Matter of Wellsville Citizens for Responsible Dev., Inc. vWal-Mart Stores, Inc.
2016 NY Slip Op 04847 [140 AD3d 1767]
June 17, 2016
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 3, 2016


[*1]
 In the Matter of Wellsville Citizens for ResponsibleDevelopment, Inc., Appellant, v Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., et al., Respondents, et al.,Respondents.

Parker R. Mackay, Kenmore, for petitioner-appellant.

Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP, New York City (Kenneth D. Friedman ofcounsel), for respondents-respondents Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., Wal-Mart Real EstateBusiness Trust and Wal-Mart Stores East, Lp.

Law Offices of Hutter & Finn, Wellsville (Michael B. Finn of counsel), forrespondents-respondents Town of Wellsville, Town Board of Town of Wellsville andDean Arnold, in His Official Capacity as Highway Superintendent of Town ofWellsville.

Appeal from a judgment (denominated order) of the Supreme Court, AlleganyCounty (Terrence M. Parker, A.J.), entered June 12, 2015 in a CPLR article 78proceeding. The judgment denied the petition.

It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously reversed onthe law without costs, and the petition is granted.

Memorandum: Petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding seeking to annul the resolution of respondent Town Board of Town of Wellsville (Town Board) adopting a negative declaration pursuant to the State Environmental Quality Review Act ([SEQRA] ECL art 8) with respect to the proposed construction of aWal-Mart Supercenter (hereafter, project) in respondent Town of Wellsville (Town). Weagree with petitioner that the Town Board failed to take the requisite hard look at theimpact of the project on wildlife, the community character of respondent Village ofWellsville (Village) and surface water, and thus that Supreme Court erred in denying thepetition.

"Judicial review of a lead agency's SEQRA determination is limited to whether thedetermination was made in accordance with lawful procedure and whether, substantively,the determination was affected by an error of law or was arbitrary and capricious or anabuse of discretion" (Matter ofEisenhauer v County of Jefferson, 122 AD3d 1312, 1313 [2014] [internalquotation marks omitted]; see Matter of New York City Coalition to End LeadPoisoning v Vallone, 100 NY2d 337, 348 [2003]). In determining whether thesubstantive requirements of SEQRA were met, the scope of judicial review is "limited towhether the lead agency . . . identified the relevant areas of environmentalconcern, took a hard look at them, and made a reasoned elaboration of the basis for itsdetermination" (Matter ofMombaccus Excavating, Inc. v Town of [*2]Rochester,N.Y., 89 AD3d 1209, 1210 [2011], lv denied 18 NY3d 808 [2012][internal quotation marks omitted]). However, "where a lead agency has failed to complywith SEQRA's mandates, the negative declaration must be nullified" (Vallone,100 NY2d at 348).

We initially reject petitioner's two contentions based on alleged proceduralviolations. First, we reject petitioner's contention that the Town Board improperly failedto complete part 3 of the environmental assessment form (EAF). As long as the factorsset forth in part 3 of the EAF are addressed by the lead agency in its environmentalreview of the project, there is no need to complete part 3, or to nullify the negativedeclaration if the lead agency fails to do so (see Matter of Residents Against Wal-Mart v Planning Bd. of Townof Greece, 60 AD3d 1343, 1344 [2009], lv denied 12 NY3d 715[2009]). Here, because the Town Board addressed each of the potentiallymoderate-to-large impacts identified in part 2 of the EAF, the negative declaration neednot be annulled because of the Town Board's failure to fill out the EAF part 3 form. Wealso reject petitioner's contention that the Town Board's failure to notify the PlanningBoard of the Town of Wellsville before assuming lead agency status requiresnullification of the negative declaration. Under the circumstances of this case, any failureof the Town Board in that regard was "inconsequential" (Matter of King v County ofMonroe [appeal No. 2], 255 AD2d 1003, 1004 [1998], lv denied 93 NY2d801 [1999]).

With respect to the substantive contentions of petitioner based on the Town Board'salleged failure to take a hard look at several relevant impacts of the project, we firstreject petitioner's contention that the Town Board failed to take a hard look at the impactof the project on traffic. The Town Board reviewed two extensive traffic impact studiesand a supplemental traffic impact study and, although there were modifications to theproject after the supplemental traffic impact study was approved by the New York StateDepartment of Transportation, the "over-all result of the modifications in their final formdid not significantly change the total square footage of building area . . .[or] the total size of parking and landscaped areas" (Matter of Monteiro v Town ofColonie, 158 AD2d 246, 249 [1990]; see Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town ofSoutheast, 9 NY3d 219, 233-234 [2007]). Contrary to petitioner's furthercontention, any alleged shortcomings in the Town Board's review of plans to provideadditional access to the Supercenter via a road called Airway Drive do not require theconclusion that the Town Board failed to take a hard look at the impact of the project ontraffic (see Matter of Terrace Manor Civic Assn. v Town of N. Hempstead, 301AD2d 534, 535 [2003]).

We agree with petitioner, however, that the Town Board failed to take the requisitehard look at the impact of the project on wildlife, the community character of the Village,and surface water, and that the resolution adopting the negative declaration musttherefore be annulled. With respect to wildlife, the Town Board was apparently madeaware in March 2014 that birds listed as "threatened" and of "special concern" by theNew York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC), and listed on a"watch list" by the New York Natural Heritage Program (NHP), had been spotted on theproject site. An ecological evaluation of the project site provided to the Town Board inAugust 2014, shortly before the negative declaration was issued, further noted that thearea surrounding the project site is a habitat for "a myriad of songbirds and someraptors." Despite that knowledge, the Town Board, in making its determination that theproject would have no significant impact on wildlife, merely relied on letters from NHPand the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service indicating that those agencies did not have anyrecords of any endangered or threatened species on the project site. The letter from NHPspecifically warned, however, that the information therein "should not be substituted foron-site surveys that may be required for environmental impact assessment." The TownBoard never undertook or demanded any such on-site surveys. Given the informationreceived from the public that state-listed threatened species might be present on theproject site and the failure of the Town Board to investigate the veracity of thatinformation, we conclude that the Town Board failed to take a hard look at the impact ofthe project on wildlife, and the negative declaration with respect thereto was thereforearbitrary and capricious (seeMatter of Kittredge v Planning Bd. of Town of Liberty, 57 AD3d 1336,1337-1338 [2008]; Matter ofPyramid Co. of Watertown v Planning Bd. of Town of Watertown, 24 AD3d1312, 1314-1315 [2005], appeal dismissed 7 NY3d 803 [2006]; seegenerally Akpan v Koch, 75 NY2d 561, 571 [1990]).

With respect to the "community character" of the Village, we note that SEQRAdefines "environment" as "the physical conditions which will be affected by a proposedaction, including . . . existing community or neighborhood character" (ECL8-0105 [6]), and "require[s] a lead [*3]agency to considermore than impacts upon the physical environment," including "the potential displacementof local residents and businesses" (Chinese Staff & Workers Assn. v City ofNew York, 68 NY2d 359, 366 [1986]). Therefore, contrary to the Town Board'sapparent conclusion, "[a] town . . . board reviewing a big box developmentshould consider the impact of the development on the community character of aneighboring village that might suffer business displacement as a result of the approval ofthe big box development" (SEQR Handbook at 179 [3d ed 2010]; see Matter of Village of ChestnutRidge v Town of Ramapo, 45 AD3d 74, 94-95 [2007], lv dismissed 12NY3d 793 [2009], 15 NY3d 817 [2010]; Matter of Wal-Mart Stores v Planning Bd.of Town of N. Elba, 238 AD2d 93, 98 [1998]). Because there is no evidence in therecord before us that the Town Board even considered the impact of the project on thecommunity character of the Village, we conclude that it failed to take a hard look at thatimpact, requiring annulment of the resolution adopting the negative declaration on thatground as well.

Finally, with respect to the impact of the project on surface water, we conclude thatthe Town Board erred in failing to consider the surface water impact of the entire project.While the Town Board considered surface water impacts relating to the footprint of theSupercenter and related areas, the project documents submitted to the Town Board makeclear that the reconstruction of four golf course holes on a golf course adjacent to theproject is a central part of the project, and the DEC specifically directed that theenvironmental assessment of the project include consideration of that reconstruction.Because the surface water studies presented to the Town Board did not include ananalysis of the potential surface water impact of the golf course reconstruction portion ofthe project, and the record does not demonstrate that the Town Board otherwiseconsidered that impact, we conclude that the Town Board failed to undertake therequisite hard look at the potential surface water impact of the entire project (seeMatter of Long Is. Pine Barrens Socy. v Town Bd. of Town of Riverhead, 290 AD2d448, 448-449 [2002], lv denied 98 NY2d 615 [2002]). Thus, annulment of theTown Board's resolution adopting the negative declaration also is required on thatground. Present—Whalen, P.J., Smith, Lindley, NeMoyer and Scudder, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.