Matter of Chung Li
2018 NY Slip Op 07120 [165 AD3d 1105]
October 24, 2018
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 28, 2018


[*1]
 In the Matter of Chung Li, Deceased. Donald Edward Osborn,Respondent; Chun Ka Luk, Appellant.

Heller, Horowitz & Feit, P.C., New York, NY (Eli Feit and Stuart A. Blander ofcounsel), for appellant.

Reed Smith LLP, New York, NY (John B. Berringer and Geoffrey G. Young of counsel), forrespondent.

In a proceeding pursuant to SCPA 2103, inter alia, to discover property allegedly withheldfrom the estate of Chung Li, Chun Ka Luk, as administrator of the estate of Nancy Lee Luk,appeals from (1) an order of the Surrogate's Court, Queens County (Peter J. Kelly, S.), datedMarch 3, 2016, and (2) an order of the same court dated August 15, 2016. The order dated March3, 2016, insofar as appealed from, denied Chun Ka Luk's motion for summary judgmentdismissing the petition on the ground that it was time-barred, and granted the petitioner's motionfor summary judgment on the petition to the extent of finding that the estate of Chung Li has anownership interest in two New York corporations, Lee Tai Enterprises USA, Ltd., and 238-2407th Ave. Corp., and directing Chun Ka Luk to turn over to the petitioner any of the decedent'srecords or property, in Chun Ka Luk's possession, attributable to such interest. The order datedAugust 15, 2016, insofar as appealed from, denied Chun Ka Luk's cross motion for leave toreargue his motion for summary judgment.

Ordered that the appeal from the order dated August 15, 2016, is dismissed, as no appeal liesfrom an order denying reargument (seeViola v Blanco, 1 AD3d 506, 507 [2003]; Matter of Robinson, 30 AD2d 702[1968]); and it is further,

Ordered that the order dated March 3, 2016, is affirmed insofar as appealed from; and it isfurther,

Ordered that one bill of costs is awarded to the petitioner.

The petitioner, Donald Edward Osborn, as ancillary administrator of the estate of Chung Li(hereinafter the decedent), commenced this proceeding pursuant to SCPA 2103 against NancyLee Luk (hereinafter Nancy), the decedent's daughter, for discovery and delivery of certainproperty allegedly belonging to the decedent's estate. Specifically, the petitioner alleged thatNancy converted the decedent's stock interests in certain family businesses. During the pendencyof this proceeding, Nancy died, and her husband, Chun Ka Luk (hereinafter Luk), asadministrator of [*2]Nancy's estate, was substituted as therespondent to the petition.

On a prior appeal, this Court affirmed an order denying Luk's motion to dismiss the petitionon statute of limitations grounds (seeMatter of Chung Li, 95 AD3d 881 [2012]). Subsequently, Luk moved for summaryjudgment dismissing the petition on the ground that it is barred by the statute of limitations, andthe petitioner moved for summary judgment on the petition. In an order dated March 3, 2016, theSurrogate's Court denied Luk's motion. In addition, the court, inter alia, granted the petitioner'smotion to the extent that it found that the decedent's estate has an ownership interest in twospecific New York corporations (hereinafter the subject corporations) and directed Luk to turnover to the petitioner any of the decedent's records or property, in Luk's possession, that wereattributable to such interest. Luk appeals.

"The doctrine of the 'law of the case' is a rule of practice, an articulation of sound policy that,when an issue is once judicially determined, that should be the end of the matter as far as Judgesand courts of co-ordinate jurisdiction are concerned" (Martin v City of Cohoes, 37 NY2d162, 165 [1975]). "The doctrine applies only to legal determinations that were necessarilyresolved on the merits in [a] prior decision, and to the same questions presented in the samecase" (RPG Consulting, Inc. vZormati, 82 AD3d 739, 740 [2011] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; see Ramanathan v Aharon, 109 AD3d529, 530 [2013]; Erickson v CrossReady Mix, Inc., 98 AD3d 717, 717 [2012]). It bars reconsideration of issues whichwere raised and determined against a party or which could have been raised on a prior appeal (see Czernicki v Lawniczak, 103 AD3d769, 770 [2013]; Moran Enters.,Inc. v Hurst, 96 AD3d 914, 916 [2012]; Stone v Stone, 39 AD3d 534, 535 [2007]). Luk's argumentsconcerning the statute of limitations were previously raised and decided against him on the priorappeal in this matter. Therefore, reconsideration of those issues is barred by the doctrine of thelaw of the case.

Further, we agree with the Surrogate's Court's determination to grant the petitioner's motionfor summary judgment to the extent of finding that the decedent's estate has an ownership interestin the subject corporations and directing Luk to turn over to the petitioner any records orproperty, in Luk's possession, attributable to such interest. Contrary to Luk's contention, thepetitioner met his burden of establishing the decedent's interest in the subject corporations(see generally United States Radiator Corp. v State of New York, 208 NY 144, 149[1913]; Estate of Essig v 5670 58 St.Holding Corp., 50 AD3d 948, 949 [2008]; Szalkowski v Asbestospray Corp.,259 AD2d 867, 868 [1999]; Tillman v Lincoln Warehouse Corp., 72 AD2d 40, 44[1979]). In response to the petitioner's prima facie showing, Luk failed to raise a triable issue offact as to whether the decedent gifted his interest in the subject corporations to Nancy (seeMatter of Lefft, 44 NY2d 915, 918 [1978]; Matter of Kaminsky, 17 AD2d 690, 691[1962]).

Luk's remaining contentions are without merit. Mastro, J.P., Sgroi, Maltese and BrathwaiteNelson, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.