[*1]
People v Surgick
2021 NY Slip Op 51007(U) [73 Misc 3d 1212(A)]
Decided on October 15, 2021
City Court Of Albany, Albany County
Farrell, J.
This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports.


Decided on October 15, 2021
City Court of Albany, Albany County


People of the State ofNew York,

against

Quashon Surgick, Defendant.




File No. 1872-20



P. David Soares, Esq.

Albany County District Attorney

Alexandra vonStackelberg, Esq.

Emily Schultz, Esq.

Assistant DistrictAttorneys

Albany City Court - Criminal Part

1 Morton Avenue

Albany, New York 12202

Stephen Herrick, Esq.

Albany County PublicDefender

Kelly D. Vidur, Esq.

Assistant Public Defender

Albany City Court - Criminal Part

1 Morton Avenue

Albany, NewYork 12202


Joshua L. Farrell, J.

Defendant stands charged with Criminal Impersonation in the Second Degree and UnlawfulDissemination or Publication of an Intimate Image. These charges allege that defendant, on April16, 2021, impersonated his ex-girlfriend B.S.[FN1]by posting an intimate video of her on her own Facebook account. The video allegedly depictedB.S. performing sexual acts. Needless to say, B.S. alleges that she did not consent to the posting.Defendant entered a plea of not guilty to the charges on April 30, 2021 and discoverycommenced. Motion practice has been extensive, both before and after this Court's July 30, 2021trial ready inquiry ("TRI"). The motions are all now fully submitted and the issues raised are eachaddressed separately below.

Defendant's Challenge to thePeople's Certificate of Discovery


Compliance



Defendant's challenge to the People's Certificate of Discovery Compliance(hereinafter "CoC") is granted only to the extent that the People failed to demonstrate that their"police personnel files" disclosure was sufficient. Defendant's challenge is otherwise denied.

CPL §245.50(1) requires the People to file and serve a CoC confirming that "afterexercising due diligence and making reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence of materialand information subject to discovery, the prosecutor has disclosed and made available all knownmaterial and information subject to discovery." Of course, and as explicitly set forth in thestatute, the People must automatically provide defendant with the discovery materials outlined inCPL §245.20(1) prior to filing their CoC. However, CPL §245.50 recognizes that notall discovery will be turned over to the defense prior to CoC filing. CPL §245.50(1)provides an explicit exception for discovery that is "lost or destroyed" or subject to a CPL§245.70 protective order.

While recognizing that some discovery may not be provided to the defense, CPL§245.50(1) makes no allowance for CoC non-filing. Even where some discovery items arenot provided to the defense, the People's CoC filing obligation remains. The People must still"exercis[e] due diligence and mak[e] reasonable inquiries" and then provide the defense with all"known material and information." CPL §245.50(1).

[The People's] requirement of providing "known material and information" iswholly dependent on the People first "exercising due diligence and making reasonable inquires."While neither "due diligence" nor "reasonable inquires" are statutorily defined, their plainmeaning proscribes an absolute requirement. Instead, due diligence is understood as: "[t]hediligence reasonably expected from, and ordinarily exercised by, a person who seeks to satisfy alegal requirement or to discharge an obligation. — Also termed reasonable diligence "Black's Law Dictionary (11th ed. 2019). Paired with the phrase "reasonable inquiries," themost natural and ordinary meaning of "due diligence" in this context requires the People toconduct a "reasonable" search for discovery material. To be sure, this reasonableness standardrequires the People to go to great effort. The prosecution of a criminal charge where liberty is atstake demands no less. The standard, however, cannot be construed as an absolute requirement toprovide the defense with all discovery material, whether known or unknown, regardless of thereasonableness of the People's searches, investigations, and inquiries.



People v Smith, Albany City Court, July 20, 2021, Farrell, J. Index No.1872-20.

Here, the defense contests the People's discovery disclosures as set forth in fourCoCs.[FN2]The People initially filed a CoC, dated June 16, 2021, and then filed a second, dated July 13,2021. By a CPL §245.35(1) Order of this Court, the People and defense counsel weredirected to "diligently confer to reach an accommodation" on their discovery disputes. Then,following the conferral, the People filed their third CoC, dated July 29, 2021. This Courtconducted its TRI the next day. The parties briefed the CoC disputes twice, and defense counselhas identified [*2]three final unresolved issues: "911 / stationcalls; additional radio transmissions disclosed" and "police personnel files." The Peoplethereafter filed a fourth CoC, dated August 10, 2021, identifying newly created discoverymaterials which are not at issue. On this record, defendant failed to demonstrate his entitlementto relief on his "911 / station calls; additional radio transmissions" challenges but did so on the"police personnel files" issue he raised.

Defendant first concedes that his request for "911 / station calls " has been satisfied and thePeople demonstrated that their search for such discovery material was reasonable. The recorddemonstrates that on April 18, 2021 the Albany County District Attorney's Office (hereinafter"DA") sent to the New York State Police (hereinafter "NYSP") a request for "a complete copy"of their records and files in this action. The NYSP responded with a "Discovery Checklist," datedApril 19, 2021, that did not indicate the existence of any "911 Calls & /or Telephone Calls."It is uncontested that this request and response provided the People with no information about theexistence of "911 / station calls " Nor is it contested that the People provided defendant with allof the materials identified in the NYSP Discovery Checklist. When defendant raised the "911 /station calls" issue in his omnibus motion, the People sought more information from the NYSPon July 12 and 26, 2021. Then, on July 29, 2021, the People "received confirmation that no suchrecording ever existed." Defendant concedes the non-existence of such material. On this record itis uncontested that the "911 / station calls " were never turned over because, in fact, they neverexisted. The People fully complied with their discovery obligations, and defendant's objections tothe CoC are entirely unfounded.

Similarly unavailing is defendant's related challenge to the " additional radio transmissionsdisclosed" by the People's third CoC. On July 29, 2021, the People provided defendant, for thefirst time, with a: CAD Log, Radio Log, Radio Transmissions (5 files), and Email from NYSP rePhone Call Information. It is uncontested that the People obtained these materials by continuedinquiries to ascertain the existence of discovery material, and then disclosed them to the defenseexpeditiously upon their receipt. The NYSP Discovery Checklist made no mention of such items,and defendant has not claimed that the People's late disclosure was in bad faith, unreasonableunder the circumstances, or caused him any prejudice. Rather, in accord with CPL§§245.60 and 245.50(1), it appears that the People fully complied with theircontinuing duty to investigate and disclose. Because the People demonstrated that their "additional radio transmissions" were disclosed in good faith and reasonable under thecircumstances, "no adverse consequences shall result" (CPL §245.50[1]) and Defendant'sobjections are rejected.

Defendant did, however, demonstrate that the People's "police personnel files" disclosurefailed to comply with CPL §245.20(1)(k)(iv)'s requirements.

The People's due diligence and reasonable inquiries obligations are especially significant forCPL §245.20(1)(k)(iv) discovery information and materials. This provision specificallyrequires the People to turn over "[a]ll evidence and information, including that which is known topolice or other law enforcement agencies acting on the government's behalf in the case, that tendsto impeach the credibility of a testifying prosecution witness." CPL §245.20(1)(k)(iv).Numerous courts have recognized that this obligation is a statutory expansion of theconstitutional disclosure requirements of Brady v Maryland (373 US 83 [1963]) andGiglio v United States (405 US 150 [1972]). See People v Salters, 72 Misc 3d 1219(A)(Nassau Dist Ct 2021); People v McKinney, 71 Misc 3d1221(A)(Crim Ct Kings Co 2021); People v Castellanos, 72 Misc 3d 371 (Sup Ct, Bronx Co 2021); People v Rosario, 70 Misc 3d 753(Albany County Ct [*3]2020).

Generally, CPL §245.20(1)(k)(iv) requires the People to turn over all impeachmentmaterial concerning their law enforcement witnesses. Recognizing the practical difficulty of thePeople obtaining such information from law enforcement agencies, CPL §245.55(1)specifically obligates the People to ensure that a flow of information exists for "any evidence orinformation discoverable under paragraph (k) of subdivision one of section 245.20." Then, in thevery next paragraph, the statute states that each law enforcement agency "shall make available tothe prosecution a complete copy of its complete records and files related to the investigation ofthe case or the prosecution of the defendant for compliance with this article." CPL§245.55(2). Moreover, a law enforcement agency's personnel files, like all items andinformation related to the prosecution of a charge, are statutorily "deemed to be in the possessionof the prosecution." CPL §245.20(2). The plain language of this presumption along with thePeople's statutory obligations demonstrate, unequivocally, the legislature's intent: the People'sdue diligence and reasonable inquiries burden is exceptionally high to obtain, review, anddisclose impeachment material concerning their law enforcement witnesses.

Moreover, the legislature explicitly and unambiguously explained its intent in favor of fulldisclosure by stating that "[t]here shall be a presumption in favor of disclosure when interpreting subdivision one of section 245.20, of this article." CPL §245.20(7).

When the People exercise due diligence to obtain their police officer witness' personnelrecords but are unable to demonstrate full compliance with their obligation, the statue providesoptions. CPL §245.35 provides a framework to "facilitate compliance." CPL§245.35(3) specifically addresses the People's CPL §245.20(1)(k) discoveryobligation, after they file a CoC, by stating:

..that the court in its discretion may issue an order: Requiring the prosecution tofile an additional certificate of compliance that states that the prosecutor and/or an appropriatenamed agent has made reasonable inquiries of all police officers and other persons who haveparticipated in investigating or evaluating the case about the existence of any favorable evidenceor information within paragraph (k) of subdivision one of section 245.20 of this article, includingsuch evidence or information that was not reduced to writing or otherwise memorialized orpreserved as evidence, and has disclosed any such information to thedefendant

By its terms, this provision recognizes the filing of an initialCoC and then authorizes an order that requires an additional CoC filing. This additional CoC isfocused specifically on CPL §245.20(1)(k) information and material, requiring a furtherstatement confirming the People's "reasonable inquiries of all police officers about the existenceof any favorable evidence or information." CPL §245.35(3). With these explicit terms thelegislature made clear that even after the People exercise due diligence and submit a valid CoC, apost-CoC statement may be ordered to ensure that all CPL §245.20(1)(k) "favorableevidence or information" is disclosed to the defense. CPL §245.35(3). The statute furtherprovides a catchall provision, authorizing an order "requiring other measures or proceedingsdesigned to carry into effect the goals of this article." CPL §245.35(4).

Of course, if the People fail to demonstrate that they have exercised due diligence and madereasonable inquiries to obtain CPL §245.20(1)(k)(iv) material and information, their CoCwould not be proper and their statement of ready would not be valid. CPL §§30.30(5)and [*4]245.50(1) and (3). The People must satisfy theirdiscovery obligations, with due diligence, prior to being ready for trial. The obligation isinflexible. No trial ready statement is valid unless the People file a CoC that truthfully assertsthat the People have "exercised due diligence and made reasonable inquiries to ascertain theexistence of material and information subject to discovery." Id.

On this record, the People failed to demonstrate their due diligence and reasonable inquiriesto comply with CPL §245.20(1)(k) for their three law enforcement witnesses.

The People first described the generally applicable background for their CPL§245.20(1)(k) inquiries by submitting Chief ADA Rossi's "standing affirmation," datedJanuary 20, 2021. They filed this affirmation four separate times in this action alone and havesubmitted it to this court with nearly every other CoC filed over the past year and a half. Thisboilerplate filing recounts Chief ADA Rossi's efforts, and that of the DA's Office, to create therequired CPL §245.55 "flow of information." The filing explains the breadth of theobligation by identifying the numerous jurisdictions, law enforcement agencies, and lawenforcement officers within Albany County. He also explains the non-uniform standards thevarious agencies employ to retain CPL §245.20(1)(k) impeachment materials. Chief ADARossi outlines the efforts his office made prior to 2020, where the DA's office required each lawenforcement agency to review their internal files and provide all impeachment materials. AsChief ADA Rossi admits, not every agency complied. In part to remedy the non-compliance ofthe agencies and also to provide all impeachment information that was not "recorded in tangibleform" (CPL §245.20[1][k]), the DA's office asked each of its police officer witnesses todisclose certain impeachment information they knew about themselves by questionnaire. Thequestionnaires too, however, were insufficient. People v Rosario, 70 Misc 3d 753 (Albany County Ct 2020). Toremedy the deficiencies, Chief ADA Rossi explains the additional efforts the DA's office took inNovember and December of 2020. He explains his office's written demand for the completepersonnel file of all police officers from every police chief in Albany County, and the meeting hisoffice had with those police chiefs concerning the demand (presumably this included the NYSP).This was followed by the DA's Office sending to each police chief their "Standing Request forMaterials Related to CPL §245.20(1)(k)," dated January 11, 2021 (hereinafter "StandingRequest"). Chief ADA Rossi concludes by explaining, in general, what materials the DA's officeis providing to the defense. He states that " we are not now providing those underlying audio andvideo recordings, witness statements, or other documents appertaining to those allegations Instead, the People are providing the defendant only with a summary of the substance of anyallegations of wrongdoing relevant to credibility."

The DA's Standing Request is a comprehensive appeal for CPL §245.20(1)(k) materialand information. Sent to every police department, it requests the "relevant portions" of thepersonnel files for officers who may reasonably be expected to testify as a witness. It definesrelevancy in terms of impeachment material, and then defines impeachment information. Thedefinition of impeachment material provides a non-exhaustive list of examples, and otherwisedescribes the information as logically and reasonably bearing on credibility. The definition alsoincludes all information, whether recorded or not. The DA's request recognizes that the term"personnel file" has different meanings across law enforcement agencies, and that the StandingRequest is not limited to those files titled "personnel record." Rather, it is impeachment materialthat is sought regardless of the file or the document's title. Recognizing this difficulty in relyingon title, the People specifically requested "all documents and information pertaining to[:] [*5]•Discipline •Letters of Censure •CitizenComplaints •Allegations of misconduct •Employment Applications andBackground Checks." (emphasis added). The People further clarified their request forunredacted records, explaining that they will conduct the necessary redaction review and"provide only those records which contain potential impeachment information."

Within this generally applicable background, the record demonstrates that the People'sefforts to ascertain the existence of impeachment materials for their three law enforcementwitnesses in this action were insufficient.

On June 16, 2021, the People filed and served their first Discovery Disclosure. The WitnessList attached to the Disclosure identified two law enforcement witnesses: Investigator MichaelAlteri and Trooper Kyle Rossback. Under the heading "CPL §245.20(1)(k) 'Brady'Information" the Disclosure stated that "[n]one is known to exist at this time." Supplementing theDisclosure, on July 13, 2021, the People filed an updated Witness List to add a third lawenforcement witness: Trooper Brent Karrow. Along with the updated Witness List, the Peopleasserted their compliance with CPL §245.20(1)(k) by stating:

Trooper Karrow's personnel file, totaling two pages, was provided to Defendant onJuly 13, 2021 [for the impeachment] records related to Investigator Michael Alteri[ t]he Peoplehave turned over all potential Brady material consisting of three pages of materials [for theimpeachment] records related to Trooper Kyle Rossback[ t]he People have turned over allpotential Brady material consisting of one page of materials



Despite the extensive briefing, the People's written submissions did not explain their efforts toascertain CPL §245.20(1)(k) impeachment materials for their three law enforcementwitnesses in this action. They offered no details to explain the inquiry conducted that producedthe six pages of documents for their three law enforcement witnesses. Instead, they relied whollyon Chief ADA Rossi's Affirmation and the Standing Request for their explanation. Theaffirmation, however, provides only background information and the Standing Request is,obviously, only a request. Neither provide case specific facts to establish the People's compliancewith their discovery obligations in this action.

At its July 30, 2021 TRI, the Court sought to clarify the written record. The Court asked thePeople, in sum and substance, the following questions for each of their law enforcementwitnesses:

What New York State government offices or departments keep files that containinformation that would tend to impeach the People's three law enforcementwitness?


For those offices and departments, who reviewed theirphysical and electronic files to cull all information for impeachment material?

The People were unable to offer any details in response and were, likewise, wholly unable toexplain the NYSP's review. The People subsequently, in a written submission, identified theindividuals who conducted NYSP's review. They did not, however, explain the reviewconducted.

Instead, to explain NYSP's review the People submitted an explanatory document titled"NYSP Member Resumes." A Member Resume, according to the unsigned and unsworndocument's provisions, is an "incident summary or synopsis" for the subject NYSP employees'disciplinary matters. The explanatory document describes the four ways in which "complaints aretypically closed," and states that although "[d]isciplinary investigations result in underlying [*6]records being generated [those] records are not being automaticallyprovided along with Member Resumes." The explanatory document also indicates that "NYSPhas provided [the DA's] office with files, identified by employee name, containing letters ofcensure on founded personnel complaints for that employee."

This showing fails to establish the People's due diligence and reasonable inquiries toascertain the existence of CPL §245.20(1)(k) material and information. The Peopledemonstrated only that they disclosed their three law enforcement witnesses' "Member Resumes"and nothing more. They simply offered no facts concerning the underlying search that led to the"Member Resumes" disclosure, without which no finding of due diligence can be made.

Moreover, although specifically requested by the defense, the People did not provide anyletters of censure for their law enforcement witnesses and offered no explanation for the failure.This non-disclosure has occurred despite the Member Resumes explanatory document'sstatement that the NYSP have turned all letters of censure over to the People. In an unswornmemorandum ADA Schultz states that "upon information and belief, everything turned over bythe State Police was provided to the defendant in this case." She did not explain the basis for her"information and belief." Nor did she explain the discrepancy between the censure letters'nondisclosure and the explanatory document's assertion that such censure letters were providedto the People. This unexplained contradiction precludes a finding that the People have compliedwith their obligations under CPL §245.20(1)(k).

Similarly, the People offered no explanation for the NYSP's noncompliance with theirStanding Request. As set forth above, the Standing Request asked the NYSP to provide thePeople with unredacted copies of all impeachment materials. The Member Resumes explanatorydocument, however, describes their disclosure as a summary of disciplinary reviews. The NYSPspecifically declined the People's request to provide unredacted impeachment materials andinstead explicitly stated that the "underlying records are not being automatically provided." ThePeople offered no explanation for the NYSP's non-compliance. Nor have the People offered anyexplanation about NYSP's failure to provide "Employment Applications and BackgroundChecks." The People's Standing Request sought such documents from the NYSP, the defense hasdemanded them, yet no explanation for their non-disclosure has been offered. Due to theseunexplained gaps in their disclosure, the People did not demonstrate their compliance with CPL§245.20(1)(k) and failed to file a proper CoC in accord with CPL §245.50(3).

Accordingly, the People shall file and serve a Supplemental CoC that demonstrates fullcompliance with CPL §245.20(1)(k) on or before October 22, 2021 at 1:30 pm.



Trial Ready Inquiry

On July 30, 2021, this Court conducted its CPL §30.30(5) Trial Ready Inquiry ("TRI")and now finds that the People's Statement of Readiness ("SoR") is not valid.

On January 1, 2020, the law governing the People's statement of ready for trail wassignificantly altered. L.2019, c. 59, pt. KKK, § 1. The change now requires the Court,pursuant to CPL §30.30(5), to conduct a trail ready inquiry:

Whenever pursuant to this section a prosecutor states or otherwise provides noticethat the people are ready for trial, the court shall make inquiry on the record as to their actualreadiness. If, after conducting its inquiry, the court determines that the people are not [*7]ready to proceed to trial, the prosecutor's statement or notice ofreadiness shall not be valid for purposes of this section. Any statement of trial readiness must beaccompanied or preceded by a certification of good faith compliance with the disclosurerequirements of section 245.20 of this chapter and the defense shall be afforded an opportunity tobe heard on the record as to whether the disclosure requirements have been met

Prior to this new trial ready inquiry legislation, Court of Appeals'precedent had held that "a statement of readiness is presumed valid, and a defendant whochallenges such a statement must demonstrate that it is illusory by showing that the People werenot actually ready at the time they filed it." People v Brown, 28 NY3d 392, 407 (2016); see generallyDonnino, McKinney Practice Commentary, CPL §30.30. By declining to include anypresumption in CPL §30.30(5), the legislature unambiguously abrogated the presumptionendorsed by the Court of Appeals in People v Brown. Instead, CPL §30.30(5) laysno burden on the defense and requires the court to "make inquiry on the record as to the[People's] actual readiness." Id. (emphasis added). This is not a discoveryrequirement under CPL Article 245, as the People correctly note, but rather an obligation of thecourt to ensure that the People are actually ready for trial. see generally People v Lobato, 66 Misc 3d 1230(A) (Crim Ct,Kings County 2020), NY Senate Debate on Senate Bill S1509-C, March 31, 2019 at 2599, NYAssembly Debate on Assembly Bill A2009-C, March 31, 2019 at 340.

With the "actual readiness" inquiry, the new legislation imposed two prerequisites to a validannouncement of ready for trial. The first requirement, set forth in CPL §245.50(3), requiresthe People to file a proper CPL §245.50(1) certificate of discovery compliance. CPL§30.30(5) itself reiterates this mandate and, with CPL §245.50(4), provides the defensewith an opportunity to challenge the People's disclosure. The second precondition, applicableonly in a misdemeanor prosecution, requires the People to certify that all pending accusatoryinstruments are facially sufficient in accord with the requirements of CPL §§100.15and 100.40. CPL §30.30(5-a).

Although the legislation requires an "actual readiness" inquiry and sets prerequisites to avalid announcement of ready, it did not further define "actual readiness." Court of Appealscaselaw, however, fills this void. In one of its seminal decisions on trial readiness the Court ofAppeals explained "the prosecutor must make his [or her] statement of readiness when thePeople are in fact ready to proceed. The statute contemplates an indication of present readiness,not a prediction or expectation of future readiness." People v Kendzia, 64 NY2d 331,337 (1985). Similarly controlling, "readiness is not defined simply by an empty declaration thatthe People are prepared to present their direct case." People v England, 84 NY2d 1, 4(1994). "[R]eadiness requires more than simply 'mouthing' the words." People v Sibblies, 22 NY3d 1174,1177 (2014). The Court of Appeals has made the obligation clear: the People must evaluate theproof they are presently able to present at trial and, in exercising their professional judgment,honestly state that their proof would establish a pima face case at trial. see generally People v Richardson, 192AD3d 432 (1st Dept 2021), Peoplev Zale, 137 AD3d 634 (1st Dept 2016), People v Williams, Albany CountyCourt, July 6, 2021, Ackerman, J. index No. DA 260-20.

Similarly evident, the obligation to state actual readiness requires more from the People thanbeing a mere advocate. "Prosecutors, in their role as advocates and public officers, are chargedwith seeing that justice is done—to act impartially, to have fair dealing with the accused,to be candid with the courts, and to safeguard the rights of all." Matter of Kurtzrock,[*8]192 AD3d 197, 219 (2d Dept 2020); see also 22 NYCRR1200 - Rule 3.8(a)("A prosecutor shall not maintain a criminal charge when the lawyer knowsor it is obvious that the charge is not supported by probable cause.") The People's statement ofreadiness must be viewed in light of this fundamental pillar of our criminal justice system: aprosecutor must seek and do justice.

Applying the requisite standards, the People's SoR is not valid in two distinct ways.

First, CPL §245.50(3) requires a finding that the People are not ready for trial. As setforth above, because the People have not demonstrated compliance with CPL §245.20(1)(k)for their law enforcement witnesses they have not yet filed a proper CoC. This precludes a validstatement of ready. According to CPL §245.50(3) the People "shall not be deemed ready fortrial for purposes of section 30.30 until" they have filed a proper CoC. As such, the People's SoRis not valid.

Second, the People failed to sufficiently demonstrate their "actual readiness" during theCourt's TRI. As part of the TRI the People did not indicate that an evidence based prosecutionwould be viable in this action, but instead specifically identified the witnesses they considernecessary for trial. For those witnesses, however, the People declined to answer the Court'squestions about their actual readiness. The People would not state whether theirnecessary witnesses were ready, willing, and able to testify, or even whether they had spokenwith them. They did not claim that they had evaluated their witnesses. Nor did they make anassertion that they were presently able to present testimony at trial to establish a pima face case.Because the People chose not to offer any information about their necessary witnesses' readiness,they failed to demonstrate that they are presently ready to offer sufficient evidence to present aprima facie case at trial. Thus, the People failed to establish their "actual readiness."

The People seek to justify their refusal to answer questions about their witnesses bymisconstruing what "actual readiness" means. The People state:

[W]hether any particular witness is cooperative or available impacts whether thePeople will be able to sustain its ultimate burden a trial, not whether it is ready to proceed. (ADASchultz Memorandum p. 7).

While it may be ill-advised undermost circumstances, the People could theoretically proceed to trial without ever speaking with avictim or other witness but instead focus their trial preparations on the evidence contained in thecase file itself. Under those circumstances, it is the People's ability to prevail at trial that may beimpacted, not their ability to proceed to trial (ADA Schultz Memorandum p.9).

[W]hether a victim — or any witness for that matter— has affirmatively indicated that he or she is ready, willing, and able to testify is of noreal consequence to the People's statement of trial readiness. To hold otherwise would conflatethe standard of whether the people are ready for trial with whether the People will successfullypresent their case at trial. (ADA Schultz Memorandum p. 11)

Theseassertions indicate a misinterpretation of "actual readiness." They demonstrate the People'swillingness to provide the Court with an empty declaration of ready, without a present ability topresent a prima face case that could prevail at trial. It bears repeating, such "an empty declarationthat the People are prepared to present their direct case" is insufficient. People v [*9]England, supra. Of course, the People will not always prevail attrial, but that is not the inquiry. Rather, it is the People's knowledge of their ability to present aprima face case and their demonstrating such ability at the Court's trial ready inquiry. Where thePeople state ready at a time when they know that they do not have the present ability to offerprima facie evidence at trial, their statement of ready is invalid. It would constitute nothing morethan "'mouthing' the words," which is simply not enough. People v Sibblies, supra.

The People also offered hypothetical safety concerns to justify their position but offered nocase specific facts arising in this action that would justify a deviation from their statutoryobligation to demonstrate "actual readiness." This court is both cognizant of and sensitive to thevery real safety concerns surrounding witnesses in certain domestic violence cases. Every effortmust be made to ensure the safety of a complaining witness to preserve their ability to have theircase heard. While the theoretical concerns of witness intimidation and batter's syndrome are toooften present and demonstrable in cases before this court, in this action the People made nofactual showing that the complaining witnesses' safety is threatened. Tellingly, the People havenot sought a protective order, pursuant to CPL §245.70, to address a specific safety concernin this action. Instead, they rely on conjured hypotheticals and possibilities, with no basis in thefacts of this case. Because the law provides no blanket exception that permits the People todeclare trial readiness in domestic violence cases when they are not actually ready, this courtcannot and will not create the exception the People seek.

Lastly, the People's reliance on People v Adams (72 Misc 3d 1208[A], Orange Co Ct 2021) iswholly unavailing. The Adams court specifically noted that the People and the defensewere in contact with that case's complaining witnesses. Here, the People have made no suchrepresentation. In Adams the witness was not absent and was otherwise subject to asubpoena. In this action, the People have made no such showing. While the Adams courtexamined the complaining "witnesses' desire to testify [and] the witnesses availability to testify,"the People made no such distinction in this action. Rather, the record is silent. The People offeredno proof of their witnesses' desire, availability, or readiness. As correctly observed inAdams, "[a] witness indicating she has no interest in testifying does not make thatwitness unavailable, and a prosecution does not necessarily end because a witness may havebecome reluctant to cooperate." The People in this action, however, did not demonstratereluctance. They made no showing whatsoever. On this lack of proof, the People failed todemonstrate "actual readiness."

Accordingly, the court will conduct a second trial ready inquiry at which the People mustdemonstrate "actual readiness" on October 22, 2021 at 1:30 pm.



Motion to Preclude Statements & Identifications - CPL§710.30

Defendant moves for an order, in accord with CPL §710.30, precluding the People fromoffering at trial any statements or identifications that he was not provided notice of within 15days of his arraignment. The People concede that they did not serve a timely CPL §710.30notice. The statutory remedy for the People's failure to provide the required notice is preclusion.CPL §710.30(3); People v Lopez, 84 NY2d 425 (1994). Accordingly, defendant'smotion is granted. The People are hereby precluded from introducing at trial any identificationevidence of defendant and any statements allegedly made by defendant that were not turned overas required by CPL §710.30(1).



Motion for a Sandoval/Ventimiglia/Molineux Hearing

Defendant moves this Court for a hearing to determine the admissibility of any prior crimesor bad acts committed by defendant. Under People v Sandoval, 34 NY2d 371 (1974),defendant is entitled to a hearing to determine the admissibility, in cross examinationimpeachment of defendant, of prior criminal convictions. Under People v Molineux, 168NY 264 (1901) defendant is entitled to a pre-trial hearing to determine the admissibility ofuncharged crimes committed by defendant as part of the People's direct case. Under People vVentimiglia, 52 NY2d 350 (1981), defendant is entitled to a hearing on the admissibility ofevidence of uncharged crimes which do not directly inculpate defendant but from which guiltmay be inferred. As such, defendant's motion is granted and the requested hearing will be held atleast two weeks prior to trial.



Motion for Brady Material

Defendant moves for an Order pursuant to Brady v Maryland, 373 US 83 (1963). Inthat case, the Supreme Court held that the People must disclose to a criminal defendant evidencein its possession that is (1) favorable to defendant and (2) material either to guilt or punishment.This rule rests on the premise that proceedings cannot be fair if evidence is withheld which castsdoubt on the guilt of defendant. People v Vilardi, 76 NY2d 67 (1990). It is incumbent onthe People, as a matter of due process, to ensure that material evidence in its possession that isexculpatory in nature be turned over to defendant. People v Novoa, 70 NY2d 490 (1987).The People are directed to do so as such evidence, if any, comes into their possession.



Renewal of Motions

Criminal Procedure Law §255.20(1) mandates that all pre-trial motions be broughtwithin one set of moving papers within forty-five (45) days of arraignment. To that extent,defendant's request for leave to submit further motions is denied. Defendant may make suchfurther motions and applications that he could not with due diligence have raised in his originalmotion papers that are not inconsistent with Article 255 of the CPL.



People's Motion to Compel Discovery

CPL §245.20(4) requires the defense to provide the people with "reciprocal discovery"and then, pursuant to CPL §245.50(2), defendant must certify that all such discovery hasbeen provided to the People. Here, in response to the People's motion to compel a CPL§245.50(2) certification, defendant served both discovery and the required certification.Because the People have made no claim of prejudice as a result of the late certification, thePeople's motion to compel is denied as moot.



Other Motions and Scheduling Order

All motions not granted herein are hereby denied.

The foregoing constitutes the Decision and Order of this Court.



ENTER.

SO ORDERED.

This 15th day of October, 2021

Albany, New York

Joshua L.Farrell

Albany City Court Judge



Papers Considered:

1. Notice of Motion and Affirmation of Kelly Vidur,dated June 24, 2021.

2. Notice of Affirmation and Affirmation in Opposition ofAlexandra VonStackelberg, dated July 13, 2021, with exhibits.

3. Certificate of Compliance of Ryan Murphy, dated June 16, 2021.

4.Certificate of Compliance, Statement of Readiness of Alexandra VonStackelberg, dated July 13,2021.

5. Supplemental Certificate of Compliance, Statement of Readiness ofAlexandra VonStackelberg, dated July 26, 2021.

6. Supplemental Certificate ofCompliance, Statement of Readiness of Alexandra VonStackelberg, dated August 10, 2021.

7. Standing Affirmation of Due Diligence Under CPL Article 245 of David Rossi, datedJanuary 20, 2021, with exhibit. (filed four times)

8. Letter Brief of Kelly Vidur, datedJuly 27, 2021.

9. Letter Brief of Alexandra VonStackelberg, dated July 29, 2021.

10 Notice of Affirmation, Affirmation of Alexandra VonStackelberg, dated August 12,2021, Memorandum of Law of Emily Schults, dated August 11, 2021, with exhibits.

11. Notice of Affirmation in Opposition and Affirmation in Opposition of KellyVidur, dated August 31, 2021.

12. Notice of Affirmation and Affirmation in Opposition of AlexandraVonStackelberg, dated September 1, 2021, with exhibit.

13. Notice of Motion andAffirmation of Alexandra VonStackelberg, dated August 4, 2021.

14. Defendant'sDisclosure of Kelly Vidur, dated August 31, 2021, Defendant's Certificate of Compliance ofKelly Vidur, dated August 31, 2021.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:The complaining witness will bereferred to herein by her initials.

Footnote 2:After this matter was fullysubmitted the People, on September 20, 2021, filed a fifth CoC disclosing a "search warrant andassociated documents." This further submission is not at issue on this motion.




NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.