Matter of Van Dyk v Town of Greenfield Planning Bd.
2021 NY Slip Op 00062 [190 AD3d 1048]
January 7, 2021
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 3, 2021


[*1]
 In the Matter of James Van Dyk et al.,Appellants,
v
Town of Greenfield Planning Board, Respondent, et al.,Respondents.

Braymer Law, PLLC, Glens Falls (Claudia K. Braymer of counsel), for appellants.

Miller, Mannix, Schachner & Hafner, LLC, Glens Falls (Leah Everhart of counsel), forTown of Greenfield Planning Board, respondent.

Lynch, J.P. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Crowell, J.), entered July 9, 2019in Saratoga County, which dismissed petitioners' application, in a combined proceeding pursuantto CPLR article 78 and action for declaratory judgment, to review a resolution of respondentTown of Greenfield Planning Board approving the site plan of respondent Stewart's ShopsCorp.

In 2003, respondent Stewart's Shops Corp. (hereinafter Stewart's) received approval fromrespondent Town of Greenfield Planning Board for a four-phase development plan to construct amanufacturing and distribution center. The plan included a stormwater pollution prevention plan(hereinafter SWPPP) and a two-cell pond system to manage stormwater runoff from the site,which system was constructed in 2003. In August 2017, Stewart's applied to modify phase fourof the plan, seeking to construct a warehouse in lieu of a previously approved parking lot.Following a lengthy review process, which included numerous public hearings and completion ofa State Environmental Quality Review Act (see ECL art 8 [hereinafter SEQRA]) fullenvironmental assessment form (hereinafter FEAF), the Planning Board issued a negativedeclaration declaring that the modification would not have a detrimental environmental impact.The Planning Board then adopted a resolution in March 2019 approving the application. In April2019, petitioners, as neighbors to the project site, commenced this combined CPLR article 78proceeding and action for declaratory judgment seeking to vacate the Planning Board's approvalfor failing to adequately address the stormwater and wetland impacts. Finding that the PlanningBoard sufficiently identified and considered the environmental concerns raised in the application,Supreme Court dismissed the petition/complaint. Petitioners appeal.

Our review of the Planning Board's SEQRA determination "is limited to whether the agencyidentified the relevant areas of environmental concern, took a hard look at them, and made areasoned elaboration of the basis for its determination" (Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town of Southeast, 9NY3d 219, 231-232 [2007] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]). An agencydecision may only be annulled "if it is arbitrary, capricious or unsupported by the evidence"(id. at 232).

In support of its 2017 application, Stewart's submitted an updated SWPPP and a StormwaterManagement Report (hereinafter SMR) prepared by its retained engineers, MJ Engineering andLand Surveyors, P.C. Stewart's also submitted updated calculations to address the pond'sfunctionality and capacity, a downstream drainage analysis to address the roadside drainage, ageotechnical report regarding excavation near the pond system and the FEAF. These submissionscontemplated the continued use of the 2003 stormwater system. The SMR explained that achange from a parking lot to a warehouse would increase the impervious area from 73,400 squarefeet to 93,300 square [*2]feet, resulting in an increase ofstormwater runoff that the existing pond system could accommodate. The SMR also proposedadding a grass swale along the perimeter of the warehouse. The SMR determined that the"proposed improvements for the project site meet or exceed water quantity, runoff reductions andwater quality requirements as specified in the 2011 [Department of Environmental Conservation(hereinafter DEC)] [Stormwater Design Manual] guidelines." The downstream drainage analysisrecommended removing a roadside culvert limiting runoff capacity and the culvert was removed.Upon review of these submissions, the Town's engineer, Charles Baker, advised the PlanningBoard in writing that the existing pond system could handle the increased stormwater runoff andconformed to current DEC standards. In our view, this review process demonstrates that thePlanning Board identified and took a hard look at the stormwater issue and made a reasoneddetermination that the capacity of the existing system was adequate to handle the increase instormwater runoff.

The further question is whether the modification would negatively impact federal wetlands, aconcern raised by petitioners and the Town's Environmental Commission. By letter dated March1, 2018, DEC advised that the project did not require any state wetland permit. In June 2018, arepresentative of the United States Army Corps of Engineers (hereinafter USACOE) informedpetitioners that Stewart's advised that it would not seek a written verification of the wetlandboundaries from the USACOE because the project was designed to avoid delineated wetlands.Petitioners maintain that the Planning Board erred in failing to obtain a determination from theUSACOE concerning federal wetlands in the area of the pond. Through a presentation by CarlHolzworth, formerly employed as a biologist in DEC's wetland permit program, petitionersasserted that the ponds were likely sited within federal wetlands. Holzworth opined thatadditional drainage from the pond system would probably "impact water levels in those wetlandsin the forest." By memorandum dated September 29, 2018, the Environmental Commissionspecifically requested that the Planning Board consult with the USACOE regarding the additionalstormwater generated by the project.

Previously, Stewart's submitted a letter, dated March 13, 2018, to the Planning Boardadvising that "this past spring the LA Group completed a wetland delineation to help us identifyplausible limits of construction (copy enclosed) . . . [and] we are comfortableasserting that the existing site plan under consideration does not fall within [US]ACOE'sjurisdictional review requirements and[,] as such[,] a determination on their part is not required."The Planning Board's meeting minutes from both February 27, 2018 and March 27, 2018 refer tothe LA Group map and, in the latter meeting, specify that "[t]he Board has copies of the wetlanddelineation that the LA Group did." [*3]Baker addressed thefederal wetlands issue in his October 26, 2018 letter to the Planning Board, noting "that theUSACOE did not need to be contacted for the project, since there are no existing wetlands in thelocation of the proposed action, and there are no modifications being proposed to the stormwatermanagement facility." In its March 2019 approval resolution, the Planning Board emphasizedthat it considered the concerns of the Town's Environmental Commission and referred to Baker'sletter. The Planning Board approved the project without USACOE involvement.

The foregoing demonstrates that the Planning Board relied on the wetland map submitted byStewart's and as interpreted by Baker to conclude that the project did not implicate any federalwetlands. Supreme Court noted as much in its decision. We are mindful that the record on appealdoes not include any map identified as a wetland delineation prepared by the LA Group. Thediscrepancy is addressed in Baker's answering affidavit in this proceeding, wherein he explainsthat 2003 submissions by Stewart's "included a wetland delineation map (prepared by SantoAssociates, dated April 17, 2003)" and identified that map as the one that Stewart's submittedwith the March 13, 2018 letter. Baker observed that "[t]he wetland delineation map prepared in2003 shows a sliver of wetlands located on the south of the existing stormwater basin, outside thelimits of the proposed stormwater management area and access road." The administrative recordincluded in the record on appeal shows that the letter submitted by Stewart's on March 13, 2018included a map prepared by Santo Associates, not the LA Group.[FN*] Moreover, petitioners concede that the SantoAssociates map was presented to the Planning Board. This map shows that a narrow wetlandstrip exists south of the stormwater pond as explained by Baker. Consistent with the March 13letter from Stewart's advising that a wetlands delineation had been completed the previousspring, the map also includes wetlands revisions added in March 2017 and May 2017. GivenBaker's opinion that the wetlands were situated outside the stormwater management area, thePlanning Board could rationally conclude that a consultation with the USACOE was unnecessaryand that the project would not compromise any federal wetlands. In view of the above, thePlanning Board's determination in the FEAF that the modification would have no impact onsurface waters is supported by the evidence and validates the Planning Board's negativedeclaration for SEQRA purposes.

Clark, Aarons, Pritzker and Reynolds Fitzgerald, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment isaffirmed, without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote *:The record copy of the SantoAssociates map is illegible. At the Court's request during oral argument, the Planning Board'scounsel has submitted a clear copy of this map. We recognize that the newly submitted mapincludes revisions made after the Planning Board's determination under review, but thoserevisions do not pertain to wetlands. As such, despite petitioners' objections, we will consider themap.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.