Matter of Jayson C.
2021 NY Slip Op 06794 [200 AD3d 447]
December 7, 2021
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Friday, February 17, 2023


[*1]
 In the Matter of Jayson C., a Person Alleged to be a JuvenileDelinquent, Appellant.

Janet E. Sabel, The Legal Aid Society, New York (John A. Newbery of counsel), forappellant.

Georgia M. Pestana, Corporation Counsel, New York (Deborah E. Wassel of counsel), forpresentment agency.

Order, Family Court, Bronx County (Gayle P. Roberts, J.), entered on or about March 15,2021, which, to the extent appealed from, declined to direct the presentment agency to provideappellant with disclosure required under CPL 245.20 (1) (k) (iv), unanimously reversed, on thelaw, without costs, and the motion granted.

In this appeal we are asked to determine whether the Family Court denied appellant equalprotection of the laws by concluding that the Family Court Act precluded application of CPL245.20 (1) (k) (iv)'s disclosure provisions regarding impeachment evidence. We find that theFamily Court did deny appellant equal protection of the laws.

Appellant Jayson C. was arrested and charged with two counts of criminal possession of aweapon in the second degree and lesser offenses based on his alleged possession of a loadedpistol. The presentment agency named fourteen police officers who were involved in appellant'sarrest and investigation and stated its intention to introduce identification testimony from four ofthose officers. It also stated its intent to introduce the weapon and related evidence which hadbeen recovered by the officers, at a suppression hearing and at trial. The presentment agencystated that it did not intend to introduce at trial any statements appellant made to the officers. Thepresentment agency also disclosed via a Voluntary Disclosure Form (VDF) that nine of thefourteen officers were involved in at least one pending lawsuit, and it listed the title and indexnumber of each proceeding.

Appellant sought discovery under Family Court Act § 331.2 (1) (a)-(h) and,citing the Equal Protection Clause of the Federal and State Constitutions, discovery under CPL 245.20 (1) (a)-(u). In particular, he soughtimpeachment information under CPL 245.20 (1) (k) (iv).

The presentment agency emailed appellant's attorney "disclosure letters" about twelve of theofficers. The letters summarized their disciplinary history. Four officers had at least one pendingNYPD disciplinary allegation; eleven had at least one substantiated NYPD disciplinary finding;six of the eleven had multiple findings; and three had at least one substantiated CCRB complaint.However, the presentment agency "refused as not properly discoverable upon a Demand toProduce" any items sought under CPL 245.20 (1) (a)-(u). Regarding any impeachmentinformation, the presentment agency said that it had served the previously described lettersregarding the disciplinary history of the officers, that no other impeachment evidence was knownto exist at the time, and if any was discovered, it would be made available to appellant "pursuantto law." The presentment agency stated that appellant was provided all the information requiredunder the Family Court Act article 3.

As part of his omnibus motion, appellant sought an order directing the presentment agency toprovide the discovery sought in his Discovery Demand, including impeachment evidencepursuant to CPL 245.20 (1) (k) (iv), [*2]and argued that it wasunconstitutional to deny him those materials solely because he is an alleged juveniledelinquent.

The presentment agency opposed the motion and argued that it provided all discoveryrequired by the Family Court Act, and that CPL article 245 did not apply to juvenile delinquencyproceedings. The presentment agency also stated that appellant's motion was moot because itfulfilled its "statutory obligations" by providing the VDF and "Rosario and discoverymaterial."

The Family Court "deemed satisfied" appellant's motion because the presentment agency hadprovided the relief requested in his motion. The Family Court denied any request for "furtherwitness information" stating that "the provisions of the CPL cited by [appellant] are expresslyinapplicable and preempted in juvenile delinquency cases pursuant to Family Ct Act 303.1 (1)."The court noted that the presentment agency was still required to comply with its statutory,Brady, and Rosario obligations.

While not all provisions of the Criminal Procedure Law are applicable to proceedings underthe Family Court Act (Family Ct Act § 303.1 [1]) under the circumstancespresented here, the denial of records available under CPL 245.20 (1) (k) (iv), which broadlyrequires disclosure of all impeachment evidence, deprived appellant of equal protection of thelaws (US Const, 14th Amend; NY Const, art I, § 11; see e.g. Matter of JamesH., 34 NY2d 814, 816 [1974]; Matter of Arthur M., 34 AD2d 761 [1st Dept 1970];Matter of Edward S., 80 AD2d 585, 585-586 [2d Dept 1981]).

A respondent in a juvenile delinquency proceeding has the same right to cross-examinewitnesses as a criminal defendant (see generally Matter of Walker, 144 AD2d 306 [1stDept 1988]), and there is no reason to allow more limited access to impeachment materials in ajuvenile suppression or fact-finding hearing than in a criminal suppression hearing or trial. Theneed for impeachment evidence is equally crucial in both delinquency and criminal proceedings.A similarly situated defendant in a criminal proceeding would be entitled to access to theimpeachment materials requested by appellant.

We note that the legislature is considering legislation that would amend the Family Court Actto include, under proposed Family Court Act § 333.1 (1) (k), the very samedisclosure now required at CPL 245.20 (1) (k) (2021 NY Senate Bill S4554 [passed Senate];2021 NY Assembly Bill A4952).

Because appellant asks only that the information be provided under Family Court Act article3 timelines, we need not address whether any different time frame contained in the CriminalProcedure Law must apply under equal protection principles. Concur—Acosta, P.J.,Gische, Webber, Friedman, Kennedy, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.