| People v Swick |
| 2018 NY Slip Op 00720 [158 AD3d 1131] |
| February 2, 2018<> |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1]
| The People of the State of New York, Respondent, vChristopher Swick, Appellant. (Appeal No. 1.) |
Sessler Law PC, Geneseo (Steven D. Sessler of counsel), for defendant-appellant.
Gregory J. McCaffrey, District Attorney, Geneseo (Joshua J. Tonra of counsel), forrespondent.
Appeal from a judgment of the Livingston County Court (Dennis S. Cohen, J.), renderedJanuary 21, 2016. The judgment convicted defendant upon a jury verdict of, inter alia, grandlarceny in the fourth degree (three counts).
It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously affirmed.
Memorandum: Defendant appeals from two judgments convicting him following aconsolidated jury trial of, inter alia, three counts of grand larceny in the fourth degree (Penal Law§ 155.30 [8]), two counts of criminal possession of stolen property in the fourthdegree (§ 165.45 [5]), and two counts of unauthorized use of a vehicle in the thirddegree (§ 165.05 [1]). Defendant contends in both appeals that County Court erredin its handling of three jury notes in violation of People v O'Rama (78 NY2d 270 [1991]).With respect to the first jury note, defendant does not take issue with the response given by thecourt to the jury, but claims instead that the court erred in failing to read the note verbatim intothe record to counsel and the jury. "While a reading of the notes into the record is the betterpractice, it is not required where, as here, the record reflects that defendant received meaningfulnotice regarding the content of [the subject] note . . . and [that] he was able tomeaningfully participate in formulating the responses to the note[ ]" (People v Powell, 115 AD3d 998,1000-1001 [3d Dept 2014]; seegenerally People v Barnes, 139 AD3d 1371, 1372 [4th Dept 2016], lv denied 28NY3d 926 [2016]). Thus, we conclude that there was no O'Rama violation with respect tothe first jury note.
We conclude that the second and third jury notes required only ministerial responses fromthe court, i.e., providing the jury with requested items that were in evidence. "[T]he O'Ramaprocedure is not implicated when the jury's request is ministerial in nature and thereforerequires only a ministerial response" (People v Nealon, 26 NY3d 152, 161 [2015]), and defendant has notestablished that the second and third jury notes at issue contained any substantive inquiries. Thus,we reject defendant's contentions with respect to those jury notes (see People v Williams, 142 AD3d1360, 1362 [4th Dept 2016], lv denied 28 NY3d 1128 [2016]).
Finally, because it is impossible to commit the crime of grand larceny in the fourth degreeunder Penal Law § 155.30 (8) without concomitantly committing the crime ofunauthorized use of a vehicle in the third degree under section 165.05 (1), we agree withdefendant that counts three and four of indictment No. 256, charging the latter crime, must bedismissed because they are lesser inclusory concurrent counts of counts seven and nine ofindictment No. 112, charging the former crime (see generally People v Miller, 6 NY3d 295, 302 [2006]). Wetherefore modify the judgment accordingly. Present—Whalen, P.J., Smith, Lindley,NeMoyer and Curran, JJ.