| Matter of Patrolmen's Benevolent Assn. of the City of N.Y. v deBlasio |
| 2019 NY Slip Op 03265 [171 AD3d 636] |
| April 30, 2019 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1](April 30, 2019)
| In the Matter of Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the Cityof New York, Appellant, v Bill de Blasio et al.,Respondents. |
Kasowitz Benson Torres LLP, Pelham (Michael J. Bowe of counsel), for appellant.
Zachary W. Carter, Corporation Counsel, New York (Aaron M. Bloom of counsel), forrespondent.
Ballard Spahr LLP, New York (Thomas B. Sullivan of counsel), for amici curiae.
Orders, Supreme Court, New York County (Shlomo Hagler, J.), entered May 7, 2018, whichdenied the petition and granted respondents' cross motion to dismiss the petition and complaint inthis hybrid CPLR article 78 proceeding to challenge the City's public release of policedepartment body-worn camera footage without a court order or the relevant officers' consent,pursuant to Civil Rights Law § 50-a, and denied petitioner's motion for apreliminary injunction, unanimously affirmed, without costs.
We affirm the denial of the petition and dismissal of the proceeding on grounds differentfrom those of Supreme Court. The court held that petitioner could not maintain this hybrid actionbecause there is no private right of action under Civil Rights Law § 50-a. Weconclude that the fact that the statute does not provide a private right of action does not precludereview of petitioner's request for injunctive relief in an article 78 proceeding, because the statutecreates protected rights (for police officers) and does not explicitly prohibit a private right ofaction or otherwise manifest a clear legislative intent to negate review (see Matter of DairyleaCoop. v Walkley, 38 NY2d 6, 10-11 [1975]; Delgado v New York City Hous. Auth., 66 AD3d 607, 608 [1stDept 2009]; see also Matter of EastRamapo Cent. Sch. Dist. v King, 29 NY3d 938 [2017]; Patrolmen's BenevolentAssn. of the City of N.Y., Inc. v de Blasio, 2015 NY Slip Op 32829[U] [Sup Ct, NY County2015]).
Nevertheless, the petition must be denied. In order to determine whether something is a"personnel record" under Civil Rights Law § 50-a, the "threshold criterion" iswhether the documents (or a summary of the documents) are "of significance to a superior inconsidering continued employment or promotion" (Matter of Luongo v Records Access Officer, Civilian Complaint ReviewBd., 150 AD3d 13, 19 [1st Dept 2017], lv denied 30 NY3d 908 [2017], quotingMatter of Prisoners' Legal Servs. of N.Y. v New York State Dept. of Correctional Servs.,73 NY2d 26, 32 [1988]).
The Court of Appeals has further clarified that whether a document "containing personal,employment-related information about a public employee," that is under the control of theagency, and "relied upon in evaluating the employee's performance" is covered by Civil RightsLaw § 50-a "depends upon its nature and its use in evaluating an officer'sperformance" (Matter of Prisoners' Legal Servs., 73 NY2d at 31-32). Moreover, the Courtof Appeals has held that, in the context of a FOIL disclosure of an officer's personnel records,preventing such disclosure requires more than merely demonstrating that the document "may beused" to evaluate performance (Matter of Daily Gazette Co. v City of Schenectady, 93NY2d 145, 157 [1999]).
Petitioner argues that the body-worn camera was designed in part for performance evaluationpurposes and is clearly "of significance" to superiors in considering employment or promotion.Petitioner also suggests that a finding that body-worn camera footage is not a personnel recordwould result in an unprecedented invasion of privacy.
While we recognize petitioner's valid concerns about invasion of privacy and threats to thesafety of police officers, we are tasked with considering the record's general "nature and use," andnot solely whether it may be contemplated for use in a performance evaluation. Otherwise, thatcould sweep into the purview of section 50-a many police records that are an expected orrequired part of investigations or performance evaluations, such as arrest reports, stop reports,summonses, and accident reports, which clearly are not in the nature of personnel records so as tobe covered by section 50-a.
We find that given its nature and use, the body-worn camera footage at issue is not apersonnel record covered by the confidentiality and disclosure requirements of section 50-a(see Matter of Prisoners' Legal Servs. of N.Y. v New York State Dept. of CorrectionalServs., 73 NY2d 26, 32 [1988]). The purpose of body-worn camera footage is for use in theservice of other key objectives of the program, such as transparency, accountability, and publictrust-building.
Although the body-worn camera program was designed, in part, for performance evaluationpurposes, and supervisors are required, at times, to review such footage for the purpose ofevaluating performance, the footage being released here is not primarily generated for, nor usedin connection with, any pending disciplinary charges or promotional processes. Matter of New York Civ. Liberties Union vNew York City Police Dept. (32 NY3d 556 [2018]), which involved disciplinarymatters, does not constrain this analysis. The footage, here, rather, is more akin to arrest or stopreports, and not records primarily generated for disciplinary and promotional purposes. To holdotherwise would defeat the purpose of the body-worn camera program to promote increasedtransparency and public accountability.
We have considered petitioner's remaining arguments and find them unavailing.Concur—Richter, J.P., Manzanet-Daniels, Tom, Gesmer, Kern, JJ.
The Decision and Order of this Court entered herein on February 19, 2019 (169 AD3d 518[2019]) is hereby recalled and vacated (see 2019 NY Slip Op 69181[U] [2019] [decidedsimultaneously herewith]).