Matter of Mathis (Commissioner of Labor)
2013 NY Slip Op 07104 [110 AD3d 1412]
October 31, 2013
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 27, 2013


In the Matter of the Claim of Valerie A. Mathis, Appellant.Commissioner of Labor, Respondent.

—[*1]Pro Bono Appeals Program, Albany (Michael J. Hutter of counsel), forappellant.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Dawn A. Foshee ofcounsel), for respondent.

Peters, P.J. Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board,filed February 13, 2012, which, among other things, charged claimant with a recoverableoverpayment of unemployment insurance benefits upon finding that she made willfulmisrepresentations to obtain benefits.

Claimant was employed as a children's services supervisor with the Ulster CountyDepartment of Social Services (hereinafter the employer). In June 2007, she was arrestedand charged with felony and misdemeanor counts of criminal possession of a controlledsubstance after heroin was found in the car she was driving. Two days later, claimant wassuspended without pay from her employment pending the resolution of the criminalcharges. She applied for unemployment insurance benefits, informing a Department ofLabor investigator that she was on disciplinary suspension due to her arrest and that shewas "not guilty of any wrongdoing in connection with the arrest." She thereafter beganreceiving benefits. Claimant was subsequently convicted of two misdemeanor counts ofcriminal possession of a controlled substance in the seventh degree arising out of thearrest. In June 2009, the employer terminated her employment.

Following claimant's termination, an Administrative Law Judge (hereinafter ALJ)disqualified her from receiving unemployment insurance benefits on the ground that shehad been separated from employment due to misconduct. This determination was lateraffirmed by the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board. Thereafter, the Commissionerof Labor issued [*2]determinations charging claimantwith a recoverable overpayment of benefits in the aggregate amount of $31,935 andreduced claimant's right to receive future benefits by 16 effective days on the basis thatshe had made willful misrepresentations to obtain benefits. Following a hearing, the ALJsustained the Commissioner's determinations. The Board affirmed the ALJ's decision,prompting this appeal.

Substantial evidence supports the Board's finding that claimant's affirmativestatement to the Department's investigator that she was "not guilty of any wrongdoing inconnection with [her] arrest" was a willful misrepresentation made in order to obtainbenefits (see Matter of Sterne[Commissioner of Labor], 104 AD3d 984, 984-985 [2013], lv denied— NY3d —, 2013 NY Slip Op 88917 [2013]; Matter of Barbera [Commissionerof Labor], 28 AD3d 973, 974-975 [2006]). In so concluding, we rejectclaimant's assertion that this statement constituted an exercise of her constitutional rightagainst self-incrimination for which she could not be penalized by the Board. Whileclaimant unquestionably had the right to refuse to respond to any inquiries related to herpossible guilt in connection with her arrest and the pending criminal charges, "neither thetext nor the spirit of the Fifth Amendment confers a privilege to lie" (Brogan vUnited States, 522 US 398, 404 [1998]; see United States v Wong, 431 US174, 178-179 [1977]; Bryson v United States, 396 US 64, 72 [1969]). By herresponse to the investigator's inquiry as to whether she was, in fact, guilty of the crimesshe was charged with, claimant "took a course that the Fifth Amendment gave [her] noprivilege to take" (United States v Wong, 431 US at 179 [internal quotationmarks and citation omitted]),[FN*]and the jury's verdict convicting her of knowingly possessing heroin at the time of herarrest conclusively established the falsity of her statement denying any wrongdoing(see generally S.T. Grand, Inc. v City of New York, 32 NY2d 300, 304-305[1973]; cf. Matter of Dougall vRhea, 106 AD3d 434, 434 [2013]). Because the Board's conclusion thatclaimant made a willful misrepresentation is supported by substantial evidence (see Matter of Cummings[Commissioner of Labor], 69 AD3d 1088, 1089 [2010]; compare Matter ofBenjamin [Hartnett], 175 AD2d 936, 937 [1991]), it must be affirmed, even if theremay be substantial evidence supporting the contrary conclusion (see Matter of Guynup [County ofClinton—Commissioner of Labor], 106 AD3d 1357, 1358-1359 [2013]).

Stein, McCarthy and Spain, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is affirmed,without costs.[*3]

Footnotes


Footnote *: Claimant both informedthe investigator that she had pleaded "not guilty" to the charges against her and alsocategorically denied any wrongdoing in connection with the arrest. Thus, we areunpersuaded by claimant's assertion that the statement at issue was simply a recitation ofher status under the law.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.