O'Neill v Pinkowski
2012 NY Slip Op 00887 [92 AD3d 1063]
February 9, 2012
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 28, 2012


Ronald O'Neill et al., Respondents, v Daniel L. Pinkowski et al.,Appellants.

—[*1]Viscardi, Howe & Rudgers, L.L.P., Ticonderoga (Carrie McLoughlin Noll of Breedlove& Noll, L.L.P. of counsel, Clifton Park), for appellants.

Wilson, Elser, Moskowitz, Edelman & Dicker, L.L.P., White Plains (Donald G. Derrico ofcounsel), for respondents.

Egan Jr., J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Muller, J.), entered September 17,2010 in Essex County, which, among other things, granted plaintiffs' motion for summaryjudgment declaring that defendants' real property is subject to certain covenants and restrictionsand permanently enjoining defendants' operation of a bed and breakfast thereon.

Outlet Drive is a residential street located in the Town of Ticonderoga, Essex County, andthe parties are neighboring landowners thereon.[FN1]In 2009, defendants sought and obtained permission from the Town of Ticonderoga PlanningBoard and the Adirondack Park Agency to operate a one-unit bed and breakfast at theirresidence.[FN2]Shortly thereafter, plaintiffs commenced this action seeking a declaration that defendants'proposed use of their property violates certain [*2]covenantspurportedly contained in the parties' various deeds and, further, to permanently enjoin defendantsfrom operating a bed and breakfast at their Outlet Drive residence. Following joinder of issue,plaintiffs moved for summary judgment, and defendants cross-moved to dismiss the complaintor, in the alternative, for summary judgment. Supreme Court granted plaintiffs' motion anddenied defendants' cross motion, prompting this appeal.

Plaintiffs seek enforcement of the following covenants: "(2) The premises shall be usedsolely and exclusively for single-family private residential purposes . . . (6) Nobusiness or occupation or any nuisance whatever . . . shall be erected, carried on,maintained or permitted on the premises at any time nor shall anything be done thereon whichmay be or become an annoyance or nuisance to the neighborhood." In order to establish that thecovenants alleged run with the land,[FN3]plaintiffs needed to demonstrate that "(1) the grantor and grantee intended the covenant to runwith the land, (2) there is privity of estate between the parties to the current dispute, and (3) thecovenant touches and concerns the land" (Johnson v Nisbet, 68 AD3d 1333, 1336 [2009] [internal quotationmarks and citation omitted], lv denied 14 NY3d 704 [2010]; see Harrison v Westview Partners,LLC, 79 AD3d 1198, 1200 [2010]; Sync Realty Group, Inc. v Rotterdam Ventures, Inc., 63 AD3d1429, 1431 [2009]; Village ofPhiladelphia v FortisUS Energy Corp., 48 AD3d 1193, 1194-1195 [2008]). This theyfailed to do.

Although the record strongly suggests that all parties derived their respective parcels from acommon grantor—namely, Leo Gayzur—plaintiffs neglected to tender a completechain of title for plaintiffs Donald G. Derrico and Christie L. Derrico, thereby precluding us frommaking this determination as a matter of law. Further, even assuming, for the sake of argument,that all parties indeed derived their parcels from a common grantor, thereby satisfying the"vertical privity" requirement (see Malley v Hanna, 65 NY2d 289, 291-292 [1985]), andthat the asserted covenants, in turn, touch and concern the land, i.e., "directly affect[ ] the uses towhich the land may be put and substantially affect[ ] its value" (Johnson v Nisbet, 68AD3d at 1336 [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]), the record before us containsinsufficient evidence to permit a finding that "the grantor and grantees intended that thecovenants would run with the land" (Harrison v Westview Partners, LLC, 79 AD3d at1201). Each of the subject deeds contains only a generic recitation of the covenants at issue;noticeably absent therefrom is any "language immediately preceding the covenant languagewhich expresses intent that the promise be binding on the sellers as well as their heirs andassigns" (id.). Moreover, not all of the deeds contained in the record consistently recitethe relevant covenants,[FN4]thereby raising an [*3]additional question of fact as to theunderlying intent of the grantors/grantees. Thus, plaintiffs are not entitled to summary judgment,and Supreme Court's order must be modified accordingly.[FN5]

The additional arguments advanced by defendants do not warrant extended discussion. Evenassuming that the affirmation submitted by Donald Derrico, an attorney and a named partyherein, was not based upon personal knowledge (compare DiBartolomeo v St. Peter's Hosp. of the City of Albany, 73AD3d 1326, 1326-1327 [2010]; Chiarini v County of Ulster, 9 AD3d 769, 770 [2004]), the variousdeeds tendered by plaintiffs in support of their motion for summary judgment constitute proof inadmissible form. Further, we agree with Supreme Court that the doctrine of unclean hands isinapplicable here, as plaintiffs' causes of action are not "founded in illegality orimmorality" (Seagirt Realty Corp. v Chazanof, 13 NY2d 282, 285 [1963]). Finally, inlight of the numerous questions of fact posed by the record, defendants' cross motion for, amongother things, summary judgment also was properly denied. Defendants' remaining contentions, tothe extent not specifically addressed, have been examined and found to be lacking in merit.

Spain, J.P., Malone Jr. and Stein, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is modified, on the law,without costs, by reversing so much thereof as granted plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment,declared the subject covenants to be valid, binding and enforceable and granted a permanentinjunction enjoining defendants from operating a bed and breakfast on their property; said motionand plaintiffs' request for declaratory relief and a permanent injunction denied; and, as somodified, affirmed.

Footnotes


Footnote 1: Plaintiffs Frank Richardson andCarol Richardson own 76 Outlet Drive, plaintiff Ronald O'Neill owns both 77 Outlet Drive and80 Outlet Drive, plaintiffs Donald G. Derrico and Christie L. Derrico own 83 Outlet Drive anddefendants own 67 Outlet Drive.

Footnote 2: Defendants dispute thecharacterization of their proposal as a bed and breakfast and, in any event, now contend that theyare merely looking to rent out the unit in question on a seasonal basis.

Footnote 3: The cited covenants appear inthe deeds conveying the relevant parcels to both the Richardsons and the Derricos, as well as thedeed conveying 80 Outlet Drive to O'Neill. The covenants also appear in the deed conveying thepertinent parcel to defendants, although the language contained in covenant No. 2 refers to"residence purposes" instead of "residential purposes." As for the conveyance of 77 Outlet Driveto O'Neill, although the record contains a complete chain of title for this parcel, none of theunderlying deeds indicates whether said conveyances are subject to the aforementionedcovenants.

Footnote 4: As noted previously, the deedsin O'Neill's chain of title for 77 Outlet Drive contain no reference to the covenants atall, and we have not been provided with a complete chain of title for the Derricos'property at 83 Outlet Drive. With respect to O'Neill's chain of title for 80 Outlet Drive, althoughcovenant No. 2 consistently appears throughout and may be traced to the original grantor,covenant No. 6 first appears in the deed from O'Neill's immediate predecessor in interest. Asimilar situation exists in the Richardsons' chain of title for 76 Outlet Drive.

Footnote 5: It necessarily follows thatSupreme Court's related declaration that the subject covenants are "valid, binding andenforceable," together with its grant of a permanent injunction enjoining defendants fromoperating a bed and breakfast on their property, also must be reversed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.