| Matter of Lombardo v Otsego County Empls. |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 01216 [125 AD3d 1079] |
| February 11, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of the Claim of Anthony Lombardo,Respondent, v Otsego County Employees et al., Appellants. Workers' CompensationBoard, Respondent. |
Sullivan Keenan Oliver & Violando, LLP, Albany (Michael D. Violando ofcounsel), for appellants.
Peter W. Hill, Oneonta, for Anthony Lombardo, respondent.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Iris A. Steel of counsel),for Workers' Compensation Board, respondent.
Egan Jr., J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filedMarch 20, 2013, which ruled that claimant's removal from the labor market wasinvoluntary.
In June 2004, after working for the employer for 32 years, claimant filed hisretirement papers, with an effective date of July 30, 2004. Claimant continued to workfull duty until July 8, 2004, when he sustained work-related injuries to his head,shoulders and back, which rendered him disabled for the duration of his employment.Workers' compensation awards were paid from the date of injury until the date ofretirement and were held in abeyance thereafter. The claim was reopened in September2011, at which time claimant alleged that he was entitled to awards subsequent to theeffective retirement date. The employer and its third-party administrator controverted theclaim, contending that claimant's retirement constituted a voluntary withdrawal from thelabor market. Following a hearing, a Workers' Compensation Law Judge determined,among other things, that as a result of claimant's causally-related disability resulting fromhis work-related injury, claimant did not voluntarily withdraw from the labor market, andestablished the claim awarding benefits subsequent to the effective retirement date. TheWorkers' [*2]Compensation Board affirmed thatdetermination, giving rise to this appeal.
We reverse. "Generally, a claimant who voluntarily withdraws from the labor marketby retiring is not entitled to workers' compensation benefits unless the claimant'sdisability caused or contributed to the retirement" (Matter of Lombardi v BrooklynUnion Gas Co., 306 AD2d 704, 705 [2003] [citation omitted]; see Matter of Flannery v NassauCounty Police Dept., 26 AD3d 678, 680 [2006]; Matter of Bury v Great NeckUFSD, 14 AD3d 786, 787 [2005]; Matter of Camarda v New York Tel.,262 AD2d 816, 816 [1999]). Whether a voluntary withdrawal has occurred "is a factualdetermination to be made by the Board, and its decision will be upheld when supportedby substantial evidence" (Matterof Ballou v Southworth-Milton, Inc., 107 AD3d 1084, 1085 [2013]; seeMatter of Flannery v Nassau County Police Dept., 26 AD3d at 678; Matter ofBury v Great Neck UFSD, 14 AD3d at 787; Matter of Gennes v Longwood Cent. School Dist., 2 AD3d1015, 1016 [2003]). There must, however, "be some evidence that the claimant'sdisability caused or contributed to retirement" (Matter of Curtis v Dale PiperyCorp., 295 AD2d 836, 837 [2002] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted];see Matter of Camarda v New York Tel., 262 AD2d at 816; Employer:Corning Inc., 2014 WL 2726554, *5, 2014 NY Wrk Comp LEXIS 3836, *14 [WCBNo. G015 9086, June 16, 2014]).
At the hearing, claimant testified that he decided to retire prior to the happening ofthe accident due to personal issues he had with his supervisors and did so with fullbenefits based upon his 32 years of service. Noticeably absent from claimant's testimonyis any assertion that his injuries were a contributing factor in his decision to retire (seeMatter of Gennes v Longwood Cent. School Dist., 2 AD3d at 1016). In fact,claimant admitted that he voluntarily retired for reasons unrelated to his claim forcompensation, but asserted that, inasmuch as his medical conditions worsened afterretirement, his withdrawal from the labor market was involuntary. Notwithstanding thepermanent and total nature of claimant's disability, there is no evidence in the record thatclaimant, who was 66 years old at the time he retired, had intended to remain attached tothe labor market post-retirement. Thus, claimant's decision to remove himself from thelabor market was unrelated to his disability, and the record is devoid of any proof thatclaimant suffered post-retirement loss of wages as a result of his disability (see Matter of Bacci v Staten Is.Univ. Hosp., 32 AD3d 582, 584 [2006]; see also Employer: Paramount Ins.Co., 1999 NY Wrk Comp LEXIS 275, *6 [WCB No. 0953 4242, Dec. 30, 1999]).Accordingly, the Board's finding that claimant involuntarily withdrew from the labormarket is not supported by substantial evidence.
Lahtinen, J.P., Lynch and Devine, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is reversed,without costs, and matter remitted to the Workers' Compensation Board for furtherproceedings not inconsistent with this Court's decision.