Matter of Coyle v Midwest Steel
2011 NY Slip Op 09228 [90 AD3d 1358]
December 22, 2011
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 1, 2012


In the Matter of the Claim of John Coyle,Appellant,
v
Midwest Steel et al., Respondents. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent.

—[*1]ILaw Office of Joseph Romano, New York City (Mark Du of counsel), for appellant.

Jones, Jones, L.L.C., New York City (Lauren Camo of counsel), for Midwest Steel,respondent.

Malone Jr., J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed June 4,2010, which ruled that claimant had involuntarily retired, but that subsequent lost earnings werenot causally related to claimant's work-related disability.

Claimant, an ironworker, sustained a work-related injury to his left knee in 1998 and wasawarded workers' compensation benefits. Ultimately, claimant underwent multiple knee and hipreplacement surgeries, and consequential compensable injuries to his back and right hip wereestablished. Claimant returned to light-duty work as a shop steward in June 2009, but that jobwas eliminated in August 2009. At that time, claimant was offered a full-duty position as anironworker, but he felt that he could not accept the position due to his medical restrictions, so heretired. The payment of workers' compensation benefits continued to claimant until December2009, when the employer's workers' compensation carrier raised the issue of claimant's voluntaryremoval from the labor market. In decisions filed in December 2009 and February 2010, aWorkers' Compensation Law Judge determined that claimant had involuntarily retired due to acausally related disability and was entitled to continued benefits. On review, the Workers'Compensation Board affirmed the December 2009 decision, but reversed the February 2010[*2]decision, denying further benefits due to claimant's failure tomaintain a sufficient attachment to the labor market subsequent to December 12, 2009. Claimantnow appeals.[FN*]

We reverse. "[A] retirement is an involuntary withdrawal if the claimant's disability causedor contributed to the decision to retire" (Matter of Pittman v ABM Indus., Inc., 24 AD3d 1056, 1057[2005]; accord Matter of Funke vEastern Suffolk BOCES, 80 AD3d 971, 972 [2011]). Here, the Board credited themedical evidence and claimant's testimony that he retired due to his causally related disability.Accordingly, we conclude that the Board's finding that claimant's retirement in August 2009 wasinvoluntary is supported by substantial evidence (see Matter of Funke v Eastern SuffolkBOCES, 80 AD3d at 972; Matter ofBryant v New York City Tr. Auth., 31 AD3d 936, 937-938 [2006]).

The Board's finding that claimant's retirement was involuntary "gave rise to an inference thathis reduced earning capacity continued after retirement" (Matter of Tipping v National Surface Cleaning Mgt., Inc., 29 AD3d1200, 1201 [2006]; see Matter ofLeeber v LILCO, 29 AD3d 1198, 1199 [2006]). That inference is removed only by"direct and positive proof that something other than the disability was the sole cause of claimant'sreduced earning capacity after retirement" (Matter of Pittman v ABM Indus., Inc., 24AD3d at 1058). Further, "[p]roof that the claimant has not sought work postretirement, by itself,does not defeat the inference or shift the burden to [the] claimant to show that the disability was acause of the reduction" (Matter of Leeber v LILCO, 29 AD3d at 1199; accord Matterof Bryant v New York City Tr. Auth., 31 AD3d at 938). Rather, the employer or workers'compensation carrier "must demonstrate that something other than the disability was the solecause of claimant's reduced earning capacity after retirement, such as age, economic conditionsor other factors unrelated to the disability" (Matter of Pepe v City & Suburban, 29 AD3d 1184, 1185 [2006][internal quotation marks and citations omitted]).

Here, the Board relied solely on the fact that claimant failed to actively search foremployment or avail himself of any employment services after retirement in denying him furtherbenefits. Given the lack of any proof by the employer that something other than claimant'sdisability was the sole cause of his reduced earnings after retirement, we conclude that theBoard's determination denying claimant further benefits is not supported by substantial evidenceand must be reversed (see Matter of Funke v Eastern Suffolk BOCES, 80 AD3d at 973;Matter of Bryant v New York City Tr. Auth., 31 AD3d at 938; Matter of Pittman vABM Indus., Inc., 24 AD3d at 1058).

Peters, J.P., Stein, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is reversed, withcosts, and matter remitted to the Workers' Compensation Board for further proceedings notinconsistent with this Court's decision.

Footnotes


Footnote *: Claimant's pro se notice ofappeal refers to an incorrect date of filing of the Board's decision. Because there has been noclaim of prejudice, we will disregard the error and address the merits of claimant's appeal(see CPLR 5520 [c]).


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.