| Matter of Broadie v Annucci |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 06863 [131 AD3d 1324] |
| September 17, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Osbourne Broadie,Appellant, v Anthony J. Annucci, as Acting Commissioner of Corrections andCommunity Supervision, Respondent. |
Matthew McGowan, Prisoners' Legal Services of New York, Albany, forappellant.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Peter H. Schiff of counsel), forrespondent.
Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Platkin, J.), entered July 1, 2014 inAlbany County, which dismissed petitioner's application, in a proceeding pursuant toCPLR article 78, to review a determination of respondent finding petitioner guilty ofviolating certain prison disciplinary rules.
A correction officer observed petitioner approach another inmate in the plumbingshop and repeatedly strike the inmate in the head with a pipe wrench. As a result,petitioner was charged in a misbehavior report with refusing a direct order, assaulting aninmate, engaging in violent conduct and possessing a weapon. Petitioner requestedvarious witnesses to testify at the tier III disciplinary hearing, including two inmates whowere allegedly present in the plumbing shop at the time of the incident. Prior to thecommencement of the hearing, petitioner's employee assistant informed him that bothinmates refused to testify. Although petitioner acknowledged this during the hearing, hemaintained that he wanted his assistant to obtain written statements from these inmatessetting forth their reasons for not testifying. The Hearing Officer agreed to have staffquestion these inmates and, if they still refused to testify, to ascertain their reasons. Laterin the hearing, the Hearing Officer reported that a correction officer had questioned thesewitnesses and obtained refusal forms indicating that they would not testify because theydid not want to get involved. At the conclusion of the hearing, petitioner was foundguilty of assaulting an inmate, engaging in violent conduct and possessing a weapon. Thepenalty was subsequently modified and the determination was upheld on administrativeappeal with the modified penalty. Petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78 [*2]proceeding challenging the determination on the basis thathe was improperly denied the right to have the two inmate witnesses testify at thehearing. Following joinder of issue, Supreme Court dismissed the petition. Petitionernow appeals.
Petitioner's sole contention is that he was deprived of his constitutional andregulatory right to call witnesses insofar as the record is insufficient concerning thereasons for the inmates' refusals to testify and the Hearing Officer did not conduct anadequate inquiry with respect thereto. We are not persuaded. This Court has held thatwhere a requested inmate witness has not previously agreed to testify and the reason forthe inmate's refusal appears on the record, such as in a witness refusal form, there is noviolation of the conditional right to call witnesses (see Matter of Cortorreal v Annucci, 123 AD3d 1337, 1338[2014], lv granted 25 NY3d 961 [2015]; see also Matter of Hill v Selsky, 19 AD3d 64, 66-67[2005]). Indeed, in such circumstances, even where the reason that appears on the recordis the inmate's desire not to be involved, this Court has declined to find a violation (see Matter of Tafari v Fischer,78 AD3d 1405, 1406 [2010], lv denied 16 NY3d 704 [2011]; Matter ofBoyd v Selsky, 232 AD2d 929, 929-930 [1996]). Notwithstanding petitioner'ssuggestion to the contrary, our decisions are consistent with the Court of Appeals'holding in Matter of Barnes v LeFevre (69 NY2d 649 [1986]). Moreover,although a Hearing Officer bears a greater responsibility to conduct a further inquiry intothe legitimacy of a refusal where the witness previously agreed to testify, but laterchanged his or her mind (seeMatter of Abdur-Raheem v Prack, 98 AD3d 1152, 1153 [2012]), that is not thesituation here. Therefore, Supreme Court properly concluded that petitioner's right to callwitnesses was not violated.
Peters, P.J., McCarthy, Garry and Clark, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment isaffirmed, without costs.