| People v DePalo |
| 2020 NY Slip Op 06069 [187 AD3d 649] |
| October 27, 2020 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1]
| The People of the State of New York,Respondent, v Robert DePalo, Appellant. |
Law Offices of Amy Adelson, LLC, New York (Amy Adelson of counsel), forappellant.
Cyrus R. Vance, Jr., District Attorney, New York (John T. Hughes of counsel), forrespondent.
Judgment, Supreme Court, New York County (Ronald A. Zweibel, J. at initial motion forletters rogatory; Mark Dwyer, J. at subsequent motions for letters rogatory or commissions; JuanM. Merchan, J. at jury trial and sentencing), rendered September 4, 2018, as amended October 3,2018, convicting defendant of scheme to defraud in the first degree (two counts), securities fraud(five counts), money laundering in the first and second degrees, criminal tax fraud in the secondand third degrees, grand larceny in the first degree, and grand larceny in the second degree (twocounts), and sentencing him to an aggregate term of 7 to 21 years, unanimously affirmed.
The court providently exercised its discretion in warning defendant that if he introducedevidence that he used legitimate sources of income, this might have the effect of opening thedoor to otherwise-inadmissible evidence that he improperly took funds from companies that werenot the subject of charges in the indictment (see People v Massie, 2 NY3d 179, 183-184[2004]). The court did not preclude defendant from introducing the evidence at issue, but onlywarned him of the possibility that the evidence might cause his uncharged crimes to becomerelevant.
Although defendant challenges the court's rulings concerning whether a prospective defensewitness's fact testimony would have implicated an advice-of-counsel defense, thereby waivingdefendant's attorney-client privilege, these challenges are moot because the witness invoked hisFifth Amendment right not to testify at trial. The record fails to support defendant's claim that, ina colloquy about the prospective witness's testimony about a document, the People compelled thewitness to assert his privilege against self-incrimination by threatening a perjury prosecution(see People v Siegel, 87 NY2d 536, 542-543 [1995]). In any event, defendant's argumentsare unavailing on the merits.
The court providently exercised its discretion in finding that defendant failed to lay thenecessary foundation to admit certain business records. Counsel did not sufficiently rebut thePeople's evidence that a corporate resolution dated September 2010 was actually created andbackdated in July 2013, resulting in it having no value. Although defendant sought toauthenticate the resolution through the testimony of the above-discussed prospective witness whoexercised his privilege against self-incrimination, we find, as previously noted, that the Peopledid not improperly prevent the witness from testifying. Defendant also failed to establish that ageneral ledger and an "ICAAP Report" (a British regulatory filing) were made "within areasonable time" (CPLR 4518 [a]) after the transactions at issue (see e.g. Standard Textile Co.v National Equip. Rental, 80 AD2d 911, 911 [2d Dept 1981]). We have considered andrejected defendant's remaining arguments concerning documents offered by the defense andrelated matters.
Defendant's arguments that the court should have issued letters rogatory (CPLR 3108) orcommissions (CPL 680.20 [1]) are moot as to a witness who testified at trial, and defendant'sarguments to the contrary are unpersuasive. As to the witnesses at issue who did not testify,assuming, without deciding, that letters rogatory may be issued in criminal cases and that thesame standard is applicable as in civil cases, we find that the respective motion courtsprovidently exercised their discretion in declining to issue letters rogatory or commissions, sincedefendant failed to show that the witnesses would provide material testimony warranting thoseextraordinary remedies (see generally People v Carter, 37 NY2d 234, 239 [1975]).
The court properly exercised its discretion in imposing reasonable limits on defendant'scross-examination of the People's witness, and none of the court's rulings or actions depriveddefendant of a fair trial.
Defendant's constitutional arguments relating to the court's above-discussed rulings regardingevidence sought to be introduced by the defense or limitations on cross-examination are withoutmerit (see generally Crane v Kentucky, 476 US 683, 689-690 [1986]; Delaware v VanArsdall, 475 US 673, 678-679 [1986]).
Defendant's arguments concerning the form and content of the testimony of the People'sexpert financial analyst are unpreserved and we decline to review them in the interest of justice.As an alternative holding, we reject them on the merits.
We perceive no basis for reducing the sentence. Concur—Kapnick, J.P., Webber,González, Moulton, JJ.