[*1]
People v Haymon
2021 NY Slip Op 50267(U) [71 Misc 3d 1203(A)]
Decided on March 29, 2021
County Court, Albany County
Carter, J.
This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports.


Decided on March 29, 2021
County Court, Albany County


The People of theState of New York, Plaintiff,

against

Shawn Haymon, Defendant.




DA 232-20



FOR THE PEOPLE:

HON. P. DAVID SOARES, ESQ., Albany CountyDistrict Attorney

By: MEGAN C. SPILLANE, ESQ. Assistant District Attorney

Albany County Judicial Center

6 Lodge Street

Albany, NewYork 12207

FOR THE DEFENDANT:

HON. STEPHEN W. HERRICK,ESQ., Albany County Public Defender

By; ANGELA KELLEY, ESQ., AssistantPublic Defender

112 State Street

Albany, New York 12207


William A. Carter, J.

By indictment filed on November 4, 2020, defendant was charged with criminal possessionof a weapon in the second degree, a class C armed violent felony (Penal Law § 265.03 [3])and criminal possession of a weapon in the third degree, a class D felony (Penal Law §265.02 [1]). By motion, defendant challenges the validity of the People's November 10, 2020certificate of compliance (CoC) and concomitant statement of trial readiness (STR). The Peopleoppose.

A CoC "serves only one practical purpose: [i]t is a necessary prerequisite to a valid statementof readiness under C.P.L. § 30.30" (People v Barnett, 68 Misc 3d 1000, 1002 [*2][Statsinger, J, Sup Ct, July 20, 2020]). The sole "conditionprecedent to the prosecutor's ability to file a [CoC] is the discovery of all material considered[a]utomatic [d]iscovery" (People vNapolitano, 67 Misc 3d 1241(A), NY Slip Op 50802(U) [Paek, J, Sup Ct, June 11,2020]).

Defendant argues, inter alia, that the People failed to act with due diligence inascertaining the existence of impeachment material for their law enforcement witnesses. Whilethe People oppose, they have recently filed a new CoC, effectively demonstrating that theNovember 10, 2020 CoC was invalid and the associated declaration of readiness illusory.Accordingly, defendant's motion is granted, and the People's November 10, 2020 CoC deemedinvalid and the concomitant STR is deemed illusory and consequently, speedy trial time hascontinued to accrue.[FN1]Motion granted.

The required judicial inquiry testing the People's "actual" trial readiness (see CPL30.30 [5]; CPL 245.50) as set forth in the March 4, 2021 CoC will be scheduled by thecourt.

March 4, 2021 CoC Judicial Inquiry: CPL 30.30 (5); CPL245.50

As in People v Quinlan, 2021 NY Slip Op 21020, 2021WL 417125 (Gray, J Bronx Crim Ct, Jan 29, 2021) and People v DeSean Cooper, Ind.No. 00853-2020 (Eagan, JCC Erie Co Ct, Feb 23, 2021), this case also turns on the issue of whatconstitutes the People's possession of material and what is known to the People.[FN2]Discovery compliance now requires the People, upon disclosing "all known" materials, to certifythat due diligence was exercised to ascertain the existence of any other materials (see People v Adrovic, 69 Misc 3d563 [Kitsis, J., NY Crim Ct, Sept 3, 2020]). CPL 245.20 (2) provides, in relevant part:

"all items and information related to the prosecution of a charge in the possession of anyNew York state or local police or law enforcement agency shall be deemed to be in thepossession of the prosecution " [emphasis added]; see also CPL 245.55 [1], [2])

The People's March 4, 2021 CoC provides, in pertinent part:

"All known and available material and information required to be disclosedpursuant to CPL §245.20(1) and not subject to a CPL § 245.70 protective order, hasnow been disclosed or made available to the defendant. The People will continue to seek andprovide any materials known or suspected to exist which are not in our actual possession"(Mar 4 CoC bulleted Para 2 [emphasis added]).

"Anyoutstanding materials which may exist will be provided as they come into our actualpossession" (Mar 4 CoC bulleted Para 3 [emphasis added]).

At theforthcoming required judicial inquiry pertaining to the People's March 4, 2021 CoC (seeCPL 30.30 [5]; CPL 245.50), the prosecutor should, at a minimum, be prepared to explain howthe above factual assertions harmonize with each other and with the People's self-imposed limitson the scope of inquiry and disclosure of known materials as set forth in Para 68 of the RossiAffirmation. Assuming harmonization is possible, the next and dispositive issue becomeswhether the People's actions to date comply with the plain text and spirit of CPL Article 245 aswell as the holdings in People v Quinlan (supra) and People v Cooper(supra), the reasoning and analysis of which this court concurs.

"[R]egardless of whether the People have actual possession of discoverable materialand information from law enforcement, such material and information is statutorilydeemed to be in [*3]the People's possession" (People vQuinlan, supra at *4 [emphasis in original]; see CPL 245.55 [1], [2])."'[W]hat the People may not do is file a certificate of compliance in which they claim to haveexercised due diligence and turned over 'all known material and information,' while at the sametime not actually turning over all known material and information'" (People v Quinlan,supra at *3, quoting People vAdrovic, 69 Misc 3d 563, 574 (Kitsis, J, NY Crim Ct Ct 2020]). As succinctly stated byJudge Eagan, "[t]he People may not withhold known material and information subject toautomatic discovery and expect the court to accept a certificate of compliance and statement oftrial readiness" (People v Cooper, supra at 7).

The above constitutes the decision and order of this court.



Dated: March 29, 2021

Albany, New York

WILLIAM A.CARTER

County Court Judge

Footnotes


Footnote 1:The felony complaints associatedwith this case were filed December 27, 2019.

Footnote 2:People v DeSean Cooper,Ind. No. 00853-2020, Eagan, JCC (Erie Co Ct, Feb 23, 2021) and People v Quinlan, 2021NY Slip Op 21d020, 2021, 2021 WL 417125 (Gray, J. Bronx Crim Ct, Jan 29, 2021) are attachedas Court's Exhibit 1 to this decision and order.




NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.