| Matter of Dawley v Whitetail 414, LLC |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 06082 [130 AD3d 1570] |
| July 10, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Desiree Dawley et al.,Appellants, v Whitetail 414, LLC, et al.,Respondents. |
Hodgson Russ LLP, Buffalo (Daniel A. Spitzer of counsel), forpetitioners-appellants.
Harris Beach PLLC, Pittsford (John A. Mancuso of counsel), forrespondents-respondents Whitetail 414, LLC, Wilmorite, Inc., James Leonard and JeanneLeonard.
Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC, Syracuse (Thomas R. Smith of counsel), forrespondent-respondent Town of Tyre Town Board.
Appeal from a judgment (denominated order and judgment) of the Supreme Court,Seneca County (W. Patrick Falvey, A.J.), entered September 18, 2014 in a CPLR article78 proceeding. The judgment dismissed the petition.
It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is reversed on the lawwithout costs, and the petition is granted.
Memorandum: Petitioners commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding seeking,inter alia, to annul the negative declaration issued by respondent Town of Tyre TownBoard (Town Board) on June 12, 2014 under the State Environmental Quality ReviewAct ([SEQRA] ECL art 8) with respect to the proposed construction of the Lago Resortand Casino. Respondents filed answers seeking dismissal of the petition. Followingadditional written submissions and oral argument, Supreme Court dismissed the petition.We conclude that the court erred in doing so, and we therefore reverse.
We agree with petitioners that the negative declaration issued on June 12, 2014failed to contain a written "reasoned elaboration" as required by Department ofEnvironmental Conservation Regulations (6 NYCRR) § 617.7 (b) (4).Although the Town Board issued the negative declaration at the June 12, 2014 meeting,the record establishes that special counsel for the Town of Tyre subsequently prepared anattachment entitled "Reasons Supporting the Determination of Significance in Part 3 ofFull Environmental Assessment Form." According to submissions made by specialcounsel in support of respondents' answers seeking dismissal of the petition, theattachment was prepared to "explain[ ] the findings made by the Town Board at themeeting and the rationale for the Negative Declaration." Notably, the attachment was notprovided to the members of the Town Board until July 11, 2014. Moreover, the recordestablishes that the Town Board has never passed a resolution approving and/or adoptingthe attachment as part of its negative declaration. Nonetheless, respondents contend, andthe court agreed, that there was compliance with SEQRA's procedural mandates. Wereject that contention.
[*2] It is well settled thatSEQRA's procedural mechanisms mandate strict compliance, and anything less willresult in annulment of the lead agency's determination of significance (see Matter ofKing v Saratoga County Bd. of Supervisors, 89 NY2d 341, 347 [1996]). "[L]iteralrather than substantial compliance with SEQRA is required" (Matter of Badura vGuelli, 94 AD2d 972, 972 [1983]; see Matter of Tupper v City of Syracuse, 46 AD3d 1343,1344 [2007], lv denied 10 NY3d 709 [2008]). Here, 6 NYCRR 617.7 (b) (4)requires that, in making the determination of significance, the lead agency—in thiscase the Town Board—must "set forth its determination of significance in awritten form containing a reasoned elaboration and providing reference to any supportingdocumentation." We conclude that the intent of the regulation is to focus and facilitatejudicial review and, of no lesser importance, to provide affected landowners andresidents with a clear, written explanation of the lead agency's reasoning at the time thenegative declaration is made. We reject respondents' contention that we should search theentire record to discern the Town Board's reasoning as of June 12, 2014 in making thedetermination to issue the negative declaration. "A record evincing an extensivelegislative process . . . is neither a substitute for strict compliance withSEQRA's [written] reasoned elaboration requirement nor sufficient to preventannulment" (Matter of TroySand & Gravel Co., Inc. v Town of Nassau, 82 AD3d 1377, 1379 [2011]).We therefore reverse the judgment and grant the petition, thereby annulling the negativedeclaration and vacating the site plan approval and all related resolutions.
In light of our determination, we do not address petitioners' remaining contentions.Carni and DeJoseph, JJ., concur.
Centra, J.P., concurs in the following memorandum.
Centra, J.P. (concurring). I agree with the majority that Supreme Court erred indismissing the petition, but I write separately because, in my view, a transcript of ahearing may in certain circumstances satisfy the requirement that a lead agency "set forthits determination of significance in a written form containing a reasoned elaboration andproviding reference to any supporting documentation" (Department of EnvironmentalConservation Regulations [6 NYCRR] § 617.7 [b] [4]; see Matter of Coursen v PlanningBd. of Town of Pompey, 37 AD3d 1159, 1160 [2007]). Under thecircumstances of this case, however, the transcript from the June 12, 2014 meeting didnot satisfy the requirements of 6 NYCRR 617.7 (b) (4). The transcript of the meetingshows that some of the responses of the members of respondent Town of Tyre TownBoard were equivocal, and thus in my view the lead agency's determination ofsignificance is not supported by the requisite reasoned elaboration.
Valentino, J., dissents and votes to affirm in the following memorandum.
Valentino, J. (dissenting). I respectfully dissent. I disagree with the majority'sconclusion that respondent Town of Tyre Town Board (Town Board) failed to complystrictly with SEQRA's procedural mandates. To the contrary, I conclude that the TownBoard's determination was made in accordance with lawful procedure (see Akpan vKoch, 75 NY2d 561, 570 [1990]; Matter of Forman v Trustees of State Univ. ofN.Y., 303 AD2d 1019, 1020 [2003]) and, thus, that Supreme Court properlydismissed the petition. I would therefore affirm the judgment.
The transcript from the June 12, 2014 meeting satisfied the requirement for "awritten form containing a reasoned elaboration" for the Town Board's determination ofno significant adverse environmental impacts (Department of EnvironmentalConservation Regulations [6 NYCRR] § 617.7 [b] [4]; see Matter of Residents AgainstWal-Mart v Planning Bd. of Town of Greece, 60 AD3d 1343, 1344 [2009],lv denied 12 NY3d 715 [2009]; Matter of Coursen v Planning Bd. of Town of Pompey, 37AD3d 1159, 1160 [2007]). Here, the information contained in the attachmentreferenced by the majority was addressed—in much the same language—atthe June 12, 2014 meeting, as were other documents created prior to that meeting. Theminutes from the June 12, 2014 meeting establish that each of the 10 areas that wereidentified as having at least one potentially moderate to large impact were discussed atlength before the Town Board members found no significant adverse environmentalimpacts. In my view, those minutes demonstrate that the Town Board "identified therelevant areas of environmental concern, took a hard look at them, and made a reasonedelaboration of the basis for its determination" (Matter of New York City Coalition toEnd Lead Poisoning v Vallone, 100 NY2d 337, 348 [2003] [internal quotation marksomitted]). Present—Centra, J.P., Carni, Valentino and DeJoseph, JJ.