| Barbes Rest. Inc. v ASRR Suzer 218, LLC |
| 2016 NY Slip Op 04331 [140 AD3d 430] |
| June 7, 2016 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1]
| Barbes Restaurant Inc., Respondent, v ASRRSuzer 218, LLC, Appellant. |
Pryor Cashman LLP, New York (Todd E. Soloway of counsel), for appellant.
David Rozenholc & Associates, New York (Steven L. Schultz of counsel), forrespondent.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Manuel J. Mendez, J.), entered November6, 2015, which granted plaintiff's motion for a preliminary injunction tolling theexpiration of a demolition notice served by defendant and enjoining defendant fromterminating its tenancy or assessing a penalty for each day that it remains in occupancy,unanimously affirmed, without costs.
Pursuant to a lease and rider dated November 17, 2003, plaintiff leased the one-storycommercial space, located at 19-21 East 36th Street in Manhattan (19-21), fromdefendant's predecessor in interest. Pursuant to a March 31, 2009 modification, the leaseterm was extended through March 31, 2019. Over the course of its tenancy, plaintiffinvested approximately $1,000,000 in improvements to the restaurant that it operates atthe premises.
In February 2015, defendant purchased 218 Madison Avenue, which consists of19-21 and the adjacent five-story building, which has residential space and twocommercial tenants. Defendant states that it purchased 218 Madison intending toredevelop it, and that after the purchase it began to consider options which included: (i)demolishing 19-21 and erecting a new structure in its place which would connect to anew structure built on top of the adjacent building and (ii) demolishing both 19-21 andthe adjacent building and erecting a new building.
On April 28, 2015, plaintiff was served with a demolition notice, which advised it ofdefendant's "election to demolish the area of the Building" where its restaurant waslocated, pursuant to section 79 of the lease rider. Section 79(A) provides in relevant partthat "[t]he parties understand and agree that if Landlord has a bona fide intention todemolish or alter the Building or the area of the Building in which the Demised Premisesis located, then and in such event Landlord may cancel the unexpired portion of the termof this Lease . . . upon not less than six (6) months prior written notice toTenant."
Two days prior to the cancellation date of October 31, 2015, plaintiff commencedthis action seeking a declaratory judgment as to the legal validity of the demolition noticeand the enforceability of section 79 (C) of the lease rider, under which defendant mayassess a $5,000 per diem penalty against plaintiff for each day it remains on the premisesafter the cancellation date. Plaintiff also sought preliminary and permanent injunctiverelief.
The grant of the preliminary injunction tolling the cancellation date and theimposition of the $5,000 per diem penalty was not an improvident exercise of discretion(see Gilliland v AcquafreddaEnters., LLC, 92 AD3d 19, 24-25 [1st Dept 2011]). Plaintiff met its burden ofdemonstrating "a probability of success on the merits, danger of irreparable injury in theabsence of an injunction and a balance of equities in its favor" (Nobu Next Door, LLC v Fine ArtsHous., Inc., 4 NY3d 839, 840 [2005]; CPLR 6301).
To establish a likelihood of success on the merits, "[a] prima facie showing of areasonable probability of success is sufficient; actual proof of the petitioners' claimsshould be left to a full hearing on the merits" (Weissman v Kubasek, 112 AD2d1086, 1086 [2d Dept 1985]; see also Demartini v Chatham Green, 169 AD2d 689[1st Dept 1991]). A likelihood of success [*2]on themerits may be sufficiently established even where the facts are in dispute and theevidence need not be conclusive (see Four Times Sq. Assoc. v Cigna Invs., 306AD2d 4, 5 [1st Dept 2003]).
Here, plaintiff established prima facie that, at the time the demolition notice wasserved, defendant lacked "a bona fide intention to demolish" the building or area of thebuilding where its restaurant was located, as required by section 79 (A) of the lease rider(Four Times Sq. Assoc. at 5-6). Up through the commencement of this action,defendant had not filed a demolition application with the Department of Buildings, and,although it had retained architectural and engineering firms to prepare architecturaldrawings, and had conducted geological and structural tests, its plans were still in theearly stages and it was still evaluating different redevelopment options (seeOriburger, Inc. v B.W.H.N.V. Assoc., 305 AD2d 275, 279 [1st Dept 2003]).Significantly, the drawings on which defendant relies are all dated September 11, 2015,4
Plaintiff also demonstrated that it will suffer irreparable harm absent an injunctionand that the balance of equities tips in its favor. If a preliminary injunction is not granted,plaintiff's restaurant, situated at a prime retail location, will be closed, its 19 employeeswill lose their jobs, and plaintiff will lose its substantial investment in improvements(see Waldbaum, Inc. v Fifth Ave. of Long Is. Realty Assoc., 85 NY2d 600, 607[1995] [forfeiture of "valuable improvements" and the good will built up by the plaintiffat the store location warranted a preliminary injunction]; Second on Second Café, Inc.v Hing Sing Trading, Inc., 66 AD3d 255, 272-273 [1st Dept 2009] ["the loss ofthe goodwill of a viable, ongoing business" constitutes "irreparable harm warranting thegrant of preliminary injunctive relief"]; FTI Consulting, Inc. v PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 8 AD3d145, 146 [1st Dept 2004] [loss of goodwill constitutes irreparable harm because it isnot "readily quantifiable"]).
While plaintiff waited until the cancellation date was imminent before commencingthis action, it explained in its application for injunctive relief that it had not moved earlierbecause it was waiting to see if defendant would file a demolition plan with theDepartment of Buildings or negotiate a buyout with the other two commercial tenants ofthe adjacent building, whose leases did not expire until 2025 and did not contain an earlycancellation for demolition clause. It was not unreasonable for plaintiff to wait and seehow defendant's demolition plan manifested. Moreover, plaintiff still brought suit priorto the stated cancellation date and there is no evidence that defendant will be prejudiced,since it still appears to be weighing its options.
The balancing of the equities requires the court to determine the relative prejudice toeach party accruing from a grant or denial of the requested relief (see Sau Thi Ma vXuan T. Lien, 198 AD2d 186 [1st Dept 1993], lv dismissed 83 NY2d 847[1994]). The harm to plaintiff and its employees outweighs any potential harm todefendant resulting from delays to its redevelopment scheme, which it has not shown tobe imminent. A preliminary injunction would "maintain the status quo [pending a hearingon the merits] and prevent the dissipation of property that could render a judgmentineffectual" (Ruiz vMeloney, 26 AD3d 485, 486 [2d Dept 2006]).
We have considered defendant's other arguments and find them unavailing.Concur—Sweeny, J.P., Renwick, Andrias, Kapnick and Kahn, JJ.