[*1]
People v Henry
2022 NY Slip Op 50265(U) [74 Misc 3d 1230(A)]
Decided on April 11, 2022
Supreme Court, Richmond County
Grey, J.
This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports.


Decided on April 11, 2022
Supreme Court, Richmond County


The People of theState of New York, Plaintiff,

against

Andrew Henry, Defendant.




Indictment No. 70277-21



For the Defendant:
Yan Katsnelson, Esq
60 Bay Street, 7th Floor
Staten Island, NY 10301

For the People:
Michael E. McMahon
District Attorney, Richmond County
26 Central Avenue
Staten Island, NY 10301
By: A.D.A. Travis Atkinson


Lisa Grey, J.

The Court commenced a Dunaway/Mapp/Huntley hearing on February 24, 2022. Inpreparation for this hearing, the People discovered the existence of additional NYPD body-worncamera footage that had not been disclosed to defense. Defendant filed a motion to invalidate thePeople's certificate of compliance pursuant to CPL 245.50[1], and for defendant's release fromcustody pursuant to CPL 30.30[2].



STATEMENT OF FACTS

Defendant was arrested on various weapons possession offenses and related charges on July26, 2021. Defendant was arraigned in Richmond County Criminal Court on July 27, 2021.Defendant was subsequently indicted for Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the Second Degree(PL 265.03[3]) and related offenses and arraigned in Supreme Court on August 18, 2021.

The People filed a certificate of compliance and a certificate of trial readiness on October 19,2021. The certificate of compliance certifies that, after "exercising due diligence and makingreasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence of discoverable material and information subject todiscovery under CPL 245.20[l], the People have disclosed and made available to defendant allknown material and information that is subject to discovery, except those items and informationthat are the subject of an order pursuant to CPL 245.70." The certificate of trial readiness [*2]"affirms, under penalty of perjury, that the People are ready fortrial" in this matter.

The certificate of compliance was filed with an attached index of disclosures, which lists thediscoverable items turned over to defendant. Contained within the index of disclosures is a list ofbody-worn cameras from police officers involved in defendant's arrest. Included among thesewas a body-worn camera video from Sergeant Tiernan.

On November 9, 2021, a motion schedule was set by this Court. An omnibus motion wasfiled by defendant on December 8, 2021, and the People filed a response to defendant's motionon December 21, 2021. The matter was adjourned for decision on January 20, 2022. On that date,a decision was issued, and this Court adjourned the case for Dunaway/Mapp/Huntleyhearings to be held on February 24, 2022.

On February 24, 2022, the People announced ready for hearings, with the caveat that theyhad discovered the existence of additional discoverable material, which was provided todefendant that day. In preparation for the hearing, the People interviewed Sergeant Tiernan, andinquired as to why his body-worn camera was only activated for his interactions with thedefendant, and not when he searched the defendant's house. Sgt. Tiernan responded that he infact did activate his body-worn camera upon entering the house to protect himself and fellowofficers from any accusation of theft or property damage. It was at this point that the Peoplerealized they were only in possession of one video from Sgt. Tiernan, when two videosexisted.

The Court commenced the hearing on February 24, 2022, with testimony from Police OfficerIsmael Diaz. After taking Officer Diaz's testimony, the Court adjourned the hearing to givedefendant an opportunity to review the belatedly disclosed body-worn camera before taking anytestimony from Sgt. Tiernan. The Court adjourned this matter to April 11, 2022. In the interim,defendant filed a motion seeking 1.) invalidation of the People's certificate of compliance underCPL 245.50[1], 2.) release of the defendant from custody pursuant to CPL 30.30[2][a], and 3.)granting such other relief as the Court may deem proper. The People filed opposition.

Defendant argues, in sum and substance, that the certificate of compliance must beinvalidated because of the categorical language of CPL 245.50[1], which states that thecertificate of compliance "must state that all known material and information subject to discoveryhas been disclosed and made available, except for items that are lost or destroyed as provided byCPL 245.80[1][b]." Defendant further claims that good faith and due diligence on the part of theprosecution is irrelevant to this analysis. Defendant further asks the Court to impose sanctionspursuant to CPL 245.55 and 245.80. Finally, defendant asserts that more than 90 days haveelapsed before the filing of a valid statement of readiness, and thus defendant should be releasedfrom custody pursuant to CPL 30.30[2].

The People argue that they acted in good faith and exercised due diligence. The Peoplefurther state that at the time of defendant's arrest, and prior to any arraignment, the arrestingofficer, Police Officer Diaz, provided the Richmond County District Attorney's Office (RCDA)with a form known as a "Body Worn Camera Checklist" This form lists all officers involved inan arrest, and whether they were equipped with body-worn camera. A copy of this list wasprovided to the Court as People's Exhibit A. Sgt. Tiernan is listed as a body-worn cameraparticipant. Based on this, the People made a request for all body-worn camera footage andreceived said footage from the NYPD. Sgt. Tiernan's video was uploaded to the RCDA electroniccase and evidence management system at approximately 10:54 a.m. on July 28, 2021. Sometimeafter this, an RCDA technician noted that he would be requesting "any outstanding video +interrogation videos." Body-worn camera videos, including Sgt. Tiernan's video, were [*3]shared with defendant on August 17, 2021. The People furtherallege that at the time of the filing of their certificate of compliance, they had performed their duediligence, as they had no reason to know that a subsequent video existed, and only realized suchin preparation for the pre-trial hearings.



CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

CPL 30.30[1][a] requires the People to be ready for trial within six months of thecommencement of a criminal action in which a felony is charged. CPL 30.30 [2] provides that adefendant, committed to custody, must be released on bail or his own recognizance if the Peopleare not ready for trial in a felony criminal action with 90 days.

Pursuant to the recent amendments to the Criminal Procedure Law, CPL 30.30[5] providesthat any statement of trial readiness must be accompanied or preceded by a certification of goodfaith compliance with the disclosure requirements of CPL 245.20. When the prosecution hasprovided the discovery required by CPL 245.20[1], it shall serve upon defendant and file with theCourt a certificate of compliance (CPL 245.50[1]).

The CPL clearly contemplated situations where not every single item of discovery would beturned over prior to the filing of a certificate of compliance, specifically by enacting CPL 245.60,245.55, and CPL 245.80. CPL 245.60 provides that in the event the prosecution "subsequentlylearns of additional material . . . which it would have been under a duty to disclose . . . it shallexpeditiously notify the other party and disclose the additional material and information asrequired for initial discovery under this article." CPL 245.55 states that "no adverse consequenceto the prosecution or the prosecutor shall result from the filing of a certificate of compliance ingood faith and reasonable under the circumstances; but the court may grant a remedy or sanctionfor a discovery violation as provided in section 245.80." 245.80[1][a] provides that "whenmaterial or information is discoverable under this article but is disclosed belatedly, the court shallimpose an appropriate remedy or sanction if the party entitled to disclosure shows that it wasprejudiced."

The only purpose of a certificate of compliance is to serve as a "necessary prerequisite to avalid statement of readiness" for CPL 30.30 purposes. Thus, the only legal effect of declaring acertificate of compliance to be invalid would be a finding that the People's statement of trialreadiness would be illusory (People v.Barnett, 68 Misc 3d 1000 [NY County Supreme Ct. 2020]; People v. Benitez, 73 Misc 3d 804[NY County Supreme Ct, 2021]).

This Court notes that "good faith, due diligence, and reasonableness under the circumstancesare the touchstones by which a certificate of compliance must be evaluated" See People v.Marin, 2022 NY Misc. LEXIS 858 [Bronx Co. Crim. Ct. 2022]; People v. Perez, 73 Misc 3d 171,177 [Queens Co. Sup. Ct. 2021]. The People have outlined the reasonable steps taken to obtaindiscovery in this case (Marin, supra). The People received a checklist from the NYPDlisting all body-worn camera participants involved in defendant's arrest; requested videos fromall members of service listed; and had an RCDA technician follow up to request "any outstandingvideo" which was met with negative results. The fact that the People had a video in theirpossession from Sgt. Tiernan, and disclosed such video, led them to believe that they werecompliant with their discovery obligations. Sgt. Tiernan was not the arresting officer, and not anecessary Grand Jury witness. As such, the only time the People spoke with him, and reasonablyso, was during preparations for pre-trial hearings.

The recently discovered body-worn camera video of Sgt. Tiernan is indisputablydiscoverable. The People indicated that they turned this video over to defendant once theylearned of its existence and obtained it, on February 24, 2022. However, this is not a situation[*4]where the People knew this piece of discovery wasoutstanding and nonetheless filed a certificate of compliance regardless (People v. Aquino, 72 Misc 3d 518[Kings Co. Sup. Ct. 2021]). The "mere fact that the People have committed a discovery violationdoes not render the statement of readiness illusory, particularly when the People are otherwiseactually ready to try the case" (People v. Deas, 2022 NY Misc. LEXIS 927 [WestchesterCo. Sup. Ct. 2022]).

Further, defendant has not shown that he has been prejudiced by the People's belateddisclosure of the body-worn camera video. In fact, this Court adjourned the pre-trial hearings togive defendant time to review the late disclosure before his cross-examination of Sgt.Tiernan.

As such, defendant's motion to invalidate the People's certificate of compliance isdenied.

Defendant's motion for release pursuant to CPL 30.30[2][a] is denied as moot.

The Court will entertain additional motions only to the extent that such motions are basedupon new and formerly unavailable information.


Dated: April 11, 2022
Staten Island, New York
Hon. Lisa Grey
Justice ofthe Supreme Court




NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.