| People v Williams |
| 2022 NY Slip Op 01845 [203 AD3d 1398] |
| March 17, 2022 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| The People of the State of New York,Respondent, v Duane Williams, Appellant. |
Erin C. Morigerato, Albany, for appellant.
Robert M. Carney, District Attorney, Schenectady (Peter H. Willis of counsel), forrespondent.
Clark, J. Appeal from a judgment of the County Court of Schenectady County (Sypniewski,J.), rendered June 24, 2019, convicting defendant upon his plea of guilty of the crime ofattempted robbery in the second degree.
In February 2018, defendant allegedly entered a convenience store with a knife and robbedthe store. Defendant was apprehended and thereafter waived indictment and pleaded guilty to asuperior court information charging him with attempted robbery in the second degree. As part ofthe plea agreement, defendant was required to waive his right to appeal, which he purportedly didboth orally and in writing. Consistent with the terms of the plea agreement, County Courtsentenced defendant to a prison term of 2
Initially, we find defendant's appeal waiver to be invalid, as the written waiver is overbroadand inaccurate, and "County Court did not overcome the overbroad language of the writtenwaiver by ensuring that defendant understood that some appellate and collateral review survivesan appeal waiver" (People v Lunan,196 AD3d 969, 970 [2021]; seePeople v Winters, 196 AD3d 847, 848-849 [2021], lv denied 37 NY3d 1030[2021]; People v Avera, 192 AD3d1382, 1382 [2021], lv denied 37 NY3d 953 [2021]; People v Anderson, 184 AD3d1020, 1021 [2020], lv denied 35 NY3d 1064 [2020]).[FN*] Given the invalidity of the appeal waiver, weturn to the balance of defendant's claims.
Defendant contends that his guilty plea was not knowing, voluntarily and intelligent. Thisclaim, however, is unpreserved for our review as the record does not reveal that defendant madean appropriate postallocution motion to withdraw his guilty plea despite having an opportunity todo so prior to sentencing (see CPL 220.60 [3]; People v Williams, 27 NY3d 212, 219-220 [2016]; People v Mercer, 169 AD3d 1112,1113-1114 [2019], lv denied 33 NY3d 979 [2019]; People v Jackson, 159 AD3d 1276, 1276 [2018], lv denied31 NY3d 1149 [2018]). Even assuming that the exception to the preservation requirement wastriggered by certain statements made by defendant during the course of the presentenceinvestigation, the record reveals that, at the sentencing proceeding, County Court fully satisfiedits duty to inquire further, clarifying that defendant was aware of the contents of the presentenceinvestigation report, that he had a chance to discuss it with counsel, that he was not attempting toraise any sort of defense of duress or coercion, that he was automatically forfeiting any suchdefense or defenses by pleading guilty and that he wished to proceed with the guilty plea (see People v Thompson, 110 AD3d1114, 1115 [2013], lv denied 22 NY3d 1091 [2014]; People v Mead, 64 AD3d 814, 815[2009], lv denied 14 NY3d 890 [2010]). "Having failed to express, in any way,dissatisfaction with the court's remedial action, defendant has waived any further challenge to theallocution, and thus no issue is preserved [*2]for our review"(People v Lopez, 71 NY2d 662, 668 [1988] [citation omitted]; accord People v Greene, 195 AD3d1317, 1318 [2021]; People vKarolys, 85 AD3d 1213, 1213 [2011], lv denied 17 NY3d 818 [2011]; cf. People v Jackson, 159 AD3d1276, 1276 [2018], lv denied 31 NY3d 1149 [2018]).
Defendant's contention that he received ineffective assistance of counsel, to the extent that itimpacts upon the voluntariness of his plea, is similarly unpreserved (see People v Nack, 200 AD3d1197, 1198 [2021]; People vJohnson, 194 AD3d 1267, 1269 [2021]). "[T]he balance of defendant's ineffectiveassistance of counsel claim, including that counsel failed to investigate the facts of his case,research the applicable law or advise him of potential defenses, involve matters outside therecord that are more properly the subject of a CPL article 440 motion" (People v McCoy, 198 AD3d 1021,1023 [2021], lv denied 37 NY3d 1162 [2022]; see People v Chrise, 197 AD3d 1357, 1359 [2021], lvdenied 37 NY3d 1059 [2021]; People v White, 172 AD3d 1822, 1824 [2019], lv denied 33NY3d 1110 [2019]). Finally, we reject defendant's claim that his sentence, which fell within thestatutory parameters for a class C felony offense (see Penal Law§§ 70.00 [2], [3]; 110.00, 110.05, 160.10), is harsh and excessive. CountyCourt imposed the agreed-upon sentence, and, upon our review of the record, including theinformation contained in the presentence report, we find no extraordinary circumstances or abuseof discretion that would warrant modification of the sentence in the interest of justice (see People v Chase, 168 AD3d1316, 1317 [2019]).
Egan Jr., J.P., Aarons, Reynolds Fitzgerald and McShan, JJ., concur. Ordered that thejudgment is affirmed.
Footnote *:We encourage County Court toreview the Model Colloquy for the waiver of the right to appeal (see NY ModelColloquies, Waiver of Right to Appeal,https://www.nycourts.gov/judges/cji/8-Colloquies/1MCTOC.shtml; People v Slade, 180 AD3d 1073,1074 [2020]; People v Batista, 167AD3d 69, 83 [2018, Scheinkman, P.J., concurring]; see People v Bisono, 36 NY3d 1013, 1026 [2020, Garcia, J.,dissenting in part and concurring in part]).