| People v Rispers |
| 2017 NY Slip Op 00492 [146 AD3d 988] |
| January 25, 2017 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| The People of the State of New York,Respondent, v Marc Rispers, Appellant. |
Gerald Zuckerman, Croton-on-Hudson, NY, for appellant.
Anthony A. Scarpino, Jr., District Attorney, White Plains, NY (RaffaelinaGianfrancesco and Richard Longworth Hecht of counsel), for respondent.
Appeal by the defendant from a judgment of the County Court, Westchester County(Zambelli, J.), rendered October 14, 2014, convicting him of robbery in the first degree(four counts), grand larceny in the fourth degree (two counts), petit larceny (two counts),criminal possession of stolen property in the fifth degree, and resisting arrest, upon a juryverdict, and imposing sentence.
Ordered that the judgment is affirmed.
The defendant was convicted of robbery in the first degree and other crimes upon,among other evidence, eyewitness testimony establishing that he and two otherindividuals robbed the owner of a car wash at gunpoint. The defendant was apprehendedafter leading the police on a high-speed car chase and subsequent chase on foot. Theguns used in the crime and some of the proceeds of the crime were found in the car inwhich the defendant and his two cohorts had fled.
In his omnibus motion, the defendant sought, inter alia, to suppress the gunsrecovered from the getaway car. After a hearing, the County Court denied suppression.After a trial at which he was convicted of various charges, the defendant moved to setaside the verdict pursuant to CPL 330.30 (3) on the ground of newly discoveredevidence, namely, that the prosecution committed a Brady violation (seeBrady v Maryland, 373 US 83 [1963]) by failing to disclose that, pursuant to a jointinvestigation by the Yonkers Police Department's Internal Affairs Division and theWestchester County District Attorney's Office, it was discovered that Detective ChristianKoch, who testified on behalf of the prosecution at the suppression hearing, had madematerial, false statements in a search warrant affidavit in an unrelated case. The CountyCourt denied the motion, finding, inter alia, that the defendant failed to establish that aBrady violation had occurred.
To establish a Brady violation, a defendant must show that (1) the evidence isfavorable to the defendant because it is either exculpatory or impeaching in nature; (2)the evidence was suppressed by the prosecution; and (3) prejudice arose because thesuppressed evidence was material (see Strickler v Greene, 527 US 263, 281-282[1999]). While it is undisputed that the purported Brady material was favorable tothe defendant for the purpose of impeaching Detective Koch's testimony (see People v Garrett, 23 NY3d878, 886 [2014]), the defendant failed to show that the People [*2]suppressed the purported Brady material. Althoughthe People are charged with knowledge of exculpatory information in the possession ofthe local police, notwithstanding the trial prosecutor's own lack of knowledge (seePeople v Santorelli, 95 NY2d 412, 421 [2000]; People v Wright, 86 NY2d591, 598 [1995]), " '[a] police officer's secret knowledge of his own prior illegalconduct in [an] unrelated case . . . will not be imputed to the prosecution forBrady purposes where the People had no knowledge of the corrupt officer's "badacts" until after . . . trial' " (People v Garrett, 23 NY3d at887-888, quoting People v Johnson, 226 AD2d 828, 829 [1996]; see People vVasquez, 214 AD2d 93, 95 [1995]; see e.g. People v Kinney, 107 AD3d 563, 564 [2013];People v Longtin, 245 AD2d 807, 810 [1997], affd 92 NY2d 640[1998]). Here, the People did not discover Detective Koch's false statements until afterthe trial had ended.
Accordingly, the County Court properly denied the defendant's motion to set asidethe verdict pursuant to CPL 330.30 (3).
The sentence imposed was not excessive (see People v Suitte, 90 AD2d 80[1982]).
The defendant's remaining contention is without merit. Chambers, J.P., Roman,Miller and Barros, JJ., concur.