[*1]
People v Sozoranga-Palacios
2021 NY Slip Op 51036(U) [73 Misc 3d 1214(A)]
Decided on September 30, 2021
Criminal Court Of The City Of New York, New York County
Stein, J.
This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports.


Decided on September 30, 2021
Criminal Court of the City of New York, New York County


The People of theState of New York,

against

Jordan Sozoranga-Palacios, Defendant




Docket No. CR-024237-20NY
Saul Stein, J.

The following papers were considered in reviewing this motion by defendant to strikethe People's Certificate of Compliance dated February 1, 2021:

Papers DateFiled

Notice of Motion and annexed Exhibits and Affidavits 4/20/21

Affirmation in Response and annexed Exhibits 5/06/21

Affirmation in Reply5/11/21

Sur-Reply 6/10/21

Court File

Defendant is charged by Information with two counts of Forcible Touching (PL§130.52 [1] and [2]), both class A misdemeanors and one count of Sexual Abuse in theThird Degree (PL § 130.55) a class B misdemeanor. The Complaint, subscribed by thearresting officer, Detective Michael Orlando, alleges that on November 20, 2020 at about8:55AM, Defendant touched the buttocks of the complaining witness on a southbound "4"train.

Defendant's motion, 1) seeks to invalidate the People's Certificate of Compliance ("CoC")dated February 1, 2021 pursuant to CPL §§ 245.20 and 245.50; 2) seeks Wade,Huntley and Dunaway hearings; and 3) seeks a Sandoval hearing and Molineux disclosure.

Defendant contends that the CoC filed by the People on February 1, 2021 should beinvalidated because the People have failed to provide sufficient automatic initial discoverypursuant to CPL § 245.20. Defendant argues that the People failed to provide, 1) adequatecontact information for the complaining witness as required by CPL § 245.20(1)(c); 2) lawenforcement personnel and disciplinary files for the arresting officer and other officers identifiedin the automatic discovery form dated February 1, 2021 pursuant to CPL§ 245.20(1)(k)(iv),and 3) other evidence with which the arresting officer and other officers came into contact. ThePeople's response stated that they provided all required disclosure. In Defendant's reply,Defendant alleged additional missing items and argued that the CoC should also be struck basedupon a missing recording of a call to the NYPD. The People filed a sur-reply in response.

Specifically, the base motion argues that the CoC is invalid because a Disclosure AdvisoryForm turned over on January 27, 2021, relating to a substantiated violation of police departmentrules by Detective Orlando, is not accompanied by the underlying documentation of the InternalAffairs Bureau ("IAB") investigation of the complaint. The Disclosure Advisory [*2]Form reveals that sometime on or before December 5, 2011,Detective Orlando posted an inflammatory statement containing foul language in a Facebookgroup and that such conduct constituted a violation of "Other Department Rules." Defendantargues that the People were obligated to turn over the entire file and that the one-page DisclosureAdvisory Form about the substantiated complaint was insufficient.

Also, raised for the first time in Defendant's reply papers is the People's failure to turn overthe recording of a call made by an MTA worker to the NYPD, that was referenced in a report ofan interview with the complaining witness (see CPL § 245.20(1)(g)). The People's sur-replystates that the referenced call was made on "6wire", an internal system used by the MTA tocontact the NYPD, and that a copy of the recording was immediately turned over afterDefendant's reply was filed.

ApplicableLaw

On January 1, 2020, Article 245 replaced Article 240 of theCriminal Procedure Law, expanding discovery in criminal cases. Pursuant to CPL §245.20(1), prosecutors are required to disclose "all items and information that relate to thesubject matter of the case that are in the possession, custody or control of the prosecution orpersons under the prosecution's direction and control." The section further provides anon-exhaustive list of materials subject to disclosure under this provision (CPL §245.20[1][a]-[u]).

CPL § 245.20(2) requires that, "[T]he prosecutor shall make a diligent, good faith effortto ascertain the existence of material or information discoverable under subdivision one of thissection and to cause such material or information to be made available for discovery where itexists but is not within the prosecutor's possession, custody, or control; provided that theprosecutor shall not be required to obtain by subpoena duces tecum material or informationwhich the defendant may thereby obtain." The section further provides, "all items andinformation related to the prosecution of a charge in the possession of any New York state orlocal police or law enforcement agency shall be deemed to be in the possession of theprosecution."

The new discovery statute is unlike the former [CPL former 240.20] and requires theprosecution to provide expansive automatic disclosure to Defendant. Automatic "means that thedefendant is not obliged to "demand" discovery; rather, the People are obligated to provide the"automatic" disclosure of the listed items regardless of a defense "demand," and they must do sonormally within a short period after arraignment on an accusatory instrument. . .[T]heprosecutor's obligations to provide discovery under the current statutes are so broad as tovirtually constitute "open file" discovery, or at least make "open file" discovery the far bettercourse of action to assure compliance. . . .Thus, a prosecutor who fails to engage in "open file"discovery (except for "work product" and information subject to a protective mandate of a statuteor court order) may do so at his or her professional peril while also jeopardizing the viability of aprosecution." (William C. Donnino, Practice Commentary, McKinney's CPL §245.10.)

CPL § 245.50(3) establishes that the filing of a proper Certificate of Compliance is aprerequisite to the People being deemed ready for trial for the purposes of CPL § 30.30.CPL § 245.50(1) provides in part that, "no adverse consequence to the prosecution or theprosecutor shall result from the filing of a certificate of compliance in good faith and reasonableunder the circumstances; but the court may grant a remedy or sanction for a discovery violationas provided in section 245.80 of this article." Read together, these sections allow the reasonable[*3]inference that a certificate of compliance is proper within themeaning of CPL § 245.50(3) if it is filed in good faith and is reasonable under thecircumstances (People v Perez, 2021 NY Slip Op 21165 [Sup Ct Queens County2021]).



Complaining Witness' Contact Information

CPL § 245.20(1)(c) requires that as part of initial disclosure, the prosecution mustprovide a defendant with, "the names and adequate contact information for all persons other thanlaw enforcement personnel whom the prosecutor knows to have evidence or information relevantto any offense charged or to any potential defense thereto. . . ."

There is no dispute that as part of its initial disclosure on January 27, 2021 the Peopleprovided, within its "Addendum to Automatic Discovery Form," the name of the complainingwitness, along with an indication that the witness could be contacted through the WitComsystem. WitCom is an app-based system that allows defense counsel to contact witnesses througha proxy phone number without the witness' personal phone number being disclosed. Defendantcontends that the WitCom system does not satisfy the requirements of CPL § 245.20(1)(c).There are conflicting determinations among trial courts with regard whether the WitCom systemsatisfies the requirements of CPL § 245.20(1)(c). This Court is persuaded by those casesfinding that the WitCom system provides defendants with adequate witness contact information(see People v Perez, 2021 NY Slip Op 21165 [Sup Ct Queens County 2021]; People v Todd, 67 Misc 3d 566[Sup Ct Queens County 2020]; People vEscamilla, 70 Misc 3d 1216 [Sup Ct Kings County 2021]; People v Jean Baptiste; 70 Misc 3d706 [Crim Ct NY County 2020]). The Court declines to follow People v Feng,NYLJ, Feb. 28, 2020, at 21, col 1, 2020 NYLJ LEXIS 501 [Sup Ct Kings County 2020] in whichthe court found the WitCom system to be inadequate.



Police Officers' Disciplinary Records and Material Underlying the 2011Substantiated Complaint against Detective Orlando.

CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv) requires the People to turn over to a defendant as part of itsinitial discovery obligation, "all evidence and information, including that which is known topolice or other law enforcement agencies acting on the government's behalf in the case, that tendsto impeach the credibility of a testifying prosecution witness." Defendant contends that thePeople's failure to provide the full personnel and disciplinary files for Detective Orlando and theother officers identified in Automatic Disclosure Form violates the requirements of CPL §245.20(1)(k)(iv), thereby rendering the People's CoC invalid. The People respond that after anextensive search they have disclosed all known information required under CPL § 245.20.The People also state that they have conducted multiple searches to investigate the existence ofinformation responsive to the requirements of CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv) and have found noindication that Detective Orlando's personnel records or disciplinary records would reveal anyfurther impeachment information beyond what they have already disclosed. It is the People'sposition that CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv) does not obligate them to turn over the underlyingmaterials of the investigation, nor are they obligated to provide an officer's full disciplinary orpersonnel file as part of their CPL § 245.20 disclosure. Further, the People contend that theone-page Disclosure Advisory Form informing Defendant about a substantiated complaintsatisfies the People's obligation under CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv).

The People argue that their disclosure obligation is limited by the language of CPL §245.20(1) to "items and information that relate to the subject matter of the case," as well as thelanguage of CPL § 245.20(2) limiting information "in the possession of any New York stateor [*4]local police or law enforcement agency [that] shall bedeemed to be in the possession of the prosecution," to information "related to the prosecution of acharge." Some Courts (see eg. People v Perez, 2021 NY Slip Op 21165 [Sup Ct QueensCounty 2021]; People v Knight, 69Misc 3d 546 [Sup Ct Bx County 2020]; People v Garcia, 2021 NY Slip Op 50791[Sup Ct Kings County 2021]) have agreed with this narrow reading of the People's discoveryobligations, holding that a prosecutor's obligation is satisfied by the production of a summary ofthe charges, without the need to disclose the underlying records of the investigation. TheseCourts have held that the prosecutor's obligation to provide underlying materials is limited toimpeachment items connected to the instant defendant's case.

In People v McKinney, 71 Misc3d 1221 [Crim Ct Kings County 2021], that Court reasoned that the use of the word "all" inCPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv) is intended to expand the disclosure obligations with regard toimpeachment materials beyond those directly related to the current Court action. (See also People v Altug, 70 Misc 3d1218 [Crim Ct NY County 2021] [holding that CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv) is applicablenot just to impeachment material related to the defendant's own case, but to matters of generalcredibility as well].)

In reaching its conclusion that all impeachment material must be disclosed, theMcKinney Court examined whether CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv) merely codified therequirements of Brady v Maryland, 373 US 83 (1963), or expanded on them. It concludedthat "by [abandoning] the materiality requirement of Brady in favor of broader disclosuresencompassing all evidence and information which tends to impeach the credibility of a testifyingprosecution witness . . . irrespective of whether the prosecutor credits the information," CPL§ 245.20(1)(k)(iv) intended to expand on Brady. The McKinney Courtfurther found that CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv) expanded the scope of impeachment material toinclude items known to the prosecution or law enforcement agencies whether or not the conductwas related to the officer's official duties, and that such disclosure should include all evidenceand information including underlying materials from internal police department investigations,not just summaries.

A similar conclusion was reached by the Court in People v Randolph, [Sup CtSuffolk County 2020]. The Randolph Court pointed to the language of CPL §245.20(7) that, "there shall be a presumption in favor of disclosure when interpreting sections245.10 and 245.25, and subdivision one of section 245.20, of this article," in applying a broadinterpretation of the statute.

By limiting impeachment related disclosures only to allegations of officer misconduct relatedto the subject matter of the current case as advocated in Perez and Knight, or bylimiting disclosure of impeachment material to material determined by the prosecutor asdiscoverable, the People would be placed in a position of inordinate control over what should orshould not be disclosed to a defendant with regard to the officer's disciplinary file. Given thebroadness of the discovery requirements and the intentional, wholesale expansion of theseobligations, the better interpretation is the more expansive one that CPL § 245.20(1)(k)(iv)applies to all disciplinary records tending to implicate the credibility of a law enforcementwitness, whether the conduct is related to the charges in defendant's case or not. Further, CPL§ 245.20(1)(k)(iv)'s use of the word "all" should be read as bringing impeachment materialwithin the meaning of, "related to the prosecution of the charge." Hence, the full IAB files, whichare deemed within the possession of the People, are subject to disclosure to the extent theycontain impeachment material. (See also People v Salters, 72 Misc 3d 1219 [Dist CtNassau County 2021]; People v. Williams, 72 Misc 3d 1214 [Crim Ct NY County 2021];People v Kelly, 71 Misc 3d1202 [Crim [*5]Ct NY County 2021]; People v Altug, 70 Misc 3d 1218[Crim Ct NY County 2021]).

This is not to say that the People have a blanket requirement to turn over full policepersonnel records as part of their automatic discovery. Rather, pursuant to CPL §245.20(1)(k)(iv), the People are obligated to turn over law enforcement records which tend to"impeach the credibility of a testifying prosecution witness," even if they are unrelated to thecurrent charges, and that the People are not the arbiter of whether information, in fact, impeachesthe credibility of a testifying prosecution witness. Therefore, in this matter, the People areobligated to turn over to Defendant, the underlying documentation relating to the substantiatedcharge against Detective Orlando.



Recording of 6Wire Call from MTA to NYPD

The People acknowledge that on November 20, 2020, a communication from the MTA toNYPD was made about this matter via 6Wire. It is not disputed that a copy of the electroniccommunication was not turned over until May 12, 2021. The People offer no explanation for thefailure to provide the recording of the 6wire call with the initial disclosure made on January 27,2021. CPL § 245.20(1)(g) requires a prosecutor to turn over, "all tapes or other electronicrecordings, including all electronic recordings of 911 telephone calls made or received inconnection with the alleged criminal incident." When a prosecutor is aware of the existence ofdiscoverable recordings, the failure to obtain and disclose them exemplifies a lack of duediligence, even when, as here, the prosecutor later provides the recording after the omission isbrought to their attention by a defendant (see People v Aquino, 72 Misc 3d 518 [Crim Ct Kings County 2021]).Hence, the recording of the 6wire call made on the date of the incident was not turned over in atimely matter.

The people cite CPL § 245.50(1) and CPL § 245.60 in support of their contentionthat the failure to turn over the recording of the 6wire call with the initial disclosure should notprovide a basis to invalidate the CoC. CPL § 245.60 provides that if either party"subsequently learns of additional material or information which it would have been under a dutyto disclose pursuant to any provisions of this article had it known of it at the time of a previousdiscovery obligation or discovery order, it shall expeditiously notify the other party" and disclosethe materials with a supplemental certificate of compliance. CPL § 245.50(1) provides thatthere should be "no adverse consequence to the prosecution" where the certificate is filed "ingood faith" and reasonably under the circumstances. This argument is unavailing as thecontinuing disclosure obligations in CPL § 245.60 relate specifically to materials previouslyunknown or unavailable to the People. Here, the People were aware of the existence of thecommunication between the MTA and NYPD, as reference to said communication was containedin the Interview in Person turned over by the People with the initial automatic discovery (see, People v Aquino, 72 Misc 3d 518[Crim Ct Kings County 2021]) and said material was available to the People.

"The filing of the certificate of compliance pursuant to CPL § 30.30 (5) could not bedeemed complete until all of the material and information identified in the certificate as subjectto discovery and electronically shared with the defendant was actually produced to the defendant,pursuant to CPL 245.50(1) and (3)" (People ex rel Ferro v Brann, 2021 NY Slip Op04897 [2nd Dept 2021]). The Court finds that the underlying documentation of the substantiatedcharge against Detective Orlando is discoverable and was not turned over to Defendant prior tothe filing of the CoC. Accordingly, the CoC filed by the People on February 1, 2021 is invalid.Further, given the clear language of CPL §245.20(7) that "there shall be a presumption infavor of disclosure when interpreting sections 245.10 and 245.25;" and as the People did notavail [*6]themselves of the opportunity to seek a protective orderafforded to them by CPL § 245.70, the People did not rely in good faith in withholding thismaterial. Similarly, the People's failure to, and lack of any explanation for its delay in, turningover the recording of the 6wire call made on the date of the incident renders the February 1, 2021CoC invalid.

Accordingly, the branch of defendant's motions seeking to invalidate the People's Certificateof Compliance dated February 1, 2021 is GRANTED.

The People are directed to provide all IAB files, in any form, relating to the materialcontained in the Disclosure Advisory Form turned over on January 27, 2021 relating to asubstantiated claim against Detective Orlando to the Defendant no later than October 15,2021.

The 2nd and 3rd branches of the motion are granted to the extent thatWade/Huntley/Dunaway hearings are to be held prior to trial. The Defendant's request fora Sandoval hearing is referred to the Trial Court.

This constitutes the opinion, decision, and order of the Court.



DATED: September 30, 2021
New York, New York
SAUL STEIN
JUDGE OF THE CRIMINAL COURT


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.