| People v Thompson |
| 2018 NY Slip Op 02219 [159 AD3d 1281] |
| March 29, 2018 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| The People of the State of New York,Respondent, v John J. Thompson, Appellant. |
LaMarche Safranko Law PLLC, Clifton Park (Andrew R. Safranko of counsel), forappellant.
Jennifer M. Hollis, Special Prosecutor, Malone, for respondent.
Lynch, J. Appeal from a judgment of the County Court of Essex County (Ryan, J.), renderedMay 3, 2016, convicting defendant upon his plea of guilty of the crime of unlawful surveillancein the second degree (four counts).
Defendant, a teacher, was indicted on, among other things, 22 counts of unlawfulsurveillance in the second degree. The charges stemmed from defendant asking a student to stayin his home from March 28, 2015 through April 2, 2015 while he was out of town. Defendantdirected the student to sleep in the guest room and permitted her to invite friends over, includingher boyfriend, and also gave her permission to drink alcohol. While staying at defendant's home,the student found recording devices—one with a motion activated sensor—in theguest room. During the midst of jury selection, defendant pleaded guilty to four counts ofunlawful surveillance in the second degree, with the recognition that the People were free torequest and County Court was free to impose any legal sentence—i.e., no specificcommitment as to sentencing was made. The court further cautioned that the sentences could beconsecutive. Defendant also waived his right to appeal. In addition, orders of protection wereissued in favor of four individuals. County Court sentenced defendant to four prison terms of 1 to3 years, to run consecutively. Defendant appeals.
To the extent that defendant claims that the waiver of the right to appeal was not knowing,voluntary and intelligent, we disagree. Defendant acknowledged that he understood that he waswaiving his appellate rights, which were not automatically forfeited by the guilty [*2]plea, and subsequently executed a detailed written waiver of theright to appeal. Further, a review of the record fails to support defendant's contention that he wasin any way coerced or rushed into waiving his right to appeal. Defendant's challenge to thevoluntariness of the plea, although not precluded by the waiver of the right to appeal, isnevertheless unpreserved for our review as the record does not reflect that defendant made anappropriate postallocution motion (seePeople v Harris, 139 AD3d 1244, 1245-1246 [2016], lv denied 28 NY3d 930[2016]; People v Walker, 135 AD3d1244, 1244-1245 [2016]).
Next, defendant challenges the legality of the sentence, claiming that the imposition ofconsecutive sentences was not authorized because his conduct amounted to a single criminalact.[FN*] Penal Law§ 70.25 (2) authorizes the imposition of either concurrent or consecutive sentencesby the trial court, except that sentences must run concurrently "[w]hen more than one sentence ofimprisonment is imposed on a person for two or more offenses committed through a single act oromission, or through an act or omission which in itself constituted one of the offenses and alsowas a material element of the other." It is the People's burden to establish "the legality ofconsecutive sentencing by showing that the acts or omissions committed by [the] defendant wereseparate and distinct acts" (People v Laureano, 87 NY2d 640, 643 [1996] [internalquotation marks omitted]; see People vMcKnight, 16 NY3d 43, 48 [2010]). To that end, where, as here, a "defendant haspleaded guilty to one or more counts alleged in the indictment, [the People] may rely on theallegations of those counts as well as the facts adduced at the allocution" (People vLaureano, 87 NY2d at 644; see People v Mangarillo, 152 AD3d at 1062).
As is relevant here, "[a] person is guilty of unlawful surveillance in the second degree when:. . . [f]or his or her own, or another person's amusement, entertainment, or profit, orfor the purpose of degrading or abusing a person, he or she intentionally uses or installs, orpermits the utilization or installation of an imaging device to surreptitiously view, broadcast orrecord a person dressing or undressing or the sexual or other intimate parts of such person at aplace and time when such person has a reasonable expectation of privacy, without such person'sknowledge or consent" (Penal Law § 250.45 [1]). Although defendant focuses onthe installation of the recording device in support of his contention that there was a single act,"[t]he 'installation' element is in the alternative to 'uses' " (William C. Donnino, PracticeCommentaries, McKinney's Cons Laws of NY, Book 39, Penal Law § 250.45 at347). Here, the indictment and the information in the plea allocution set forth four specific datesregarding the unlawful surveillance—each of which defendant admitted. We find that thiswas sufficient to establish that the instances of unlawful surveillance were separate and distinctacts so as to permit the imposition of consecutive sentences (see e.g. People v Brahney, 29 NY3d 10, 15 [2017]; cf. People v Dean, 8 NY3d 929,931 [2007]; People v Mangarillo, 152 AD3d at 1063).
Defendant's remaining contentions, including his challenges to the sufficiency of the pleaallocution and the severity of the sentence, are precluded by the valid waiver of the right toappeal.
McCarthy, J.P., Clark, Aarons and Pritzker, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment isaffirmed.
Footnote *:A challenge to the legality of asentence is not precluded by a guilty plea or the waiver of the right to appeal (see People v Pacherille, 25 NY3d1021, 1023 [2015]; People vMangarillo, 152 AD3d 1061, 1061-1062 [2017]).