| Matter of Gottlieb v City of New York |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 04645 [129 AD3d 724] |
| June 3, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Craig Gottlieb,Appellant, v City of New York, Respondents. |
Craig Gottlieb, Flushing, N.Y., appellant pro se.
Zachary W. Carter, Corporation Counsel, New York, N.Y. (Pamela Seider Dolgowand Elizabeth S. Natrella of counsel), for respondents.
In a hybrid proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of theNew York City Office of Child Support Enforcement dated November 14, 2012,denying, in effect, the petitioner's request for a recalculation of the amount of childsupport debt owed by him, and action to recover damages for violation of the Fair CreditReporting Act (15 USC § 1681 et seq.), intentional infliction ofemotional distress, and gross negligence, and for an injunction, the petitioner appealsfrom an order and judgment (one paper) of the Supreme Court, Queens County(McDonald, J.), dated October 1, 2013, which denied the petition and dismissed theproceeding, and granted the respondents' motion, inter alia, pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) todismiss the causes of action alleging a violation of the Fair Credit Reporting Act,intentional infliction of emotional distress, gross negligence, and for an injunction.
Ordered that the order and judgment is affirmed, with costs.
On January 23, 2009, the wife of the petitioner/plaintiff (hereinafter the petitioner)filed a petition seeking, inter alia, child support from him. On February 24, 2009, aSupport Magistrate entered a temporary order of support directing the petitioner to paychild support in the sum of $100 per week to his wife through the New York StateSupport Collection Unit (hereinafter the SCU), commencing on February 27, 2009. In anorder dated July 7, 2009 (hereinafter the July 2009 order), entered upon consent, thepetitioner was directed to pay the sum of $1,215 per month in combined child andspousal support, payable through the SCU, commencing on July 30, 2009. The July 2009order further provided that the petitioner was "additionally responsible for the support soordered from January 23, 2009 to July 30, 2009," and directed the petitioner to pay thesum of $8,440. The SCU was directed to "[c]redit all payments made [by the petitioner]since 1/23/2009 to reduce the retro amount."
In March 2012, the petitioner admittedly withheld payment and, in April 2012, onlyremitted the sum of $50.79, based on his contention that he was owed a credit by theSCU for payments made by him between February 28, 2009, and July 30, 2009.Enforcement measures were taken by the New York City Human ResourcesAdministration Office of Child Support Enforcement (hereinafter OCSE), including theissuance of restraining notices to two different financial institutions holding thepetitioner's bank accounts. On October 9, 2012, the petitioner submitted a "Mistake ofFact" form to the SCU, claiming that his account was not in arrears and, instead, that[*2]he was "due a credit of $18.08." On November 14,2012, the OCSE denied the petitioner's claim that the SCU "has made an error in theamount of child support debt that is owed," and determined that "there is an amountpast-due and owing."
The petitioner commenced this hybrid proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 toreview the determination dated November 14, 2012, and action to recover damages for aviolation of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 USC § 1681 et seq.),intentional infliction of emotional distress, and gross negligence, and to permanentlyenjoin the respondents/defendants (hereinafter the respondents) from reporting anyderogatory information related to his support collection account to credit reportingagencies, and directing the respondents to take steps necessary to remove any derogatoryinformation from his credit file at the credit reporting agencies. The respondents moved,inter alia, pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) to dismiss the petition/action.
A special proceeding under CPLR article 78 is available to challenge the actions orinaction of agencies and officers of state and local government (see Matter of Luczaj v Bortnik,91 AD3d 872, 873 [2012]). The standard of judicial review in the instant matter iswhether the administrative determination was made in violation of lawful procedure, wasaffected by an error of law, or was arbitrary and capricious or an abuse of discretion(see CPLR 7803 [3]; Matter of JP & Assoc. Corp. v New York State Div. of Hous.& Community Renewal, 122 AD3d 739, 739 [2014]). An arbitrarydetermination is one that is without a sound basis in reason, and is made without regardto the facts (see Matter ofWooley v New York State Dept. of Correctional Servs., 15 NY3d 275, 280[2010]; Matter of Pell v Board of Educ. of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 of Townsof Scarsdale & Mamaroneck, Westchester County, 34 NY2d 222, 231[1974]).
Here, the determination of the OCSE to deny the petitioner's claim that the SCUerred in calculating the amount of past-due support owed by him has a rational basis inthe record, and was, thus, not arbitrary and capricious. The payment history for thepetitioner's support collection account established that, at the time the petitionersubmitted the "Mistake of Fact" form, his account was in arrears. Moreover, the paymenthistory flatly contradicted the petitioner's claim that the payments made by him fromFebruary 2009 until July 2009 were not credited to his account (see Matter of Kirkpatrick vWambua, 117 AD3d 739, 740 [2014]; Ford v Department of SocialServs., 41 Misc 3d 1237[A], 2013 NY Slip Op 52045[U], *7-8 [Sup Ct, NY County2013]; Ward v NYC Human Resources Admin., 2011 NY Slip Op 33162[U][Sup Ct, NY County 2011]; Matter of Ovalles v New York City Human ResourcesAdmin., 2008 NY Slip Op 33635[U], *2-4 [Sup Ct, NY County 2008]). Further,contrary to the petitioner's contention, the OCSE was authorized, upon determining thathis account was in arrears, to attach and seize his assets for the purpose of collecting theoverdue support obligation (see Social Services Law § 111-t; 18NYCRR 346.11), and offset any refund of income tax by the amount of overdue supportowed by him (see 42 USC § 666 [a] [3] [A]; Social Services Law§ 111-b [7], [8]; 18 NYCRR 346.9). Accordingly, the Supreme Courtproperly denied the petition and dismissed the proceeding.
The Supreme Court also properly granted the respondents' motion, inter alia,pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) to dismiss the causes of action alleging violations of the FairCredit Reporting Act, intentional infliction of emotional distress, gross negligence, andfor an injunction. On a motion to dismiss a cause of action pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a)(7), all of the allegations in the pleading are deemed true and the petitioner is affordedthe benefit of every favorable inference (see Matter of Kar-McVeigh, LLC v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Townof Riverhead, 93 AD3d 799, 800 [2012]). Although the facts pleaded arepresumed to be true, "bare legal conclusions as well as factual claims flatly contradictedby the record are not entitled to any such consideration" (Riback v Margulis, 43 AD3d1023, 1023 [2007]).
The substance of the cause of action alleging a violation of the Fair Credit ReportingAct was, in essence, a challenge to the determination by the OCSE that the petitioner'saccount was in arrears, which authorized the OCSE, pursuant to Social Services Law§§ 111-b, 111-c and 111-t, to take enforcement action and report hisarrears to the credit reporting agencies. This cause of action essentially constituted arequest for relief pursuant to CPLR article 78, regardless of the form in which it waspleaded and, thus, was properly dismissed (see Hertzel v Town of Putnam Val., 121 AD3d 641,643-644 [2014]; Kickertz vNew York Univ., 110 AD3d 268, 272 [2013]).
[*3] "[P]ublic policy bars claims sounding in intentionalinfliction of emotional distress against a governmental entity" (Lauer v City of NewYork, 240 AD2d 543, 544 [1997]; see Dillon v City of New York, 261 AD2d34, 41 [1999]). Here, the individual respondents were only sued in their officialcapacities. Therefore, the petitioner could not and did not state a cause of action againstthem for intentional infliction of emotional distress. Accordingly, that branch of therespondents' motion which was to dismiss this cause of action was properly granted.
Finally, the Supreme Court properly granted those branches of the respondents'motion which were to dismiss causes of action alleging gross negligence and forinjunctive relief. Even if the allegations contained in the petition are assumed to be true,they do not state a cause of action to recover damages for gross negligence or supportingthe issuance of a permanent injunction (see Vilella v AT&T, 35 Misc 3d 1224[A], 2012 NYSlip Op 50853[U], *10 [Sup Ct, NY County 2012]; Josey v Sallie Mae, Inc.,2009 WL 2518643, *8, 2009 US Dist LEXIS 72157, *24-25 [SD NY, Aug. 17, 2009,No. 09 Civ. 4403 (SHS) (AJP)]). Rivera, J.P., Dickerson, Chambers and Barros, JJ.,concur.