People v Weeks
2020 NY Slip Op 06827 [188 AD3d 1420]
November 19, 2020
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 30, 2020


[*1]
 The People of the State of New York,Respondent,
v
Allen Weeks, Appellant.

Noreen McCarthy, Keene Valley, for appellant.

Meagan K. Galligan, Acting District Attorney, Monticello, for respondent.

Lynch, J. Appeal from a judgment of the County Court of Sullivan County (McGuire, J.),rendered May 11, 2018, (1) which revoked defendant's probation and imposed a sentence ofimprisonment, and (2) convicting defendant upon his guilty plea of the crime of failure to registeran Internet identifier as a sex offender.

Defendant, a registered sex offender, was convicted in 2006 of failure to register as a sexoffender, then a misdemeanor. In 2011, he was convicted of the reduced charge of attemptedfailing to register as a sex offender, as a felony. In 2016, he was convicted upon his guilty plea ofthe felony of failing to timely provide an updated photograph under the Sex OffenderRegistration Act (see Correction Law art 6-C [hereinafter SORA]), for which he wassentenced to five years of probation, the first six months to be served in jail, and conditions ofprobation were imposed (see Correction Law §§ 168-f [2] [b-3];168-t). Then, in 2017, after probation officials were notified that an unregistered Facebookaccount with pictures and a video recording of defendant was discovered under an alias, a searchof defendant's residence disclosed pornography, marihuana and drug paraphernalia. Defendantwas charged in felony complaints with failing to register the Facebook alias as required byCorrection Law § 168-f (4) and criminal possession of marihuana in the fourthdegree. Thereafter, defendant was also charged in a petition with violating several conditions ofhis probation by violating state laws as charged in the complaints, possessing pornography andfailing to comply with SORA requirements.

Defendant accepted the terms of a plea agreement resolving all charges. Pursuant to theagreement, defendant waived indictment and consented to be prosecuted by a superior courtinformation (hereinafter SCI) and waived his right to appeal. He admitted that he was a registeredsex offender and had previously been convicted of failing to register as a sex offender, as chargedin a special information. Defendant then pleaded guilty as charged in the SCI to a felony chargeof failing to register an Internet identifier as a sex offender in violation of Correction Law§§ 168-f (4) and 168-t, admitting that he had created the Facebook accountusing an alias and was aware of his obligation to register that Internet identifier but had failed todo so. Defendant also waived a hearing and admitted that, as charged, he had violated theconditions of his probation by possessing pornography and by having an active Facebook accountusing an unregistered alias to identify himself. Consistent with the terms of the agreement,County Court found that defendant had violated the conditions of his probation, revoked thesentence of probation and imposed a prison sentence of 1 to 3 years, to be served concurrentlywith a prison term of 2 to 6 years imposed upon his conviction of failing to register an Internetidentifier as a sex offender. Defendant appeals.

We affirm. Defendant argues that the waiver of indictment is invalid and the SCI isjurisdictionally defective in that they do not set forth the specific date, approximate time andplace where the crime occurred, information required by CPL 195.20. This jurisdictional claimsurvives defendant's guilty plea and unchallenged appeal waiver (see People v Guerrero, 28 NY3d110, 116 [2016]; People vMathis, 185 AD3d 1094, 1096 [2020]). The omission of such "non-elemental factualinformation" does not, however, render the waiver of indictment jurisdictionally defective orrequire dismissal of the SCI (People v Lang, 34 NY3d 545, 569 [2019]; see People v King, 184 AD3d 909,910 [2020]; People vMorgan-Smith, 182 AD3d 923, 924-925 [2020], lv denied 35 NY3d 1047[2020]; People v Shindler, 179AD3d 1306, 1307 [2020]). Both the waiver and the SCI contained the name of the offensewith which he was being charged and the date by which the obligation to register the Internetidentifier was violated; those documents, together with the felony complaint, provided defendantwith adequate notice of the date and location, i.e., the precise address where the offense occurred,namely, defendant's residence. As the omission of the approximate time of the charged offensewas a nonjurisdictional defect, and defendant raised no objections before County Court,defendant's challenge was forfeited by his guilty plea (see People v Cruz, 186 AD3d 932, 933 [2020], lv denied 35 NY3d 1112 [2020]; People v Morgan-Smith, 182 AD3d at 925; People vShindler, 179 AD3d at 1307; Peoplev Elric YY., 179 AD3d 1304, 1305 [2020]). We find no merit to defendant's challengeto designating his residence as the "place" of the offense of failing to register his Internetidentifier (CPL 195.20), as this is the address that he was required to register as a sex offender(see Correction Law § 168-f [4]; see also CPL 20.40 [2] [c]; [3]; People v Stedge, 135 AD3d 1174,1175 [2016]).

Defendant also challenges the SCI as jurisdictionally defective in that, he argues, it failed tocharge him with a crime, a claim that survives his waiver of appeal and guilty plea (see People v Coss, 178 AD3d 25,27 [2019]). Pursuant to Correction Law § 168-f (4), as relevant here, a sex offenderis required to register with the Division of Criminal Justice Services "no later than [10] calendardays after any change of . . . [I]nternet identifiers that such offender uses." AnInternet identifier is defined as "electronic mail addresses and designations used for thepurposes of chat, instant messaging, social networking or other similar [I]nternetcommunication" (Correction Law § 168-a [18] [emphases added]). Although aFacebook account itself is not an Internet identifier, defendant's alias or "designation" used tocreate and access his Facebook account, and to identify himself to and interact with other userson this "social networking" site, is an Internet identifier that defendant admittedly failed toregister (see People v Ellis, 33NY3d 582, 584-586 [2019]). Indeed, "the name one uses to interact with other users onFacebook—such as a screen name, pseudonym or alias—may be an Internetidentifier that must be disclosed to [the Division of Criminal Justice Services] if it is a'designation[ ] used for the purposes of chat, instant messaging, social networking or othersimilar [I]nternet communication' " (id. at 585, quoting Correction Law§ 168-a [18]). Contrary to defendant's claim, the SCI correctly alleged that theomission constituting the offense was the failure to register an Internet identifier used by him toaccess and identify himself on the Facebook account that he created and maintained, and did notimproperly premise the charge on his failure to register the Facebook account itself. Thus, theSCI charged defendant with conduct that constitutes a crime (cf. People v Ellis, 33 NY3dat 584, 586).

With regard to defendant's contention that the SCI failed to allege all of the elements of theoffense, the SCI incorporated by reference the specific statutory provision violated, CorrectionLaw § 168-f (4), and the underlying specific omission supporting the charge. Thisincorporation "constitute[d] allegations of all of the elements of the crime charged" as well as"the statutory definitions of those elements," warranting rejection of this jurisdictional challenge(People v Edwards, 180 AD3d1111, 1111-1112 [2020] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted], lv denied35 NY3d 969 [2020]; see People v Mathis, 185 AD3d at 1096). The SCI was not requiredto further list all of the elements of the offense, such as defendant's knowledge of the registryrequirement in issue (see People vHaddock, 48 AD3d 969, 970-971 [2008], lv dismissed 12 NY3d 854 [2009]).Defendant's additional challenge to the factual sufficiency and specificity of the SCI isnonjurisdictional and, as such, was foreclosed by his guilty plea, and is also unpreserved (see People v Gannon, 167 AD3d1163, 1164 [2018]; People vDubois, 150 AD3d 1562, 1564 [2017]; see also CPL 200.15, 200.50 [7]).

Further, the SCI was not defective for failing to allege that defendant had a prior convictionfor failing to register. To the contrary, the People appropriately filed a special informationalleging defendant's prior felony conviction for failing to register under SORA, which raised thepresent offense to a class D felony (see Correction Law § 168-t). Defendantadmitted the prior conviction during the plea allocution, as required by the plea agreement. Thefact of the prior conviction was correctly omitted from the SCI (see CPL 200.60 [1]; [3][a]). Finally, defendant's challenge to his probation violation is based upon the same argumentsregarding the SCI that we have already rejected, and his remaining claims similarly lackmerit.

Garry, P.J., Egan Jr., Clark and Colangelo, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment isaffirmed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.