People v Hewitt
2022 NY Slip Op 00079 [201 AD3d 1041]
January 6, 2022
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 9, 2022


[*1]
 The People of the State of New York,Respondent,
v
James Hewitt, Appellant.

Steven M. Sharp, Albany, for appellant.

Jason M. Carusone, District Attorney, Lake George (Robert P. McCarty of counsel), forrespondent.

Colangelo, J. Appeal from a judgment of the County Court of Warren County (Hall Jr., J.),rendered December 23, 2020, convicting defendant upon his plea of guilty of the crime ofpromoting a sexual performance by a child.

Defendant and his wife were charged in a 14-count indictment with various sex crimesstemming from their conduct, during the summer of 2019, in taking pictures of children underthe age of 17 in varying degrees of nudity using a camera in a pen in the bathroom of anamusement park in Warren County. In satisfaction of all charges,[FN1] defendant pleaded guilty to promoting a sexualperformance by a child as charged in count 11 of the indictment, admitting that he and his wifetook pictures of partially or fully nude children under 17 years old. In exchange, defendant waspromised a prison term of no less than 1 to 3 years and no more than 2 to 6 years, and wasrequired to waive his right to appeal. Prior to sentencing, defendant retained new counsel andmoved to withdraw his plea as not knowing, voluntary and intelligent premised upon the People'sclaimed failure to comply with CPL article 245, the new discovery statute. Defendant also arguedthat he was denied the effective assistance of counsel at the time of his plea. County Court deniedthe motion in a written decision. In accordance with the plea agreement, County Court sentenceddefendant to a prison term of 2 to 6 years. Defendant appeals.

We affirm. Defendant argues that the People's failure to comply with the CPL article 245disclosure requirements prior to his guilty plea and counsel's ineffectiveness rendered his plea notknowing, voluntary and intelligent, and required that his motion to withdraw his plea be granted.Defendant's challenge to the voluntariness of his plea survives his unchallenged waiver of appealand is preserved by his motion to withdraw his plea (see People v Mills, 189 AD3d 1826, 1827 [2020]). In 2019, CPLarticle 245 was adopted, which imposed on the People broad automatic disclosure obligationsincluding prior to guilty pleas (see CPL 245.20, 245.25), replacing CPL article 240; itbecame effective as of January 1, 2020 (L 2019, ch 59, § 1, part LLL,§ 2; see William C. Donnino, Practice Commentary, McKinney's ConsLaws of NY, Book 11A, CPL 245.10, 2021 Pocket Part at 8).[FN2] Pursuant to CPL 245.20 (1), the prosecutionmust disclose "all items and information that relate to the subject matter of the case and are in thepossession, custody or control of the prosecution or persons under the prosecution's direction orcontrol," including, as relevant here, when the prosecution has made a guilty plea offer to resolvean indictment (see CPL 245.25 [2]). As the People acknowledge, defendant entered aguilty plea on February 19, 2020 and, thus, CPL article 245 was in effect and applied to his plea(compare People v Pizarro, 185AD3d 1092, 1093 [2020]).[FN3] Although timely disclosure must occur at leastseven days before any plea offer is set to expire, here [*2]therecord does not reflect that there was a deadline on the plea offer (see CPL 245.25 [2]).Where, as here, defendant makes a motion premised upon the People's noncompliance with thisprovision, "the court must consider the impact of any violation on the defendant's decision toaccept or reject a plea offer" (CPL 245.25 [2]; see William C. Donnino, PracticeCommentary, McKinney's Cons Laws of NY, Book 11A, CPL 245.10, 2021 Pocket Part at26-27).[FN4]

The record reflects that, in 2019, the People served a trial readiness packet within days of theOctober arraignment and then responded to counsel's demand to produce with extensivedisclosure in November. In December 2019, during ongoing plea negotiations concerning thisindictment and the charges pending in Albany County, defense counsel represented to CountyCourt, in writing, that the People had provided the defense "with most, if not all, of the discoveryrelated to this matter" and waived "any timeliness objections as it relates [sic] to discovery inconnection with this matter." As such, the defense waived compliance with the disclosurerequired prior to defendant's guilty plea (see CPL 245.25 [2]; 245.75).[FN5] Even if that waiver were notsufficient, the People substantially complied with the disclosure requirements; although theprosecutor concededly did not turn over the grand jury minutes as required (see CPL245.20 [1] [b]), our review of those minutes fails to substantiate defendant's conclusory claimthat their nondisclosure had any impact on his decision to accept the plea offer, as the minutes donot negate his guilt and given the extensive timely disclosure of similar information to defensecounsel (see CPL 245.25 [2]).[FN6] With regard to the People's failure to file andserve a certificate of compliance with the disclosure rules, that requirement is tied to the People'sreadiness for trial (see CPL 245.50 [3]; William C. Donnino, Practice Commentary,McKinney's Cons Laws of NY, Book 11A, CPL 245.10, 2021 Pocket Part at 27-28), and theprovision governing disclosure prior to guilty pleas does not expressly require such a certificate(see CPL 245.25). In any event, there is no basis upon which to conclude that the failureto file a certificate impacted defendant's decision to enter a guilty plea.

We similarly find without merit defendant's arguments that he was denied the effectiveassistance of counsel at the time of his guilty plea, to the extent that such claims were raised andpreserved in his motion to withdraw his plea (see CPL 220.60 [3]). "In the context of aguilty plea, a defendant has been afforded meaningful representation when he or she receives anadvantageous plea and nothing in the record casts doubt upon the apparent effectiveness ofcounsel" (People v LaPierre, 195AD3d 1301, 1306 [2021] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]). Defense counselsecured a favorable plea deal that required defendant to enter a guilty plea to only one of the[*3]six indicted charges against him, avoided potentialconsecutive sentencing for the distinct crimes (see Penal Law § 70.25 [2]),ensured a sentence less than the maximum for the crime to which he was entering a guilty pleaand permitted him to advocate for a minimum sentence (see Penal Law§ 70.00 [2] [d]). Counsel also negotiated for concurrent sentences on the AlbanyCounty charges.

Moreover, contrary to defendant's claims in moving to withdraw his plea, after he was swornin during the plea allocution, he assured County Court that he was satisfied with counsel'srepresentation, he had sufficient time to discuss his plea with counsel, his learning disability didnot prevent him from understanding the proceedings and he had been able to effectivelycommunicate with counsel, who had explained the law and his options including going to trial.Defendant indicated that he understood that his guilty plea would waive any defenses and, whencounsel advised the court that he had discussed with defendant the strength of the People's caseand available defenses, defendant did not contradict him, raise any concerns or ask any questionswhen provided with the opportunity to do so. Defendant has not shown that counsel's decision topursue plea negotiations and not file an omnibus motion lacked a legitime strategic reason or thatsuch a motion would have had colorable merit (see People v Caban, 5 NY3d 143, 152 [2005]; People v Sabin, 179 AD3d 1401,1403 [2020], lv denied 35 NY3d 995 [2020]). To the extent that many of defendant'sclaims concern matters appearing both on and outside of the record regarding counsel'srepresentation, such as what counsel investigated, they are more properly addressed together in amotion pursuant to CPL article 440 (seePeople v McCoy, 198 AD3d 1021, 1023 [2021]; People v Taylor, 156 AD3d 86, 89-92 [2017], lv denied 30NY3d 1120 [2018]).

"Whether to permit a defendant to withdraw his or her plea of guilty is left to the sounddiscretion of County Court, and withdrawal will generally not be permitted absent some evidenceof innocence, fraud or mistake in its inducement" (People v Simpson, 196 AD3d 996, 997 [2021] [internal quotationmarks and citations omitted], lv denied 37 NY3d 1029 [2021]). Defendant has not shownany such basis to have warranted permitting him to withdraw his plea. To that end, the transcriptof the plea allocution demonstrates that defendant was clearly advised of the plea terms and thetrial rights he was foregoing by a guilty plea, and unequivocally admitted the charged conduct.Given our conclusion that defendant's challenges to his guilty plea are not supported by or arecontradicted by the record, which reflects that his guilty plea was a knowing, voluntary andintelligent choice among alternative courses of action, we find that County Court did not abuseits discretion in denying his motion to withdraw his guilty plea, without a hearing (see People v Conceicao, 26 NY3d375, 382 [2015]; People [*4]v Mills, 189 AD3d at1828; People v Burks, 187 AD3d1405, 1406-1407 [2020], lv denied 36 NY3d 1095 [2021]). Defendant's remainingclaims have been reviewed and found to be without merit.

Egan Jr., J.P., Clark, Aarons and Reynolds Fitzgerald, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgmentis affirmed.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:It was noted that defendant wasalso charged with similar conduct in Albany County. County Court made clear that thesentencing court in Albany County would thereafter decide whether to impose any sentenceconcurrently or consecutively to the Warren County sentence, but that the expectation was thatdefendant would receive the same sentence as imposed in Warren County, to be servedconcurrently. The record does not reflect the disposition of the Albany County charges.

Footnote 2:CPL article 245 was furtheramended effective May 3, 2020 (L 2020, ch 56, § 1, part HHH, § 1).

Footnote 3:As such, the retroactivityanalysis urged by defendant is unnecessary.

Footnote 4:CPL 245.25 (2) further providesthat, "[i]f the court finds that such violation materially affected the defendant's decision, andif the prosecution declines to reinstate the lapsed or withdrawn plea offer, thecourt—as a presumptive minimum sanction—must preclude the admission at trialof any evidence not disclosed as required under this subdivision" (emphasis added). We read thatsanction provision, and the "materially affect[s]" standard, as applying only where either adefendant declines a plea offer or it lapses or is withdrawn and defendant later claims thatfull disclosure did not occur. Accordingly, the "materially affect[s]" standard should not havebeen employed in People v Pizarro (185 AD3d at 1094), where the defendant pleadedguilty.

Footnote 5:In May 2020, after defendant'sguilty plea, CPL 245.75 (1) was amended to require that the court conduct an inquiry withdefendants to ensure their understanding of their right to discovery and to waive discovery.Notably, the plea agreement was not impermissibly conditioned on defendant waiving automaticdisclosure under CPL article 245 (see CPL 245.25 [2]).

Footnote 6:County Court's decision denyingdefendant's motion to withdraw his guilty plea does not mention or reflect that it reviewed thegrand jury minutes, which were provided to defense counsel for purposes of this appeal and, thus,we exercise our independent authority to review this evidence to determine if its nondisclosureimpacted the knowing, voluntary and intelligent nature of defendant's guilty plea.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.