| Matter of Guynup (County of Clinton—Commissioner ofLabor) |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 03734 [106 AD3d 1357] |
| May 23, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Terry L. Guynup, Respondent.County of Clinton, Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent. |
—[*1] Steven A. Crain, Civil Service Employees Association, Inc., Albany, for Terry L.Guynup, respondent.
Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filedNovember 9, 2011, which ruled that claimant was entitled to receive unemploymentinsurance benefits.
In October 2008, claimant, a lieutenant with the Clinton County Sheriff'sDepartment, was charged under Civil Service Law § 75 with misconduct,incompetence and insubordination. The misconduct charge arose out of an incident inwhich claimant was served with an order of protection that had been obtained on an exparte basis by his wife, from whom he was estranged. Two superior officers served theorder of protection upon claimant, which required that he surrender all firearms.Claimant became upset during this encounter, verbally protested the surrender of hisfirearms and used profanity toward the officers. Nevertheless, he eventually compliedwith the terms of the order of protection. Claimant was ultimately found guilty ofincompetence and insubordination, and he was terminated from his position as a result.He commenced a CPLR article 78 proceeding challenging his termination, which waslater upheld by this Court (Matter of Guynup v County of Clinton, 90 AD3d 1390[2011]).
Following his separation from employment, claimant applied for unemploymentinsurance benefits. The Department of Labor initially disqualified him from receivingbenefits on the ground that he lost his employment through misconduct. AnAdministrative Law Judge, however, concluded differently after a hearing and awardedclaimant benefits. The [*2]Unemployment InsuranceAppeal Board upheld this decision and claimant's former employer now appeals.
Given that claimant had a full and fair opportunity to litigate the issue of misconductat the Civil Service Law § 75 hearing, the Board properly accorded collateralestoppel effect to the factual findings of the Hearing Officer (see Matter of Cheeseboro[Commissioner of Labor], 84 AD3d 1635, 1636 [2011]; Matter of Morales [Commissionerof Labor], 70 AD3d 1271, 1272 [2010], lv denied 14 NY3d 711[2010]). It was, however, incumbent upon the Board to draw its own conclusion as towhether such factual findings amounted to misconduct disqualifying claimant fromreceiving unemployment insurance benefits (see Matter of Morales, 70 AD3d at1272; Matter of Sona[Commissioner of Labor], 13 AD3d 799, 799-800 [2004]). Significantly, "[t]hesame conduct that leads to a claimant being discharged for cause may not necessarily riseto the level of misconduct for unemployment insurance purposes" (Matter of Wright [City ofSyracuse—Commissioner of Labor], 101 AD3d 1198, 1199 [2012]; see Matter of Jackson [County ofNassau Civ. Serv. Commn.—Commissioner of Labor], 97 AD3d 889,890 [2012]). The Board's decision in this regard will not be disturbed if supported bysubstantial evidence (see Matter of Wright [City of Syracuse—Commissionerof Labor], 101 AD3d at 1199; Matter of Jackson [County of Nassau Civil Serv.Commn.—Commissioner of Labor], 97 AD3d at 890).
Here, while the Board found that claimant used vulgar and intemperate languagetoward his superior officers, it concluded that, given the context of his conduct, it wasnot so egregious as to disqualify him from receiving benefits. The Board relied onevidence of claimant's marital problems and his lack of knowledge of the order ofprotection prior to being served with it. Furthermore, the superior officers testified thatthey were not directly threatened by claimant. There was also evidence that, despite hisoutburst, claimant fully complied with the terms of the order of protection by timelysurrendering his firearms. In view of the foregoing, substantial evidence supports theBoard's finding that claimant did not engage in disqualifying misconduct, despite theexistence of substantial evidence supporting the contrary conclusion.
Rose, J.P., Lahtinen, Spain and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision isaffirmed, without costs.