| Matter of Hunter (Gannett Co., Inc.—Commissioner ofLabor) |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 01509 [125 AD3d 1166] |
| February 19, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of the Claim of Camille Hunter,Respondent. Gannett Company, Inc., Doing Business as Democrat and Chronicle,Appellant; Commissioner of Labor, Respondent. |
Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC, Syracuse (Daniel J. Pautz of counsel) and TheZinser Law Firm, PC, Nashville, Tennessee (L. Michael Zinser admitted pro hac vice),for appellant.
James W. Cooper, Warrensburg, for Camille Hunter, respondent.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Steven Koton of counsel),for Commissioner of Labor, respondent.
Satterlee Stephens Burke & Burke, LLP, New York City (Mark A. Fowler), forNew York News Publishers Association, amicus curiae.
Appeals from two decisions of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filedJuly 25, 2013, which ruled, among other things, that Gannett Company, Inc. is liable foradditional unemployment insurance contributions on remuneration paid to claimant andothers similarly situated.
Claimant contracted with Gannett Company, Inc. to deliver newspapers to residentialcustomers. After the Commissioner of Labor deemed claimant an employee, Gannettobjected and, following a hearing, the Administrative Law Judge disagreed andconcluded that claimant was an independent contractor. On appeal by the Commissionerof Labor, the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board reversed that determination andfound claimant and all motor-route carriers similarly situated to be employees. Gannettnow appeals, and we affirm.
[*2] The essenceof Gannett's argument is that the Board's finding of an employer-employee relationship isnot supported by substantial evidence. We disagree. "Whether an employer-employeerelationship exists is a factual determination for the Board, and its decision will beupheld if supported by substantial evidence" (Matter of John Lack Assoc., LLC [Commissioner of Labor],112 AD3d 1042, 1043 [2013] [citations omitted]; see Matter of ConcourseOphthalmology Assoc. [Roberts], 60 NY2d 734, 736 [1983]). "While no singlefactor is determinative, control over the results produced or the means used to achievethose results are pertinent considerations, with the latter being more important" (Matter of Joyce [Coface N. Am.Ins. Co.—Commissioner of Labor], 116 AD3d 1132, 1134 [2014][internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; see Matter of Spielberger [Commissioner of Labor], 122 AD3d998, 999 [2014]).
Recently, in Matter ofArmison (Gannett Co., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor) (122 AD3d 1101[2014]), this Court upheld a finding of an employer-employee relationship betweenGannett and certain newspaper delivery persons. Here, as we did in Armison, wefind that the requisite level of control was present to support the Board's finding of anemployer-employee relationship. Claimant was required to make deliveries within settime frames and according to other conditions. Claimant was also required to be alicensed driver with a registered and insured vehicle, and was obligated to provideGannett with a copy of her driver's license and proof of liability insurance. Additionally,under the terms of the distribution agreement, all substitutes were required to be licensedand insured. Claimant was provided a route set by Gannett and, if claimant was notavailable to deliver her route, she was responsible for finding a substitute. In the eventthat deliveries were not made by claimant, Gannett would use an employee to make thedelivery and charge claimant a fee. Further, Gannett controlled other aspects ofclaimant's work, including prohibiting placing foreign materials on or in the publications.Claimant was also provided access to accident insurance from Gannett's policy. In lightof the foregoing, and despite the existence of other evidence in the record suggestive ofan independent contractor relationship—including the distribution agreementexpressly designating claimant as an independent contractor—we find thatsubstantial evidence supports the Board's determination that claimant was an employee(see Matter of Armison [Gannett Co., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 122AD3d at 1101; Matter of Lewis[Absolute Distrib., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 121 AD3d 1488[2014]; Matter of Kelly [FrankGallo, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 28 AD3d 1044, 1045 [2006],lv dismissed 7 NY3d 844 [2006]). Gannett's remaining arguments have beenconsidered and found to be lacking in merit.
Lahtinen, J.P., Garry, Lynch and Clark, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.