Matter of Town of Marilla v Travis
2017 NY Slip Op 04583 [151 AD3d 1588]
June 9, 2017
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 2, 2017


[*1]
 In the Matter of Town of Marilla et al., Appellants, v Stanley E.Travis et al., Respondents.

Richard E. Stanton, Buffalo, for petitioners-appellants.

Harris Beach PLLC, Pittsford (John A. Mancuso of counsel), for respondents-respondentsStanley E. Travis, Trav-Co Farms and Sustainable BioPower, LLC.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Meredith G. Lee-clark of counsel), forrespondent-respondent New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.

Appeal from a judgment (denominated judgment and order) of the Supreme Court, ErieCounty (John L. Michalski, A.J.), entered October 13, 2015 in a proceeding pursuant to CPLRarticle 78. The judgment, among other things, consolidated two separate proceedings anddismissed the consolidated proceeding.

It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.

Memorandum: Respondent Sustainable BioPower, LLC, and its predecessor in interest, Quasar Energy Group, LLC (collectively, BioPower), applied to respondent New York StateDepartment of Environmental Conservation (DEC) for a solid waste facility management permit(Permit), which would allow it to store the end product of wastewater and other waste treatmentprocesses that BioPower conducted in two existing anaerobic digestion facilities. That endproduct, trade named equate, would eventually be used as an agricultural fertilizer. BioPowersought permission to store the equate in an existing million-gallon manure storage tank on afarm, until it could be transported and used as fertilizer. After petitioner Town of Marilladeclined to seek lead agency designation for purposes of the State Environmental Quality ReviewAct ([SEQRA] ECL art 8), the DEC designated itself as lead agency. After reviewing theapplication and seeking further information and increased detail regarding the proposal, the DECissued a negative declaration of environmental significance. Next, after seeking more informationfrom BioPower, seeking public comment, and considering the comments received, the DECgranted the Permit. Petitioners commenced separate CPLR article 78 proceedings, each seekingto annul the negative declaration and the determination to grant the Permit. Petitioners nowappeal from a judgment that, inter alia, consolidated the proceedings and dismissed theconsolidated proceeding. We affirm.

Petitioners contend that the DEC erred in granting the Permit based on its improperinterpretation of the procedures set forth in its applicable regulations. "Our review of an agencydetermination that was not made after a quasi-judicial hearing is limited to consideration ofwhether the determination was made in violation of lawful procedure, was affected by an error oflaw, or was arbitrary and capricious or an abuse of discretion" (Matter of Harpur v Cassano, 129 AD3d964, 965 [2015], lv denied 26 NY3d 916 [2016]; see CPLR 7803 [3]). Here,petitioners contend that the DEC's determination to issue the Permit was "made in violation oflawful procedure" (Harpur, 129 AD3d at 965), because the DEC's regulations mandatethat any application for a permit be accompanied by a report signed, stamped and certified by anengineer, containing certain specific information, including wind maps, topographical mapsshowing streams and elevations, and other detailed environmental data (see 6 NYCRRpart 360), and the application for the Permit did not include some of those items. We reject thatcontention.

"[I]t is well settled that an agency's failure to follow procedural provisions that are merelydirectory rather than mandatory in nature will not warrant annulling a subsequent determinationunless the challengers show that substantial prejudice resulted from the agency's noncompliance"(Matter of Dudley Rd. Assn. v Adirondack Park Agency, 214 AD2d 274, 279 [1995],lv dismissed in part and denied in part 87 NY2d 952 [1996]; see Matter of Syquia vBoard of Educ. of Harpursville Cent. School Dist., 80 NY2d 531, 535-536 [1992]). Here, therecord regarding the DEC's determination of the application for the Permit establishes that theDEC obtained and reviewed all of the information that petitioners contend should be included inthe engineering report, and that BioPower's engineers certified, signed and stamped all of theinformation presented in support of the application. In addition, the DEC established that italready possessed much of the information that petitioners claim was omitted from theapplication, including wind and topographical maps. Furthermore, the evidence in the recordestablishes that the process took more than a year, during which the DEC made several requestsfor additional information, documentation, or engineering certification from BioPower, and thatall the requested information was provided. Thus, Supreme Court properly dismissed thepetitions insofar as they sought to vacate the Permit because petitioners established no prejudicefrom the DEC's failure to insist that BioPower and its predecessor put all the information into asingle report. In addition, the DEC's interpretation of its regulation is entitled to deferenceinasmuch as it "involves knowledge and understanding of underlying operational practices orentails an evaluation of factual data and inferences to be drawn therefrom" (Kurcsics vMerchants Mut. Ins. Co., 49 NY2d 451, 459 [1980]; see Matter of Lighthouse Pointe Prop. Assoc. LLC v New York State Dept.of Envtl. Conservation, 14 NY3d 161, 176 [2010]).

Conversely, with respect to the procedural rules governing determinations pursuant toSEQRA, it is well settled that a lead agency must strictly comply with SEQRA's proceduralmandates, and failure to do so will result in annulment of the lead agency's determination ofsignificance (see Matter of King v Saratoga County Bd. of Supervisors, 89 NY2d 341,347 [1996]; Matter of Pyramid Co. ofWatertown v Planning Bd. of Town of Watertown, 24 AD3d 1312, 1313 [2005], lvdismissed 7 NY3d 803 [2006]). Here, however, a review of the extensive recorddemonstrates that the DEC complied with the procedural requirements of SEQRA in determiningthat the issuance of the Permit would have no significant adverse environmental impacts and inissuing the negative declaration. At the DEC's request, BioPower prepared part one of a fullenvironmental assessment form (EAF), which included a comprehensive report prepared byBioPower's engineers that identified and reviewed in detail the areas of environmental concernrelevant to the storage of equate in the existing manure tank, including possible odor emissions,mitigation of the effects of accidental discharges, and traffic. Later, again pursuant to the DEC'srequest, BioPower prepared portions of parts two and three of the EAF. The DEC concluded thatthe EAF was properly completed, and we agree inasmuch as it "contain[s] enough information todescribe the proposed action, its location, its purpose and its potential impacts on theenvironment" (6 NYCRR 617.2 [m]). We have considered petitioners' remaining contentionsconcerning the DEC's compliance with SEQRA's procedural mandates, and we conclude thatthey are without merit.

Where, as here, "an agency has followed the procedures required by SEQRA, a court's reviewof the substance of the agency's determination is limited" (Matter of Eadie v Town Bd. of Town of N. Greenbush, 7 NY3d306, 318 [2006]). "It is well established that, 'in reviewing the substantive issues raised in aSEQRA proceeding, [a] court will not substitute its judgment for that of the agency if the agencyreached its determination in some reasonable fashion' " (Matter of Kaufmann'sCarousel v City of Syracuse Indus. Dev. Agency, 301 AD2d 292, 304 [2002], lvdenied 99 NY2d 508 [2003]). Upon conducting such a review, contrary to petitioners'contention, we conclude that the DEC properly "identified the relevant areas of environmentalconcern, took a 'hard look' at them, and made a 'reasoned elaboration' of the basis for itsdetermination" (Matter of Jackson v New York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400,417 [1986]). Present—Whalen, P.J., Smith, Centra, Troutman and Scudder, JJ. [PriorCase History: 49 Misc 3d 1203(A), 2015 NY Slip Op 51367(U).]


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.