People v Hubbard
2015 NY Slip Op 07858 [132 AD3d 1013]
October 28, 2015
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 9, 2015


[*1]
 The People of the State of New York,Appellant,
v
Gabriel Hubbard, Respondent.

Thomas J. Spota, District Attorney, Riverhead, N.Y. (Glenn Green of counsel), forappellant.

Robert C. Mitchell, Riverhead, N.Y. (Louis E. Mazzola of counsel), forrespondent.

Appeal by the People from an order of the Supreme Court, Suffolk County (Efman,J.), dated July 25, 2014, which granted the defendant's motion pursuant to CPL 440.10 tovacate a judgment of the County Court, Suffolk County (Efman, J.), rendered June 7,2012, convicting him of murder in the second degree, upon a jury verdict, and imposingsentence, and directed a new trial.

Ordered that the order is affirmed.

The Supreme Court properly granted the defendant's motion pursuant to CPL 440.10to vacate the judgment for violation of Brady v Maryland (373 US 83 [1963]),and directed a new trial. The People have an obligation to disclose exculpatory evidencein their possession that is favorable to the defendant and material to his or her guilt orinnocence (see id. at 87; People v Fuentes, 12 NY3d 259, 263 [2009]; People vScott, 88 NY2d 888, 890 [1996]). "The prosecutor's duty to exchange Bradymaterial extends to the disclosure of evidence that can be used to impeach thecredibility of a witness for the People whose testimony may be determinative of thedefendant's guilt" (People vWagstaffe, 120 AD3d 1361, 1363 [2014]; see Giglio v United States,405 US 150, 154-155 [1972]; People v Baxley, 84 NY2d 208, 213 [1994]). Inorder to establish a Brady violation, a defendant must prove: (1) the evidence atissue is favorable to him or her, (2) the evidence was suppressed by the prosecution,either willfully or inadvertently, and (3) prejudice arose because the suppressed evidencewas material (see Strickler v Greene, 527 US 263, 281-282 [1999]; People v Garrett, 23 NY3d878, 885 [2014]; People vHayes, 17 NY3d 46, 50 [2011]).

Here, the crucial evidence against the defendant at trial was his statement admittingto the shooting, taken by Detective Ronald Tavares. There was no physical evidenceconnecting the defendant to the crime, and the eyewitnesses could not identify him.Given the importance of Detective Tavares' testimony in establishing the defendant'sguilt, the Supreme Court properly determined that evidence concerning allegations thathe had procured a false confession in an unrelated matter involving two police officers,which led to an internal affairs investigation of those officers and a federal lawsuitagainst, among others, Detective Tavares, was favorable to the defense and material(see People v Garrett, 23 NY3d at 886; People v Ennis, 11 NY3d 403, 414 [2008]; People vJones, 193 AD2d 696 [1993]). The evidence was responsive to a defense demandand there is a reasonable [*2]possibility that the outcomeof the trial would have differed had the evidence been produced (see People vEnnis, 11 NY3d at 414; People v Scott, 88 NY2d 888, 891 [1996]; cf.People v Garrett, 23 NY3d at 892). Furthermore, the defendant sufficientlyestablished that the prosecutor had actual knowledge of the allegations against DetectiveTavares and the related investigation in the unrelated matter (see generally People vSantorelli, 95 NY2d 412, 421 [2000]; People v Simmons, 36 NY2d 126, 132[1975]; cf. People v Garrett, 23 NY3d at 891). Hall, J.P., Sgroi, Cohen andMaltese, JJ., concur. [Prior Case History: 45 Misc 3d 328.]


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.