| Ballesteros v Ballesteros |
| 2016 NY Slip Op 01450 [137 AD3d 722] |
| March 2, 2016 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| Daniela Ballesteros, Respondent, v RobertBallesteros, Appellant. |
Soto Sanchez & Negron, LLP, Yonkers, NY (Wilson Soto of counsel), forappellant.
Daniel M. Miller, PLLC, Mahopac, NY, for respondent.
Appeal from a judgment of divorce of the Supreme Court, Putnam County (FrancisA. Nicolai, J.), dated January 15, 2014. The judgment, insofar as appealed from, upon adecision dated December 13, 2013, made after a framed-issue hearing, awarded theplaintiff the principal sum of $250,000.
Ordered that the judgment is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the law, withcosts, and the matter is remitted to the Supreme Court, Putnam County, for the entry ofan appropriate amended judgment in accordance herewith.
The parties were married on July 27, 2008. Prior to the marriage, on July 23, 2008,the parties signed a prenuptial agreement "opting-out" of New York's statutory schemegoverning maintenance and equitable distribution. Thereafter, in the summer of 2009, thehusband told the wife he wanted a divorce and she needed to leave his home. The wifebegan looking for a place to live. The husband then changed his mind and told the wifehe did not want to get divorced and that they should try to resolve their problems. Thewife did not want to get divorced and told the husband she was willing to work on theirmarriage but she needed financial security from him. The husband agreed to sign adocument entitled "Promissory Note" in which he agreed to purchase a condominium forthe wife, in the event of a divorce, in an amount not less than $250,000. The wife draftedthe agreement, and both she and the husband signed it on September 3, 2009. Thehusband told the wife he would return the agreement to her after he had it notarized. Anotary signed the agreement but did not attach a certificate of acknowledgment.
The parties continued to work on their marriage, but at some point thereafter, thehusband again asked the wife to leave his home. The wife commenced this action onJune 14, 2012, inter alia, for a divorce and ancillary relief, and to enforce the promissorynote.
The Supreme Court held a framed-issue hearing to determine whether the agreementwas enforceable. After the hearing, the court issued a decision dated December 13, 2013,which held that the document entitled "Promissory Note" was an enforceable agreement,and directed the husband to pay the wife $250,000. Judgment was entered upon thecourt's decision and in [*2]accordance with the prenuptialagreement and a stipulation of settlement dated December 30, 2013. The husbandappeals from so much of the judgment as awarded the wife the principal sum of$250,000.
Contrary to the wife's contention, the agreement signed by the parties, despite its titleof a "Promissory Note," was an agreement between spouses subject to DomesticRelations Law § 236 (B) (3). Pursuant to Domestic Relations Law§ 236 (B) (3), "[a]n agreement by the parties, made before or during themarriage, shall be valid and enforceable in a matrimonial action if such agreement is inwriting, subscribed by the parties, and acknowledged or proven in the manner required toentitle a deed to be recorded." A written agreement between parties made before orduring a marriage which does not meet the formalities of Domestic Relations Law§ 236 (B) (3) is not enforceable (see Galetta v Galetta, 21 NY3d 186, 192 [2013];Matisoff v Dobi, 90 NY2d 127, 130 [1997]; Rio v Rio, 110 AD3d 1051, 1053 [2013]). Therefore, apostnuptial agreement that is signed but not acknowledged is invalid and unenforceablein a matrimonial action (see Galetta v Galetta, 21 NY3d at 192; Matisoff vDobi, 90 NY2d at 135; Rio v Rio, 110 AD3d at 1053). Here, although thepostnuptial agreement was signed by a notary public, it is uncontroverted that it was notproperly acknowledged. Therefore, the agreement is unenforceable (see Galetta vGaletta, 21 NY3d at 192; Matisoff v Dobi, 90 NY2d at 135; D'Elia v D'Elia, 14 AD3d477, 478 [2005]).
The wife's remaining contentions are without merit. Dillon, J.P., Dickerson, Cohenand Duffy, JJ., concur.