| John G. Ullman & Assoc., Inc. v BCK Partners,Inc. |
| 2016 NY Slip Op 03611 [139 AD3d 1358] |
| May 6, 2016 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1]
| John G. Ullman & Associates, Inc., Respondent, vBCK Partners, Inc., et al., Appellants. |
Leclair Korona Giordano Cole, LLP, Rochester (Steven E. Cole of counsel), fordefendants-appellants.
Hinman, Howard & Kattell, LLP, Binghamton (Jeanette N. Warren of counsel),for plaintiff-respondent.
Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Steuben County (Peter C. Bradstreet,A.J.), entered July 21, 2015. The order granted the motion of plaintiff for a preliminaryinjunction.
It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously reversed on thelaw without costs, the motion is denied and the preliminary injunction is vacated.
Memorandum: Plaintiff, a financial services firm, commenced this action seeking toenforce restrictive covenants in an employment agreement signed by the individualdefendants when they were hired by plaintiff. Approximately one month before theyresigned from their employment with plaintiff, the individual defendants formed theirnew venture, defendant BCK Partners, Inc. (BCK Partners). After submitting theirresignations, the individual defendants publicly announced that BCK Partners wouldestablish a permanent office to provide financial services on the same street as plaintiff.Plaintiff thereafter moved for a preliminary injunction enjoining defendants fromoffering financial services within 50 miles of plaintiff's office, soliciting plaintiff'sclients, and disclosing plaintiff's proprietary information, all allegedly pursuant to therestrictive covenants in the individual defendants' employment agreements. We concludethat Supreme Court erred in granting plaintiff's motion.
It is well settled that " '[p]reliminary injunctive relief is a drastic remedy[that] is not routinely granted' " (Sutherland Global Servs., Inc. v Stuewe, 73 AD3d 1473,1474 [2010]). "In order to prevail on a motion for a preliminary injunction, the movingparty has the burden of demonstrating, by clear and convincing evidence, (1) a likelihoodof success on the merits, (2) irreparable injury in the absence of injunctive relief, and (3)a balance of equities in its favor" (Eastman Kodak Co. v Carmosino, 77 AD3d 1434, 1435[2010]). Here, we conclude that plaintiff failed to establish by clear and convincingevidence either a likelihood of success on the merits or irreparable injury.
With respect to plaintiff's likelihood of success on the merits, we conclude thatplaintiff failed to establish that the restrictive covenants at issue were necessary to protectits legitimate business interests, or that the individual defendants provide "unique orextraordinary" services (Riedman Corp. v Gallager, 48 AD3d 1188, 1189 [2008];see generally BDO Seidman v Hirshberg, 93 NY2d 382, 389 [1999]). Withrespect to irreparable injury, plaintiff asserted in support of the motion that it wouldsuffer some unspecified damage to its "goodwill and reputation," and those conclusoryallegations "do not establish that irreparable harm will result in the absence of injunctiverelief" (A. John Merola, M.D., P. C. v Telonis, 127 AD2d 1007, 1007 [1987]). Itis also unclear from this record whether the "goodwill" relating to the clients who havetransferred their business from plaintiff to defendants belongs to plaintiff or theindividual defendants (see BDO [*2]Seidman, 93NY2d at 393; Riedman Corp., 48 AD3d at 1190; Scott, Stackrow & Co.,C.P.A.'s, P.C. v Skavina, 9 AD3d 805, 806 [2004], lv denied 3 NY3d612 [2004]). Nor did plaintiff establish that it would not have "an adequate remedy in theform of monetary damages" and thus would suffer irreparable injury in the absence of apreliminary injunction (DestinyUSA Holdings, LLC v Citigroup Global Mkts. Realty Corp., 69 AD3d 212, 220[2009]), even if the monetary damages in this case are capable of calculation only "withsome difficulty" (SportsChannel Am. Assoc. v National Hockey League, 186AD2d 417, 418 [1992]). Present—Whalen, P.J., Peradotto, Lindley, NeMoyer andScudder, JJ.