| Matter of Falcon Group Ltd. Liab. Co. v Town/Village ofHarrison Planning Bd. |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 07025 [131 AD3d 1237] |
| September 30, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Falcon Group Limited LiabilityCompany, Respondent, v Town/Village of Harrison Planning Board,Appellant. |
Friedman Harfenist Kraut & Perlstein, LLP, Lake Success, N.Y. (Steven J.Harfenist, Leo Napior, and Neil Torczyner of counsel), for appellant.
Hocherman Tortorella & Wekstein, LLP, White Plains, N.Y. (Adam L.Wekstein and Geraldine N. Tortorella of counsel), for respondent.
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, inter alia, to review a determination ofthe Town/Village of Harrison Planning Board dated February 28, 2012, adopting afindings statement pursuant to the State Environmental Quality Review Act (ECL art 8),in connection with an application for subdivision approval, the Town/Village of HarrisonPlanning Board appeals, as limited by its brief, from so much of a judgment of theSupreme Court, Westchester County (Adler, J.), dated April 12, 2013, as granted thatbranch of the petition of Falcon Group Limited Liability Company which was to annulthe findings statement and remitted the matter to the Town/Village of Harrison PlanningBoard for the issuance of a new findings statement that is consistent with a certain FinalEnvironmental Impact Statement.
Ordered that the judgment is affirmed insofar as appealed from, without costs ordisbursements.
The petitioner, Falcon Group Limited Liability Company (hereinafter Falcon), ownsan undeveloped 14.62-acre parcel of land in the Town of Harrison. The property is in anR-1 zoning district, in which single-family homes on one-acre lots are permitted. In May2005, Falcon submitted an application to the Town/Village of Harrison Planning Board(hereinafter the Board) for approval to subdivide the property into 13 single-familybuilding lots and a 14th lot for stormwater detention. The project would requireimprovement of a paper street and construction of an emergency access road. It wouldalso require a waiver of the cul-de-sac length requirements of the Town/Village's zoningordinance and steep slope and wetlands permits.
The Board declared itself the lead agency under the State Environmental QualityReview Act (ECL art 8 [hereinafter SEQRA]) and adopted a positive declaration findingthat the site was significantly constrained by the presence of steep slopes, wetlands, astream, and subsurface conditions. A public scoping session was held and a draftenvironmental review statement (hereinafter DEIS) was prepared which included severalalternative development plans. The Board accepted the DEIS as complete on March 25,2008. Public hearings were held on the DEIS, which was then revised to incorporate afurther alternative plan. Additional public hearings were held, and a final environmentalimpact statement (hereinafter FEIS) was prepared. The Board accepted the [*2]FEIS as complete on September 27, 2011. The FEISincluded two new alternatives which would reduce the density of the project and many ofthe environmental impacts.
After a public hearing on the FEIS, the Board adopted a findings statement pursuantto SEQRA on February 28, 2012. The Board found that the proposed action, as well asthe various alternative development plans, did not minimize or avoid adverseenvironmental effects to the maximum extent practicable, and would result in significantadverse environmental impacts that could not be avoided. Falcon commenced this CPLRarticle 78 proceeding seeking, inter alia, to annul the findings statement on the groundsthat it contradicted conclusions reached in the FEIS and DEIS and was not supported byempirical evidence in the record before the Board. The Supreme Court, inter alia, grantedthat branch of the petition which was to annul the findings statement and remitted thematter to the Board for the issuance of a new findings statement that is consistent withthe FEIS. The Board appeals from that portion of the judgment.
Judicial review of an agency determination under SEQRA is limited to whether theagency procedures were lawful and "whether the agency identified the relevant areas ofenvironmental concern, took a 'hard look' at them, and made a 'reasoned elaboration' ofthe basis for its determination" (Matter of Jackson v New York State Urban Dev.Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 417 [1986], quoting Aldrich v Pattison, 107 AD2d 258,265 [1985]; see Matter ofRiverkeeper, Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town of Southeast, 9 NY3d 219, 231-232[2007]). "In a statutory scheme whose purpose is that the agency decision-makers focusattention on environmental concerns, it is not the role of the courts to weigh thedesirability of any action or choose among alternatives, but to assure that the agencyitself has satisfied SEQRA, procedurally and substantively" (Matter of Jackson vNew York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d at 416). The agency decision should beannulled only if it is arbitrary, capricious, or unsupported by the evidence (see Matterof Riverkeeper, Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town of Southeast, 9 NY3d at 232).
"The purpose of an environmental impact statement is to provide detailedinformation about the effect which a proposed action is likely to have on theenvironment, to list ways in which any adverse effects of such an action might beminimized, and to suggest alternatives to such an action so as to form the basis for adecision whether or not to undertake or approve such action" (ECL 8-0109 [2]). In afindings statement, the lead agency "considers the relevant environmental impactspresented in an EIS, weighs and balances them with social, economic and other essentialconsiderations, provides a rationale for the agency's decision and certifies that theSEQRA requirements have been met" (6 NYCRR 617.2 [p]; see Matter of WEOKBroadcasting Corp. v Planning Bd. of Town of Lloyd, 79 NY2d 373, 380 [1992]).Agencies have considerable latitude in evaluating environmental effects and choosingbetween alternatives (see Akpan v Koch, 75 NY2d 561, 570 [1990]).
While an agency's ultimate conclusion is within the discretion of the agency, it mustbe based upon factual evidence in the record and not generalized, speculative communityobjections (see Matter of WEOK Broadcasting Corp. v Planning Bd. of Town ofLloyd, 79 NY2d at 384-385). "While an EIS does not require a public agency to actin any particular manner, it constitutes evidence which must be considered by the publicagency along with other evidence which may be presented to such agency" (Matter ofTown of Henrietta v Department of Envtl. Conservation of State of N.Y., 76 AD2d215, 222 [1980]).
Here, the Supreme Court properly annulled the Board's findings statement asunsupported by the evidence. The Board was required to render its conclusions regardingthe sufficiency of mitigation measures, the propriety of permit approvals, and a balancingof considerations, based on the evidence contained in the environmental review. TheBoard's conclusions in the findings statement were based, at least in part, on factualfindings which were contradicted by the scientific and technical analyses included in theFEIS and not otherwise supported by empirical evidence in the record (see Matter of Kinderhook Dev.,LLC v City of Gloversville Planning Bd., 88 AD3d 1207 [2011]; Matter ofErnalex Constr. Realty Corp. v Bellissimo, 256 AD2d 338 [1998]).
The findings statement also failed to give sufficient consideration to the various[*3]alternative plans reviewed in the FEIS (seeECL 8-0109 [2] [d], [f]; Matter of Rye Town/King Civic Assn. v Town ofRye, 82 AD2d 474, 481 [1981]). While the findings statement discussed thealternatives that involved clustering the development into a smaller area, it did notaddress the reduced-density alternative set forth in the FEIS, which was not a clusteralternative and which reduced many of the environmental impacts of the original plan.Accordingly, the Supreme Court properly granted that branch of the petition which wasto annul the findings statement and remitted the matter to the Board for the issuance of afindings statement that is consistent with the FEIS.
The Board's remaining contention is not properly before this Court (see Matter of Kahn v Planning Bd.of City of Buffalo, 60 AD3d 1451 [2009]). Dillon, J.P., Chambers, Hall andDuffy, JJ., concur.