| People v Adams | i
| 2020 NY Slip Op 20041 [66 Misc 3d 918] [66 Misc 3d 918] |
| February 7, 2020 |
| Morris, J. |
| Supreme Court, Queens County |
| As corrected through Wednesday, April 22, 2020 |
[*1]
| The People of the State of New York,Plaintiff, v Jaquan Adams, Defendant. |
Supreme Court, Queens County, February 7, 2020
Queens Defenders (Christopher Van Zele of counsel) fordefendant.
Melinda Katz, District Attorney (Rachel Buchter andLauren Reilly of counsel), for plaintiff.
The court, on its own motion, rescinds the prior decision and order dated February 6,2020, and replaces it with this decision and order in its place and stead.
In an indictment filed July 8, 2019, the defendant, Jaquan Adams, is charged withtwo counts of criminal possession of a weapon in the second degree (Penal Law§ 265.03 [1] [b]; [3]), criminal possession of a weapon in the third degree(Penal Law § 265.02 [1]), and menacing in the second degree (Penal Law§ 120.14 [1]). The defendant now challenges the People's certificate ofcompliance and statement of readiness dated January 24, 2020, on the grounds that thePeople's disclosure was insufficient and not proper. Upon oral argument, and a review ofthe relevant documents/items in dispute, email exchanges between the parties, and thePeople's written response to the defendant's demands, for the following reasons and withthe additional discovery ordered as set forth in the following decision, the People'scertificate of compliance and statement of readiness, dated January 24, 2020, are deemedvalid.
The Parties' Duty to Diligently Confer with Each Other
Pursuant to CPL 245.35, the parties are ordered to diligently confer with each otherto reach an accommodation as to any dispute prior to seeking a ruling from the court. Tothat end, prior to the oral argument held on January 30, 2020, the parties were required todiscuss any discovery disputes in order to resolve any outstanding issues. Going forward,the parties are reminded of their obligation to confer with each other to reach a resolutionprior to seeking [*2]judicial intervention.
Contact Information Properly Disclosed
Pursuant to CPL 245.20 (1) (c), the People are required to turn over the names and"adequate contact information" for the witnesses they intend to call at trial. The People,as part of their automatic disclosure, have provided the names and personal emailaddresses of said witnesses to the defendant.[FN1] Thedefendant alleges, despite not having attempted to reach{**66Misc 3d at 921} any witnesses in this case, that such information is insufficientand demands telephone numbers and/or better contact information.
[1] The court finds that the People have properly met their burden inproviding adequate contact information for the witnesses they intend to call at trial. In theyear 2020, where electronic communication is widely used and available, email addressesfor the witnesses provide an appropriate balance between the defendant's rights tomeaningful discovery in order to defend against the crimes for which he/she is accused,and the privacy rights of victims and witnesses to crimes. Moreover, it cannot bereasonably inferred that the legislature intended the statute to require that the Peopleprovide such personal information (i.e., home, cellular or work telephone numbers) forall civilian witnesses.
Electronic Audio Recordings
Pursuant to CPL 245.20 (1) (g), the People are required to disclose, within 15 days ofa defendant's arraignment, any tapes or electronic recordings in their possession that theyintend to use at trial. In the instant case, the People have provided, among other forms ofelectronic communications, approximately 200 electronic recordings of calls made by thedefendant while housed at a facility operated by the New York City Department ofCorrection (Rikers calls), with a general statement that, at this stage of the case, theyintend to seek to introduce all recordings, subject to admissibility issues. The Peoplehave further asserted that due to the voluminous nature of said calls, it would not bepossible or reasonable in the time restraints of CPL 245.10 (1) (a) for them to be able tonarrow down the exact calls, if any, they intend to use at trial. The defendant argues thatthis is insufficient under the statute.
[2] While not expressly stated on the record it appears that the People areseeking a modification pursuant to CPL 245.70 (2), which allows the court to alter thetime periods for discovery imposed upon a showing of good cause. In the instant case,such good cause has been met. Here, there are close to 200 Rikers calls provided and itwould be next to impossible for them to be reviewed in order to determine which theywould actually seek to introduce at trial within the time restraints required by the statute.As such, the time period in which to{**66 Misc 3d at922} identify which of these approximately 200 Rikers calls they will seek tointroduce at trial is modified and the People are ordered to provide a list of specificRikers calls they will seek to introduce, if any, at least 30 days prior to the first scheduledtrial date.[FN2] Itis further ordered that this delay in disclosure does not affect the People's certificate ofcompliance and statement of readiness dated [*3]January24, 2020.
Notes on the Envelope Containing the "Cigarette Butt" Vouchered asEvidence
During the compliance conference, the defendant alleged that the People failed toturn over, as part of their automatic discovery, a copy of the envelope used to storeevidence recovered in this case, which purportedly contains markings or notes from theofficer who vouchered the evidence. In response, the People state that they haveprovided a copy of an inventory sheet which details the markings, but not the note itself,as no copy was readily available and the property was vouchered and placed in theevidence locker.
[3] Since the new law favors disclosure of evidence, and without seeing theactual envelope or a copy thereof, there is no way of knowing what is exactly written onthe envelope, disclosure of the envelope is required. Accordingly, the People are orderedto either provide a copy of the envelope, or allow the defendant, through counsel, toinspect the actual envelope at the next court date or at a mutually convenient time to beagreed to by the parties. However, while this document needs to be provided to thedefense, since there is no evidence that the People acted in bad faith and have providedan inventory sheet detailing the markings, which appear to only be voucher and/or casenumbers, such failure does not warrant a finding that the People's certificate ofcompliance was illusory.
"LIMS" Bench Notes, Computer System and Audit Trail
During the compliance conference, the defendant alleged that the People failed toturn over, as part of their automatic discovery, a copy of the laboratory informationmanagement system (LIMS) audit trail from the New York City Office of Chief MedicalExaminer's (OCME) LIMS computer system regarding the DNA evidence which thePeople intend to introduce at trial, as well as any "bench notes" not previously {**66 Misc 3d at 923}turned over. The People counter thatOCME is not under their "control" for purposes of automatic discovery and, in any event,do not have, nor are they aware, whether such documentation exists. Since the last courtdate, the defendant has clarified his request and has now asked for a copy of the entireLIMS computer system, as well as the bench notes and audit trail. (See emailsattached to People's reply to instant motion.)
As a preliminary matter, because the OCME performed DNA analysis in this case atthe request of either the New York City Police Department or the Queens County DistrictAttorney's Office, and not because they were under some statutory duty to do so, the datarequested by the defense pertaining to this DNA analysis is discoverable pursuant to CPL245.20 (1) (j). (People vGills, 52 Misc 3d 903, 907 [Sup Ct, Queens County 2016, Koenderman,J.].)[FN3]
[4] With respect to the "bench notes" the People affirm that, to the best oftheir knowledge, the source of which is the General Counsel of OCME, all requested"bench notes" have previously been provided to the defense and that no additionalmaterials exist. Thus, the People have satisfied their discovery requirements under thestatute as to the "bench notes."
With respect to the request for the entire LIMS computer system, such request isdenied as overbroad, as the entire LIMS computer system would provide the defendantinformation far greater than information pertaining to his individual case, and no goodcause has been shown as for the reason for the request. Moreover, it cannot be reasonablyinferred that the legislature, in creating CPL 245.20 (1) (j), meant to give the defendantthe entire LIMS computer system, and not just the relevant information pertaining totheir individual case.
With respect to the LIMS audit trail contained in the LIMS system, the court findsthat such audit trail would be considered{**66 Misc 3d at924} a "record" for purposes of the new statute and therefore is discoverable andmust be provided to the defense. (CPL 245.20 [1] [j].) However, because such records donot actually exist and cannot be provided by the OCME without imposing an undueburden on it, the discovery requirements of CPL 245.20 (1) (j) can be met by requiringthe OCME to make the LIMS system/audit trail as it pertains to the evidence in this caseavailable for review and inspection by counsel for the defendant and/or any expert whichthe defendant designates. Such review and inspection should be done withoutunnecessary delay at a mutually convenient time between the parties and OCME, but inno event later than at least 30 days prior to the first scheduled trial date.
Conclusion
Upon the filing of the additional discovery, the People are ordered to supplementtheir certificate of compliance consistent with CPL 245.50 (1). Although the court isordering additional discovery not previously provided by the People, this order does notinvalidate the People's certificate of compliance or statement of readiness dated January24, 2020. (See CPL 245.50 [1].) The court finds that the People acted in goodfaith and there is no evidence that either the certificate of compliance or statement ofreadiness was illusory.
Footnote 1:The People affirmedthat they received the current email addresses directly from their witnesses and furtheraffirmed that they have encouraged their witnesses to acknowledge receipt of any contactby the defense by email, regardless of whether or not the witness wishes to speak withthe defense.
Footnote 2:The court is aware thatadditional Rikers calls may become available and all of those calls should be provided todefense counsel as soon as they are received, and in accordance with this order.
Footnote 3:While the court is awareof the Second Department decisions in People v Tsintzelis (153 AD3d 558 [2d Dept 2017]) and People v Velez (164 AD3d622 [2d Dept 2018], lv granted 32 NY3d 1129 [2018]), both of which arescheduled for oral argument before the Court of Appeals on February 12, 2020, suchdecisions did not overrule the decision in People v Gills. Moreover, those casessimply held that the lower court had not abused its discretion in denying the defendant'srequest that the People provide OCME records. In any event, those decisions aredistinguishable from the instant case in that they were decided under the formerdiscovery statute, CPL 240.20, whereas this case is being litigated under the newdiscovery reform statute which has greatly expanded the People's discovery obligations,and specifically references the type of records which this court has ordered must bedisclosed. (CPL 245.20 [1] [j].)