions to this exemption for "statistical or factualtabulations or data" (Public Officers Law § 87 [2] [g] [i]) or "instructions tostaff that affect the public" (Public Officers Law § 87 [2] [g] [ii]; seeMatter of Gould v New York City Police Dept., 89 NY2d 267, 276 [1996]; Matter of Tuck-It-Away Assoc.,L.P. v Empire State Dev. Corp., 54 AD3d 154, 166 [1st Dept 2008]).

Moreover, three of the four opinions are "specifically exempted from disclosure bystate . . . statute" (Public Officers Law § 87 [2] [a]; seeMatter of Short v Board of Mgrs. of Nassau County Med. Ctr., 57 NY2d 399 [1982])pursuant to Executive Law § 297 (8), which prohibits respondent frommaking public information contained in reports obtained by it with respect to a particularperson without his or her consent. Respondent cannot rely on the alternative groundraised on appeal that the legal opinions are privileged as attorney work-product pursuantto CPLR 3101 (c), since it did not invoke this ground as a basis for denying petitioner'srequest (see [*2]Matter of National Fuel Gas Distrib. Corp. v Public Serv.Commn. of the State of N.Y., 16 NY3d 360, 368 [2011]).

Respondent properly denied the request for its "Case Management System LegalResources Notebook," which does not constitute a record within the meaning of FOIL,since it is not "information" (Public Officers Law § 86 [4]) but rather asoftware application providing the means of accessing information in its electronic filesystem. It also properly withheld the user's manual for that application, since itsdisclosure "would jeopardize [respondent's] capacity . . . to guarantee thesecurity of its . . . electronic information systems" (Public Officers Law§ 87 [2] [i]).

Since petitioner has not substantially prevailed, he is not entitled to attorney's feesand costs pursuant to Public Officers Law § 89 (4) (c).Concur—Gonzalez, P.J., Tom, Renwick and Gische, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.