| Matter of Hinton v Fischer |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 05492 [108 AD3d 1000] |
| July 25, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Leonard Hinton, Petitioner, v BrianFischer, as Commissioner of Corrections and Community Supervision,Respondent. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Peter H. Schiff of counsel), forrespondent.
Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Franklin County) to review a determination of respondentwhich found petitioner guilty of violating certain prison disciplinary rules.
Petitioner, a prison inmate, was charged in a misbehavior report with violentconduct, committing an unhygienic act, harassment, threats and a mess hall violation.According to the report, after a correction officer placed a cup of coffee on petitioner's"feed up hatch," petitioner intentionally used his breakfast tray to push the coffee off thehatch so that it spilled onto the officer and the floor. Following a tier III disciplinaryhearing, petitioner was found guilty of all charges. The determination was affirmed onadministrative review, prompting the commencement of this CPLR article 78 proceeding.
Initially, respondent concedes, and we agree, that substantial evidence does notsupport that part of the determination finding petitioner guilty of harassment, threats anda mess hall violation. The determination with respect to these charges must therefore beannulled but, as petitioner has served the penalty and there was no loss of good time, thematter need not be remitted for a redetermination of the penalty (see Matter of Franza vVenettozzi, 98 AD3d 782, 783 [2012]). Further, despite respondent's claim thatpetitioner abandoned all challenges to the [*2]charges ofviolent conduct and committing an unhygienic act,[FN*]our review of petitioner's submissions to this Court confirms that he is pursuing hiscontention that the misbehavior report, including the charges of violent conduct andcommitting an unhygienic act, was written in retaliation for numerous harassmentgrievances that he previously filed against the author of the misbehavior report.
In that regard, petitioner maintains that the Hearing Officer improperly denied hisright to call witnesses at the hearing. Petitioner sought to call an inmate who did notwitness the incident but purportedly heard a remark from a correction officer that "wefinally got him." Contrary to petitioner's claim, this alleged remark does not establish thatthe misbehavior report was unfounded. Rather, it merely suggests that correction officershad been trying to catch him violating prison rules and had finally succeeded.Accordingly, there was no error in denying the witness as irrelevant (see Matter of Dallio v Fischer,68 AD3d 1380, 1380 [2009]; Matter of Washington v Napoli, 61 AD3d 1243, 1243[2009], lv denied 13 NY3d 704 [2009]; compare Matter of H'Shaka v Fischer, 100 AD3d 1056,1057 [2012]).
Petitioner also sought to call an investigator from the Inspector General's office.Although petitioner now claims that the proposed witness investigated this incident, atthe hearing he indicated only that the proposed witness had investigated his previouslyfiled complaints of harassment and official misconduct. The Hearing Officer acceptedthe fact that petitioner had previously complained of harassment, and there is noindication that the proposed witness ever investigated the incident that is the subject ofthe misbehavior report. Accordingly, the proposed witness had no relevant testimonyregarding this incident, and we find no error in the Hearing Officer's refusal to call him(see Matter of Tafari vRock, 96 AD3d 1321, 1321 [2012], lv denied 19 NY3d 810 [2012]; Matter of Tafari v Fischer, 93AD3d 1054, 1054-1055 [2012], lv dismissed 19 NY3d 1007 [2012]; compare Matter of Diaz vFischer, 70 AD3d 1082, 1082-1083 [2010]). Similarly, we are unpersuaded bypetitioner's claim that he was denied the right to produce evidence of a grievance he hadfiled months prior to the incident, inasmuch as the Hearing Officer accepted the fact thatpetitioner had previously filed complaints (see Matter of Washington v Napoli,61 AD3d at 1243).
Peters, P.J., Rose, Stein and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determinationis modified, without costs, by annulling so much thereof as found petitioner guilty ofharassment, threats and a mess hall violation; petition granted to that extent andrespondent is directed to expunge all references thereto from petitioner's institutionalrecord; and, as so modified, confirmed.
Footnote *: Notably, inasmuch aspetitioner does not pursue a substantial evidence challenge in his brief regarding theviolent conduct and unhygienic act charges charges, we deem any claims in that regard asto those charges to be abandoned (see Matter of Lamage v Bezio, 74 AD3d 1676, 1676[2010]).