| Torati v Hodak |
| 2017 NY Slip Op 01160 [147 AD3d 502] |
| February 14, 2017 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1]
| Hezi Torati et al., Respondents, v Daniel Hodak,Appellant, et al., Defendants. |
Ganfer & Shore LLP, New York (Ira Brad Matetsky of counsel), for appellant.
Edelstein & Grossman, New York (Jonathan I. Edelstein of counsel), forrespondents.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Ellen M. Coin, J.), entered September 22, 2015,which, insofar as appealed from, denied defendant Hodak's motion to dismiss the causes ofaction for libel and libel per se as against him pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1) and (7),unanimously modified, on the law, to grant the motion except as to the claims based on theFacebook message, and otherwise affirmed, without costs.
The complaint alleges defamation stemming from negative comments anonymously postedby defendant on various consumer review websites or shared via Facebook message. With theexception of the Facebook message (which contains statements that are largely factual in nature),the challenged statements are not actionable, because they are expressions of opinion (see Mann v Abel, 10 NY3d 271,276 [2008], cert denied 555 US 1170 [2009]). While the Internet reviews containelements of both fact and opinion, when viewed in context, they suggest to a reasonable readerthat the author was merely expressing his opinion based on a negative business interaction withplaintiffs (see id.; Steinhilber v Alphonse, 68 NY2d 283, 294 [1986]). Thecommunications have a "[l]oose, figurative or hyperbolic" tone (see Dillon v City of NewYork, 261 AD2d 34, 38 [1st Dept 1999]), referring to plaintiff as a "bad apple,""incompetent and dishonest," and a "disastrous businessman," from whom consumers should"[s]tay far away." Moreover, they were posted anonymously online. As this Court hasrecognized, "[R]eaders give less credence to allegedly defamatory remarks published on theInternet than to similar remarks made in other contexts" (Sandals Resorts Intl. Ltd. v Google, Inc., 86 AD3d 32, 44 [1st Dept2011]).
The reviews are analogous to those at issue in Matter of Woodbridge Structured Funding, LLC v Pissed Consumer(125 AD3d 508 [1st Dept 2015]), which were found not to be actionable, although "some ofthe statements [were] based on undisclosed, unfavorable facts," because "the disgruntled tone,anonymous posting, and predominant use of statements that cannot be definitively proven true orfalse" made them "only susceptible of a nondefamatory meaning, grounded in opinion"(id. at 509). The fact that, in this case, defendant was plaintiffs' business partner ratherthan an ordinary consumer is immaterial.
An additional ground for dismissing the claims based on the Yelp review is that they aretime-barred, since they were asserted after the one-year statute of limitations had run (CPLR 215[3]). They cannot relate back to the original complaints, because those complaints were notsufficient to put defendant on notice of any Yelp-related claims (see CPLR 203 [f];see also CPLR 3016 [a]).
The Facebook message, however, is actionable. The fact that it was only shared with threepeople, all members of the individual plaintiff's family, is not grounds for dismissal. Publicationto even one person other than the defamed is sufficient (Matter of Lentlie v Egan, 61[*2]NY2d 874, 876 [1984]), and the fact that the person to whomthe statement was made is a family member is immaterial (see 60 Minute Man vKossman, 161 AD2d 574, 576 [2d Dept 1990]). Concur—Tom, J.P., Sweeny,Renwick, Moskowitz and Kapnick, JJ.