Matter of Norton v Town of Islip
2018 NY Slip Op 08308 [167 AD3d 624]
December 5, 2018
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, January 30, 2018


[*1]
 In the Matter of Howard Norton, Appellant,
v
Town ofIslip et al., Respondents. Erin A. Sidaras et al., Nonparty Respondents.

Twomey, Latham, Shea, Kelley Dubin & Quartararo LLP, Riverhead, NY (Bryan C.Van Cott and Alexandra Halsey-Storch of counsel), for appellant.

Lewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP, Islandia, NY (Robert A. Lifson, Jessica Klotz, and RosaM. Feeney of counsel), for respondents-respondents and nonparty-respondents.

In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to compel the production of certain recordspursuant to the Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law art 6), the petitioner appealsfrom an order of the Supreme Court, Suffolk County (Joseph A. Santorelli, J.), dated July 26,2017. The order granted the motion of the Town of Islip, Patricia Pascuitti, Erin A. Sidaras, andPierce Fox Cohalan, in effect, to dismiss the proceeding insofar as asserted against PatriciaPascuitti, and, in effect, to deny the petitioner's motion to adjudicate the Town of Islip, PatriciaPascuitti, Erin A. Sidaras, and Pierce Fox Cohalan in contempt of court for failure to complywith a judgment of the same court (Michael F. Mullen, J.) entered January 31, 2006, insofar asthat motion sought relief against Patricia Pascuitti, Erin A. Sidaras, and Pierce Fox Cohalan.

Ordered that the order is reversed, on the law, with costs, and the motion of the Town ofIslip, Patricia Pascuitti, Erin A. Sidaras, and Pierce Fox Cohalan, in effect, to dismiss theproceeding insofar as asserted against Patricia Pascuitti and, in effect, to deny the petitioner'smotion to adjudicate the Town of Islip, Patricia Pascuitti, Erin A. Sidaras, and Pierce FoxCohalan in contempt of court for failure to comply with a judgment of the same court (MichaelF. Mullen, J.) entered January 31, 2006, insofar as that motion sought relief against PatriciaPascuitti, Erin A. Sidaras, and Pierce Fox Cohalan, is denied.

In July 2003, the petitioner commenced this proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 tocompel the Town of Islip and Patricia Pascuitti, Michelle Remsen, and Richard Hoffman, in theircapacity as Town officials, to comply with his requests pursuant to the Freedom of InformationLaw (Public Officers Law art 6 [hereinafter FOIL]). After this Court determined that denial of theFOIL requests was improper (see Matterof Norton v Town of Islip, 17 AD3d 468 [2005]), the Supreme Court (Michael F.Mullen, J.), in a judgment entered January 31, 2006, inter alia, directed the production of certaindocuments. Thereafter, Erin A. Sidaras, who was then an Assistant Town Attorney of counsel toPierce Fox Cohalan, who was then Town Attorney, provided documents to the petitioner's [*2]attorney. The petitioner was dissatisfied with the response,contending that certain requested documents had not been produced and others had beenprovided with improper redactions.

Thereafter, the petitioner moved to adjudicate the Town and Pascuitti, Sidaras, and Cohalan(hereinafter collectively the individual movants) in contempt of court for failing to comply withthe judgment entered January 31, 2006. The petitioner also sought to impose sanctions and anaward of an attorney's fee. The Town and the individual movants cross-moved to imposesanctions upon the petitioner and his attorney for engaging in frivolous conduct. After an incamera review of the Town's records to determine whether they were the subject of thepetitioner's FOIL requests, the Supreme Court, in an order dated July 26, 2007, denied the motionand the cross motion, finding that the redactions did not violate the terms of the judgment. On anappeal by the petitioner and cross appeal by the Town and the individual movants, this Courtreversed the order and remitted the matter for a hearing to determine whether the Town and theindividual movants failed to comply with the judgment entered January 31, 2006, by virtue of"nonproduction of certain documents" (Matter of Norton v Town of Islip, 70 AD3d 833 [2010]).

Although the contempt hearing was scheduled to take place in 2013, it has still not been helddue to, inter alia, proceedings regarding the disqualification of the petitioner's attorney based onthe advocate-witness rule (see Matter of Norton v Town of Islip, 167 AD3d 622 [2018] [decided herewith]). In April 2017, the Town and the individual movants moved, ineffect, to dismiss the proceeding insofar as asserted against Pascuitti, and, in effect, to deny thepetitioner's motion to hold the Town and the individual movants in contempt of court insofar asthat motion sought relief against the individual movants, arguing, among other things, that thepetitioner may only seek sanctions against the Town for the alleged contempt. In the orderappealed from, the Supreme Court granted the motion. We reverse.

"An appellate court's resolution of an issue on a prior appeal constitutes the law of the caseand is binding on the Supreme Court, as well as on the appellate court . . . [and]operates to foreclose re-examination of [the] question absent a showing of subsequent evidenceor change of law" (J-Mar Serv. Ctr., Inc.v Mahoney, Connor & Hussey, 45 AD3d 809, 809 [2007] [citations and internalquotation marks omitted]; see US Bank,N.A. v Morrison, 160 AD3d 679, 680 [2018]; Madison Acquisition Group, LLC v 7614 Fourth Real Estate Dev., LLC,134 AD3d 683, 684 [2015]). On the prior appeal, this Court considered, and rejected, thearguments that Pascuitti was no longer a proper party to this proceeding and that the petitionercould not seek relief against the individual movants in the contempt motion (see generallyMcCain v Dinkins, 84 NY2d 216, 228-230 [1994]; Matter of McCormick v Axelrod,59 NY2d 574, 583 [1983]). The Town and the individuals movants have failed to make asufficient showing to warrant reexamination of these issues (see Breidbart v Wiesenthal, 136 AD3d 851, 851-852 [2016]; Wells Fargo Bank Minn., N.A. v Perez,70 AD3d 817, 817 [2010]; Seamanv Wyckoff Hgts. Med. Ctr., Inc., 51 AD3d 1002, 1003 [2008]). Accordingly, based onthe law of the case doctrine, we disagree with the Supreme Court's determination granting themotion (see Matter of 24 Franklin Ave.R.E. Corp. v Heaship, 101 AD3d 1034, 1036 [2012]; Matter of Haberman v Zoning Bd. ofAppeals of City of Long Beach, 94 AD3d 997, 1000 [2012]). Austin, J.P., Roman, Sgroiand LaSalle, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.