| Matter of Ingle (Mechanical Secretary,Inc.—Commissioner of Labor) |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 05553 [129 AD3d 1424] |
| June 25, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of the Claim of Barbara B. Ingle,Respondent. The Mechanical Secretary, Inc., Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent. |
Roy Jacobs & Associates, New York City (Roy L. Jacobs of counsel), forappellant.
Cynthia Feathers, Glens Falls, for Barbara B. Ingle, respondent.
Lynch, J. Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board,filed January 10, 2014, which ruled, among other things, that The Mechanical Secretary,Inc. was liable for unemployment insurance contributions based on remuneration paid toclaimant and others similarly situated.
Claimant was a transcriber of administrative hearing tapes for The MechanicalSecretary, Inc., a company that provides various transcription services for its clients. Byinitial determination, the Department of Labor granted claimant's application forunemployment insurance benefits. Following a hearing, an Administrative Law Judgefound claimant to be an independent contractor and overruled the initial determination.Ultimately, the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board ruled, among other things, thatan employer-employee relationship existed between The Mechanical Secretary andclaimant and those similarly situated and that The Mechanical Secretary was liable foradditional unemployment contributions based upon remuneration paid to thosetranscribers. This appeal ensued.
"Whether an employment relationship exists within the meaning of theunemployment insurance law is a question of fact, no one factor is determinative and thedetermination of the [Board], if supported by substantial evidence on the record as awhole, is beyond further judicial [*2]review even thoughthere is evidence in the record that would have supported a contrary conclusion"(Matter of Concourse Ophthalmology Assoc. [Roberts], 60 NY2d 734, 736[1983] [citation omitted]). "An employer-employee relationship exists when the evidenceshows that the employer exercises control over the results produced or the means used toachieve the results" (Matter ofEmpire State Towing & Recovery Assn., Inc. [Commissioner of Labor], 15NY3d 433, 437 [2010] [citation omitted]). Here, the record establishes that TheMechanical Secretary advertised for transcriber positions. The president would interviewthe applicants and assess the quality of their work. The transcriber was required to havecertain equipment, but The Mechanical Secretary would loan the transcriber atranscription machine if needed. The Mechanical Secretary arranged to have the workdelivered to and picked up from the transcribers within a certain area. In claimant's case,however, because she did not live in close proximity to the company, she was required topick her work up at its office and to return the completed work to that office by 9:00 a.m.Claimant was occasionally reimbursed for her travel expenses. Significantly, TheMechanical Secretary set the nonnegotiable pay rate, supplied all the paper needed by thetranscribers, and reviewed the final product for mistakes and would correct any minormistakes or, where the mistakes were significant, send it back to be corrected by thetranscriber. Furthermore, The Mechanical Secretary had to be notified if a transcriberwas going to take any vacation. Given the evidence produced, we find that there issubstantial evidence to support the Board's finding that The Mechanical Secretaryexercised a sufficient degree of control over claimant's work to establish an employmentrelationship (see Matter ofAmoroso [Laraine T. Carmichael, Ltd.—Commissioner of Labor], 22 AD3d940, 942 [2005]; Matter of Medical Transcription Plus [Commissioner ofLabor], 302 AD2d 689, 690 [2003]; Matter of Bailey [Remee Prods.Corp.—Roberts], 132 AD2d 820, 821 [1987]).
We are unpersuaded by The Mechanical Secretary's contention that the Board wasbound by a prior unappealed Administrative Law Judge decision that found medicaltranscribers that it had used to be independent contractors. Claimant, who is not amedical transcriber, was not involved in that prior proceeding such that there was a fulland fair opportunity for her to contest the decision, nor is the Board "required to conformto the precedent established in the prior unappealed decision or offer a rationalexplanation for not doing so" (Matter of Bull [Yansick Lbr.Co.—Sweeney], 235 AD2d 722, 723 [1997], lv dismissed 90 NY2d913 [1997]). In any event, the record before us discloses that The Mechanical Secretaryexercised additional indicia of control over claimant's work not found with regard to themedical transcribers.
Peters, P.J., Lahtinen and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is affirmed,without costs.