| Matter of Reyes v Annucci |
| 2017 NY Slip Op 03587 [150 AD3d 1373] |
| May 4, 2017 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Jacob Reyes, Petitioner, v Anthony J. Annucci,as Acting Commissioner of Corrections and Community Supervision,Respondent. |
Matthew P. McGowan, Prisoners' Legal Services of New York, Albany, for petitioner.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Marcus J. Mastracco of counsel), forrespondent.
Lynch, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of respondent findingpetitioner guilty of violating certain prison disciplinary rules.
Petitioner became physically combative during a pat frisk requiring correction officers to useforce to restrain him. He was escorted by two correction officers to the medical clinic followingthis incident. During the escort, petitioner refused orders to remain quiet and face forward, andthen allegedly struck one of the correction officers who was accompanying him in the chest. As aresult of his conduct during the escort, petitioner was charged in a misbehavior report withrefusing a direct order, assaulting staff and engaging in violent conduct. Following a tier IIIdisciplinary hearing, he was found guilty of the charges. The determination was later upheld onadministrative appeal with a modified penalty, and this CPLR article 78 proceedingensued.[FN*]
[*2] Petitioner challenges the disciplinary determination onprocedural grounds, arguing that he was improperly denied documentary evidence and thetestimony of two witnesses, which he contends were potentially relevant to his retaliationdefense. The documentary evidence requested consisted of a letter written by another inmate thatwas specifically referenced in the use of force report signed by the Superintendent following theincident and which prompted the Superintendent to call for a further investigation. Petitionerrequested production of this letter at the hearing, believing that it might contain informationsupporting his claim that the correction officer who wrote the misbehavior report, against whomhe had previously filed complaints, held a grudge and fabricated the report. The Hearing Officerdenied petitioner's request because the letter was issued "after the fact." Respondent concedesand we agree that this was error as the letter may have contained potentially relevant informationregarding the circumstances surrounding the incident, as well as the officer's motivation forwriting the report. Absent disclosure of the letter, we cannot conclude on this record thatpetitioner's defense was not prejudiced (see Matter of Telesford v Annucci, 145 AD3d 1167, 1167 [2016];Matter of Gallagher v Fischer, 108AD3d 802, 802 [2013]; Matter ofCaldwell v Rock, 93 AD3d 1048, 1048 [2012]).
Petitioner also takes issue with the fact that two correction officers, who responded to theinitial altercation and were also purportedly present during the escort, were denied as witnesses.The denial of these witnesses was not specifically addressed at the hearing, but the witnessinterview forms completed by the Hearing Officer disclose that they were denied as immaterialbecause petitioner admitted that they were not present during the escort. The record, however, isnot entirely clear in this regard. One of the escort officers who testified at the hearing related thathe could not recall other officers being present during the escort and the other escort officer didnot address this subject. Significantly, there was no testimony adduced at the hearing to establishthat the two officers at issue were definitely not present. Although petitioner expressed to theHearing Officer that he understood the escort officers to say that they escorted petitioner bythemselves and the Hearing Officer agreed, this was not an admission that other correctionofficers were not present. Notably, confidential documentation in the record discloses that thetwo officers reported to the medical clinic immediately after responding to the initial altercationand may have been in the hallway during the escort. Inasmuch as their testimony was potentiallyrelevant to petitioner's defense, it was error to deny them as witnesses (see Matter of McFarlane v Annucci,145 AD3d 1312, 1313 [2016]; Matter of Gross v Yelich, 101 AD3d 1298, 1298 [2012]).
Given the Hearing Officer's errors in denying potentially relevant documentary evidence andwitness testimony, the determination must be annulled. However, inasmuch as the record revealsa good faith basis for the Hearing Officer's actions, the appropriate remedy for these regulatoryviolations is remittal for a new hearing rather than expungement (see Matter of McFarlane vAnnucci, 145 AD3d at 1313; Matterof Ellison v Annucci, 142 AD3d 1233, 1234 [2016]; Matter of Gross v Yelich,101 AD3d at 1298).
Garry, J.P., Rose, Clark and Aarons, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination is annulled,without costs, and matter remitted to [*3]respondent for furtherproceedings not inconsistent with this Court's decision.
Footnote *:Although the verified petitiondoes not raise the issue of substantial evidence and the proceeding was, therefore, improperlytransferred to this Court, we retain jurisdiction in the interest of judicial economy (see Matter of Meehan v Annucci, 144AD3d 1278, 1278 n [2016]).