Matter of Bolt v New York City Dept. of Educ.
2016 NY Slip Op 08158 [145 AD3d 450]
December 6, 2016
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 1, 2017


[*1]
 In the Matter of Ericka Bolt,Respondent,
v
New York City Department of Education,Appellant.

Zachary W. Carter, Corporation Counsel, New York (Melanie West of counsel), forappellant.

Law Offices of Richard J. Washington, P.C., New York (Richard J. Washington ofcounsel), for respondent.

Order and judgment (one paper), Supreme Court, New York County (Joan M.Kenny, J.), entered April 28, 2015, which granted the petition to vacate an arbitrator'sopinion and award, dated October 15, 2014, terminating petitioner's employment withrespondent based on her misconduct, and denied respondent's cross motion to dismiss thepetition, unanimously modified, on the law, to confirm the Arbitrator's determination thatpetitioner is guilty as charged in specifications 2 and 3 (a), (b), (c) and (d), and to remandthe matter to respondent for imposition of a lesser penalty, and otherwise affirmed,without costs.

Notwithstanding the existence of conflicting testimony, the Arbitrator's findings ofmisconduct on specifications 2, 3 (a), (b), (c) and (d) are supported by adequate evidenceand are not irrational (seeLackow v Department of Educ. [or "Board"] of City of N.Y., 51 AD3d 563,567-568 [1st Dept 2008]). However, while we confirm the Arbitrator's finding, based onthe testimony of three students, that petitioner "directly or indirectly," assisted severalstudents on a standardized English Language Arts exam, we find that under thecircumstances presented here the penalty of termination shocks our sense of fairness(see Matter of Pell v Board of Educ. of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 of Towns ofScarsdale & Mamaroneck, Westchester County, 34 NY2d 222, 234[1974]).

"[A] result is shocking to one's sense of fairness if the sanction imposed is so gravein its impact on the individual subjected to it that it is disproportionate to the misconduct,incompetence, failure or turpitude of the individual, or to the harm or risk of harm to theagency or institution, or to the public generally visited or threatened by the derelictions ofthe individuals. Additional factors would be the prospect of deterrence of the individualor of others in like situations, and therefore a reasonable prospect of recurrence ofderelictions by the individual or persons similarly employed. There is also the elementthat the sanctions reflect the standards of society to be applied to the offense involved"(Pell, 34 NY2d at 234).

While petitioner's behavior in suggesting to several students that some of theiranswers might be wrong demonstrated a lapse in judgment, petitioner did not provide thestudents with the correct answers and there is no evidence that the incident was anythingbut a one-time [*2]mistake (see Matter of Diefenthaler vKlein, 27 AD3d 347, 349 [1st Dept 2006] ["we find it shocking to theconscience that these long-standing and well-regarded employees have been terminatedfor such an isolated error of judgment"]). Prior to her termination in October 2014,petitioner, a tenured teacher who had worked for respondent since 2003, had anunblemished record and, as the OSI investigator testified, was considered to be a goodteacher (see Matter of Solis vDepartment of Educ. of City of N.Y., 30 AD3d 532, 532 [2d Dept 2006][termination disproportionate "(i)n light of, among other things, the petitioner's otherwiseunblemished 12-year record as a teacher"]). Moreover, the record is devoid of evidencethat would suggest petitioner could not remedy her behavior.

Matter of Carangelo v Ambach (130 AD2d 898 [3d Dept 1987], lvdenied 70 NY2d 609 [1987]), cited by the dissent, does not mandate a differentresult. In Carangelo, the teacher was found guilty of failing to properly safeguardhis students' Regents examinations, failing to accurately grade them and altering answers.The evidence indicated that of 705 answers on 15 examinations, 79 were altered. Theteacher admitted that it was apparent that the answers had been changed by someoneother than the students and that he did nothing about it, and the District's expert opinedthat it was highly probable that the teacher made 76 of the 79 changes (id. at899). In affirming the penalty of termination, the Third Department found that "[a]lteringthe answers given on an examination, or even ignoring alterations obviously not made bythe student, amounts to a serious breach of a teacher's obligations" (id. at 900).Here, petitioner pointed out to several students that certain answers on their exams mightbe wrong and suggested they take another look at them. She did not alter any of herstudent's answers or advise them what the correct answers were.

Nor does Matter of Carlan v Board of Educ. of Lawrence Union Free SchoolDist. (128 AD2d 706 [2d Dept 1987]), cited in the Arbitrator's report, mandate thepenalty of termination. In Carlan, the petitioner was found "guilty of some 53charges and specifications concerning, inter alia, repeated and continuous neglect ofduty, insubordination, failure to prepare and grade certain final examinations, andmanipulation of students' test scores" (id. at 707). Concur—Acosta,Andrias, Manzanet-Daniels and Webber, JJ.

Sweeny, J., dissents in part in a memorandum as follows: I concur with the majoritythat there is no basis to overturn the factual findings reached by the Arbitrator.

I disagree that the matter should be remanded for imposition of a lesser penalty. Themajority is in error to say the penalty of termination is so shocking to the conscience thatit must be vacated.[FN1][*3] The majority has accepted the Arbitrator's findings wherein he found credible thetestimony of three separate students that petitioner assisted them and other students bypointing out a number of answers to be changed in a statewide English proficiency exam.Where I depart from the majority is their attempt to, for example, compare an employeeneglecting to do carpentry work in a lavatory (Matter of Diefenthaler v Klein, 27 AD3d 347 [1st Dept2006]) to a teacher who violated the integrity of a school examination.

In a case with a fact pattern similar to this, the Third Department found "petitioner'soffense goes to the heart of one of the most integral aspects of the education process:integrity in conducting examinations" (Matter of Carangelo v Ambach 130 AD2d898, 900 [3d Dept 1987], lv denied 70 NY2d 609 [1987]).

The Arbitrator found, and the majority does not challenge, that petitioner"[c]ommitted insubordination by assisting students during the administration of thestatewide exams when she was expressly directed not to do so." He further found "that[petitioner] was the authority figure for these students, who were approximately ten yearsold at the time the incident occurred, and that she had the responsibility to set a goodexample for her students to emulate. [T]he message that her conduct conveyed to theseyoung students, that cheating is permitted, was completely inappropriate and more thanharmful. . . . [H]er actions demonstrated a lack of integrity and irrevocablycomprised her ability to serve as a role model for students."

That petitioner had a previously unblemished record is not compelling, especiallywith the facts herein (see Matterof Russo v New York City Dept. of Educ., 25 NY3d 946 [2015]; Altsheler vBoard of Educ. of Great Neck Union Free School Dist. 62 NY2d 656 [1984]; Matter of Montanez v Departmentof Educ. of the City of N.Y., 110 AD3d 487 [1st Dept 2013]).[FN2]

Although the majority may feel a lesser penalty is more appropriate, as students andparents have the right to believe the testing process is fairly administered, it cannot besaid that the penalty shocked one's sense of fairness (Pell at 234).

I would reverse the lower court and reinstate the arbitration decision along with thepenalty of termination.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:I agree with the majoritythat the seminal cases such as Matter of Pell v Board of Educ. of Union Free SchoolDist. No. 1 of Towns of Scarsdale & Mamaroneck, Westchester County (34NY2d 222 [1974]) clearly set out the heavy burden to vacate an arbitrator's penaltydetermination. I disagree to their application herein.

Footnote 2:The majority's reliancein Matter of Solis v Departmentof Educ. of City of N.Y. (30 AD3d 532 [2d Dept 2006]) is not helpful as theunderlying act the teacher committed in that case was not explained.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.