Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v New York State Dept. of Envtl.Conservation
2017 NY Slip Op 05778 [152 AD3d 1016]
As corrected through Wednesday, August 30, 2017


[*1]
1 In the Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc., Appellant,
v
NewYork State Department of Environmental Conservation et al., Respondents. (And AnotherRelated Proceeding.)

Todd Ommen, Pace Environmental Litigation Clinic, White Plains, and Abigail Jones,Riverkeeper, Inc., Ossining, for appellant.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Susan L. Taylor of counsel), for New YorkState Department of Environmental Conservation, respondent.

Nixon Peabody, LLP, Albany (Ruth E. Leistensnider of counsel), for Danskammer Energy,LLC, respondent.

Devine, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (McDonough, J.), entered January26, 2016 in Albany County, which dismissed petitioner's applications, in two combinedproceedings pursuant to CPLR article 78 and actions for declaratory judgment, to, among otherthings, review a determination of respondent Department of Environmental Conservationgranting respondent Danskammer Energy, LLC certain permits to operate a natural gas electricgenerating station.

The Danskammer Generating Station (hereinafter the station) uses four steam turbinegenerators to produce electricity. The station is located on the shore of the Hudson River andemploys a "once-through cooling system" to prevent the generating units from overheating, aprocess wherein water is pumped from the river to cool the units and then returned to the river ata higher temperature. This discharge of warmer water is a pollutant under federal and state law(see 33 USC §§ 1326, 1362 [6]; ECL 17-0105 [17]) and, as such,requires a State Pollutant [*2]Discharge Elimination System(hereinafter SPDES) permit issued by respondent Department of Environmental Conservation(hereinafter DEC) (see ECL 17-0701, 17-0801 et seq.; see also Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. vCrotty, 28 AD3d 957, 957 [2006]). The station is also a source of hazardous airpollutants within the meaning of the federal Clean Air Act (see 42 USC§ 7412) that requires an additional permit, known as a "Title V" permit, issued byDEC (see 42 USC § 7661 et seq.; ECL 19-0311).

The station's SPDES permit was set to expire in 2011, but remained in effect due to apending renewal application (see State Administrative Procedure Act § 401[2]). The then-owner of the station also filed for bankruptcy in 2011 and, as part of thebankruptcy proceedings, sought to sell the station at auction. A massive storm flooded the stationand forced it offline in October 2012, prompting the then-owner to request authorization toquickly discontinue operation of the station and sell it to a bidder at auction that had an expressedintention of demolishing the station. Authorization to retire the station was granted by the PublicService Commission in April 2013, but the sale was never consummated and regulatory changesrestored the station's financial viability. The station was then sold to a different entity that, inJune 2014, was authorized by the Public Service Commission to resume operations at the stationand transfer it to respondent Danskammer Energy, LLC (hereinafter Danskammer).

The ownership changes and passage of time resulted in applications to DEC for the issuanceof updated operating permits, including SPDES and Title V permits. In August 2014, DECpublished a combined notice of complete applications in which it noted its issuance of a negativedeclaration pursuant to the State Environmental Quality Review Act (see ECL art 8[hereinafter SEQRA]) and the availability of draft SPDES and Title V permits. Followingtechnical review and public comment, DEC granted final SPDES and Title V permits toDanskammer. Petitioner thereafter commenced two combined proceedings pursuant to CPLRarticle 78 and actions for declaratory judgment seeking various relief, including annulment of thenegative declaration under SEQRA and the final SPDES and Title V permits. Following joinderof issue, Supreme Court considered the two combined proceedings and actions together anddismissed them in a single judgment. Petitioner appeals, and we now affirm.

Contrary to petitioner's contention, DEC was not required to hold a public adjudicatoryhearing prior to issuing final SPDES and Title V permits. It was incumbent upon DEC, afterevaluating the permit applications and reviewing all comments submitted in response to them, to"determine whether or not to conduct a public hearing 'based on whether the evaluation orcomments raise substantive and significant issues relating to any findings or determinations[DEC] is required to make . . . , including the reasonable likelihood that [thepermits] will be denied or can be granted only with major modifications to the project' "(Matter of Eastern Niagara ProjectPower Alliance v New York State Dept. of Envtl. Conservation, 42 AD3d 857, 859[2007], quoting ECL 70-0119 [1]; see 6 NYCRR 621.8). The ultimate burden rested onpetitioner to show that its issues were "substantive and significant" enough to warrant a publichearing (6 NYCRR 624.4 [c] [4]; see Matter of Eastern Niagara Project Power Alliance vNew York State Dept. of Envtl. Conservation, 42 AD3d at 859).

In that regard, while petitioner raised a number of concerns regarding the draft SPDESpermit, it also acknowledged that the draft permit was largely identical to the existing permit (see e.g. Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. vJohnson, 52 AD3d 1072, 1072-1073 [2008], lv denied 11 NY3d 716 [2009]),one that DEC noted had only been issued after extensive administrative proceedings and anadjudicatory hearing. Moreover, to the extent that the draft SPDES permit modified the terms ofthe prior permit, those modifications reduced the impact of the station [*3]upon the river. The objection to the Title V permit amounted to therather obvious point that a station in service would create more atmospheric emissions than oneoffline. DEC issued a written response to petitioner's comments and, while it did makemodifications as a result of the concerns raised, it gave no reason to believe that those concernsmight have required extensive retooling of either permit or imperiled their issuance altogether.Accordingly, mindful as we are that our judgment should not be substituted for that of theagency, the determination that petitioner had failed to demonstrate the need for an adjudicatoryhearing was not arbitrary and capricious (see Matter of Raritan Baykeeper, Inc. v Martens, 142 AD3d 1083,1085-1086 [2016]; Matter of Eastern Niagara Project Power Alliance v New York State Dept.of Envtl. Conservation, 42 AD3d at 861).

Turning to the merits of petitioner's challenges to the various permits, we reiterate that we donot "substitute [our] judgment for that of the agency responsible for making the determination,. . . [and] ascertain only whether there is a rational basis for the decision or whetherit is arbitrary and capricious" (Flacke v Onondaga Landfill Sys., 69 NY2d 355, 363[1987]; see Matter of Department of Envtl. Protection of City of N.Y. v Department of Envtl.Conservation of State of N.Y., 120 AD2d 166, 169 [1986], lv denied 69 NY2d 921[1987]). As for the SPDES permit, petitioner claims that the discharge of warm water from thestation will cause surface water temperature near the discharge point to occasionally exceed theregulatory maximum of 90 degrees Fahrenheit and threaten marine life (see 6 NYCRR700.1 [a] [17]; 704.2 [b] [5] [i]). That being said, there is nothing inherently improper in"allow[ing] for ambient [temperature] above the criteria in small areas near outfalls" (EPA,Water Quality Standards Handbook: Second Edition at 5-1 [Aug. 1994], available athttps://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-06/documents/wqs-handbook-1994.pdf[accessed July 13, 2017]). New York has adopted such a "mixing zone" policy (see 6NYCRR 704.1 [b]; 704.3; see also 40 CFR 131.13), and such a zone will pass muster solong as it is defined in scope, does "not interfere with spawning areas, nursery areas and fishmigration routes" (6 NYCRR 704.3 [c]) and avoids lethality "in contravention of water qualitystandards to aquatic biota which may enter" it (6 NYCRR 704.3 [b]). Lethality, for purposes ofmixing zones, focuses upon the impacts of a mixing zone upon an entire population, not whetherthe water temperature in the zone will prove deadly to an individual organism (see 6NYCRR 704.1 [a]; EPA, Water Quality Standards Handbook: Second Edition at 5-6 [Aug.1994], available athttps://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-06/documents/wqs-handbook-1994.pdf[accessed July 13, 2017]).

DEC had before it a report disclosing the results of a thermal survey of the defined mixingzone, conducted in 2005, finding that the zone would "accommodate [all] water greater than 90[degrees Fahrenheit] at any point in time under all likely [station] operation scenarios andreceiving water conditions while respecting" the requirements of 6 NYCRR 704.3. In reachingthat conclusion, the survey found that maximum temperatures only had the potential to beexcessive during the summer months and, even then, would do so in shifting portions of themixing zone and would have no impact upon bottom-dwelling organisms where the temperaturewould be lower.[FN*] DECfurther noted that most fish in the area did not spawn during the summer [*4]months and that juvenile and adult fish are capable of detecting andavoiding water hot enough to stress them. The foregoing constitutes a rational basis from whichDEC could conclude that the mixing zone complies with 6 NYCRR 704.3.

With regard to the Title V permit, petitioner argues that the permitting process demanded anew source review, defined as "a pre-construction review to determine the appropriate airpollution controls" for a new or modified major stationary source of air pollution (Part 231 NewSource Review for New and Modified Facilities Frequently Asked Questions, NYS Departmentof Environmental Conservation, available at http://www.dec.ny.gov/chemical/63396.html[accessed July 13, 2017]; see 6 NYCRR part 231). DEC held that the review was notrequired here because the application involved "[t]he reissuance, recertification or extension ofany permit for previously approved activities which will be continued on the same site withoutmaterial change" (6 NYCRR 201-2.1 [b] [26]). "[R]eactivation of a permanently shutdownfacility will be treated as operation of a new source" for purposes of a new source review,however, and petitioner asserts that the station had been permanently shut down in the wake ofits closure due to storm damage (Matter of Monroe Electric Generating Plant EntergyLouisiana, Inc., Proposed Operating Permit, Petition No. 6-99-2, EPA Order at 8 [1999],available at https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2015-07/documents/ccaw_ord.pdf[accessed July 13, 2017]).

The question of "whether or not a shutdown should be treated as permanent depends on theintention of the owner or operator at the time of shutdown based on all facts and circumstances"(Matter of Monroe Electric Generating Plant Entergy Louisiana, Inc., Proposed OperatingPermit, Petition No. 6-99-2, EPA Order at 8), including "the amount of time the facility hasbeen out of operation, the reason for the shutdown, statements by the owner or operator regardingintent, cost and time required to reactivate the facility, status of permits, and ongoingmaintenance and inspections that have been conducted during shutdown" (Matter of MonroeElectric Generating Plant Entergy Louisiana, Inc., Proposed Operating Permit, Petition No.6-99-2, EPA Order at 9). The station here was shut down due to storm damage beyond theoperator's control and, following a period of standard maintenance and storm-related repairs,resumed operation less than two years later. The operator of the station continued to maintain thevarious permits required to run it and, indeed, applications to renew those permits lie at the heartof these proceedings. Moreover, while the former owner sought permission to sell the station to awinning auction bidder that intended to demolish it, the sale never occurred and was abandonedonce the financial and regulatory situation made continued operation of the station viable. DECrationally concluded, as a result, that there was no intent to permanently shut down the stationand that new source review was not required.

Petitioner's final contention is that DEC failed to comply with the requirements of SEQRA infinding that the permit renewals would have no significant effect upon the environment andissuing a negative declaration. DEC observed that the station's environmental impacts were notnew—notwithstanding the puzzling insistence of petitioner that the station's briefshutdown warranted treating them as such—and that the issuance of modified renewedpermits would lessen the existing impacts by, among other things, eliminating coal as a fuel[*5]source for the station's turbines. It is accordingly evident thatDEC "identified the relevant areas of environmental concern, took a hard look at them, and madea reasoned elaboration of the basis for its determination" (Matter of Chinese Staff & Workers' Assn. v Burden, 19 NY3d922, 924 [2012] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]). Thus, we are satisfied thatDEC satisfied its statutory responsibilities under SEQRA when it issued the negativedeclaration.

Egan Jr., J.P., Lynch, Clark and Aarons, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed,without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote *:Any thermal discharge must also"assure the protection and propagation of a balanced, indigenous population of shellfish, fish, andwildlife in and on the body of water" into which the discharge occurs, and petitioner argues thatsuch was not the case here (6 NYCRR 704.1 [a]). Petitioner's argument flies in the face of recordproof such as the results of a 1978 study of the thermal discharge's effect on fish, the 2005thermal survey and ongoing river monitoring, all of which reflect that the discharge does not posea problem to maintaining a balanced, indigenous population of aquatic life in the Hudson River.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.