| People v Perkins |
| 2019 NY Slip Op 06516 [175 AD3d 1327] |
| September 11, 2019 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| The People of the State of New York,Respondent, v Thomas E. Perkins, Appellant. |
Zachary Margulis-Ohnuma, New York, NY (Adam Elewa of counsel), for appellant.
John M. Ryan, Acting District Attorney, Kew Gardens, NY (John M. Castellano, JohnnetteTraill, and Sharon Y. Brodt of counsel), for respondent.
Nathan Freed Wessler, New York, NY (Esha Bhandari, Hugh Handeyside, ChristopherDunn, and Aadhithi Padmanabhan of counsel; Adam Schwartz, Sophia Cope, and Aaron Mackeyon the brief), for amici curiae American Civil Liberties Union and others.
Appeal by the defendant from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Queens County (RichardBuchter, J.), rendered April 6, 2017, convicting him of possessing a sexual performance by achild (two counts), and imposing sentence. The appeal brings up for review the denial, after ahearing (Ronald D. Hollie, J.), of those branches of the defendant's omnibus motion which wereto suppress physical evidence and statements he made to law enforcement officials, and thedenial (Richard Buchter, J.), without a hearing, of the defendant's motion pursuant to CPL 30.30to dismiss the indictment on the ground that he was denied the statutory right to a speedytrial.
Ordered that the matter is remitted to the Supreme Court, Queens County, to hear and reporton the defendant's motion pursuant to CPL 30.30 to dismiss the indictment on the ground that hewas denied the statutory right to a speedy trial, and the appeal is held in abeyance in the interim.The Supreme Court, Queens County, is to conduct the hearing and file its report with allconvenient speed.
The defendant contends that the Supreme Court erred in summarily denying his motionpursuant to CPL 30.30 to dismiss the indictment on the ground that he was denied the statutoryright to a speedy trial because the People failed to demonstrate, as a matter of law, theirentitlement to exclude the period from May 19, 2014, through July 8, 2014.
In felony cases, the People are required to be ready for trial within six months after thecommencement of the criminal action (see CPL 30.30 [1] [a]; People v Allard,113 AD3d 624, 625 [2014]). A defendant seeking dismissal of the indictment on speedy trialgrounds under CPL 30.30 meets his or her initial burden on the motion simply by alleging thatthe People failed to declare readiness within the statutorily prescribed period (see People vBeasley, 16 NY3d 289, 292 [2011]; People v Goode, 87 NY2d 1045, 1047 [1996])."[O]nce the defendant has shown the existence of a delay greater than six months, the burden ofproving that certain periods within that time should be excluded falls upon the People"(People v Berkowitz, 50 NY2d 333, 349 [1980]; see People v Santos, 68 NY2d859, 861 [1986]; People v Allard, 113 AD3d at 625).
Here, the defendant sustained his initial burden on the motion by alleging that a period ofunexcused delay in excess of six months had elapsed since the date that he was arraigned on thefelony complaint (see CPL 30.30 [1] [a]). In opposition, the People failed to conclusivelydemonstrate with "unquestionable documentary proof" that any periods within that time shouldbe excluded (CPL 210.45 [5] [c]; see People v Berkowitz, 50 NY2d at 349; People vAllard, 113 AD3d at 626). Moreover, the "court action sheet" provided to this Court onappeal, of which we may take judicial notice (see People v Dinkins, 261 AD2d 171, 172[1999]; People v Chu Zhu, 245 AD2d 296, 296 [1997]; see also Fisch, New YorkEvidence § 1065 [2d ed 1977]), contained only an ambiguous notation purportedlyregarding the defendant's alleged waiver of his CPL 30.30 rights from May 5, 2014, to July 8,2014 (see CPL 210.45 [5] [c]; People v Berkowitz, 50 NY2d at 347-349).Accordingly, the matter must be remitted to the Supreme Court, Queens County, for a hearingand thereafter a report on the defendant's motion (see CPL 210.45 [5]; People vSantos, 68 NY2d at 861; People v Berkowitz, 50 NY2d at 349; People vAllard, 113 AD3d at 626; People v Smith, 245 AD2d 534, 534 [1997]; People vMackenzie, 231 AD2d 740, 741 [1996]; People v Robbins, 207 AD2d 565, 566[1994]; People v Manescala, 138 AD2d 633, 633 [1988]).
We decide no other issues at this juncture. Scheinkman, P.J., Maltese, Connolly andBrathwaite Nelson, JJ., concur.