| Matter of Luongo v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State ofN.Y. |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 03714 [117 AD3d 1286] |
| May 22, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Jessie Luongo, Petitioner, v TaxAppeals Tribunal of the State of New York et al.,Respondents. |
Roberts & Holland, LLP, New York City (Ellen S. Brody of counsel), forpetitioner.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Kathleen M. Arnold of counsel),for Commissioner of Taxation and Finance of the State of New York, respondent.
Stein, J.P. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuant toTax Law § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax AppealsTribunal, which, among other things, sustained a sales and use tax assessment imposedunder Tax Law articles 28 and 29.
Petitioner was the sole shareholder of Fifth Avenue Restaurant AcquisitionCorporation, which operated Tuscan Square Restaurant and Marketplace. Tuscan Squarewas originally owned and operated by Toscorp[FN1]
—the parent company of Tuscan Square and other restaurants—throughToscorp's subsidiary, Rock 51 PRTN Corporation, of which petitioner's husband,Giuseppe Luongo, was the chief executive officer. After Toscorp and Rock 51 filedpetitions for bankruptcy, Fifth Avenue was formed for the purpose of acquiring theassets of Rock 51. On the advice of counsel, petitioner agreed to take ownership of FifthAvenue in an attempt to preserve the family's assets, but immediately named Luongo itssole director. Luongo, in turn, named himself its president, treasurer and secretary and,thereafter, ran the day-to-day operations of the restaurant.
[*2] Fifth Avenue eventually filed for bankruptcy and, aspart of that process, the Department of Taxation and Finance conducted a sales tax fieldaudit of its books and records for the period March 1, 2004 though November 30, 2006.That audit revealed that Fifth Avenue had underreported gross sales on its sales taxreturns and owed sales and use taxes in excess of $230,000, plus applicable penalties andinterest.[FN2]
Consequently, the Department issued several notices of determination to petitioner,notifying her—as a "Responsible Person"—of the amount owed.[FN3]
After two conciliation conferences, the notices of determination were sustained.
Petitioner subsequently filed petitions with the Division of Tax Appeals, seeking aredetermination of the deficiency on the ground that petitioner was not responsible forFifth Avenue's tax liabilities. A hearing was held before an Administrative Law Judge,who ultimately rejected petitioner's contention that she was not a person required tocollect tax and denied the petitions. Petitioner filed a notice of exception with respondentTax Appeals Tribunal, which affirmed the Administrative Law Judge's determination.This CPLR article 78 proceeding ensued.
We confirm. Tax Law § 1133 (a) imposes personal liability on anyperson who is responsible for collecting tax under Tax Law article 28 (see Matter of Coppola v TaxAppeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 37 AD3d 901, 902 [2007]). A person required tocollect tax includes "any officer, director or employee of a corporation . . .who . . . is under a duty to act for such corporation . . . incomplying with any requirement of [Tax Law article 28]" (Tax Law § 1131[1]). Moreover, a person who is not an officer, director or employee of a corporation isrequired to collect tax if he or she "possessed all the indicia of control that would imposeliability upon an officer, director or employee of a corporation" (Matter of Ianniello vNew York Tax Appeals Trib., 209 AD2d 740, 741 [1994]). Whether a person has aduty to act for a corporation and is responsible for collecting sales tax is a factualdetermination to be made on a case-by-case basis (see Matter of Coppola v TaxAppeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 37 AD3d at 903; Matter of Cohen v State TaxCommn., 128 AD2d 1022, 1023 [1987]; 20 NYCRR 526.11 [b] [1], [2]). Suchdetermination turns on a variety of factors, including the status of a stockholder, theauthority to hire and fire employees and responsibility for the corporation's management(see Matter of Cohen v State Tax Commn., 128 AD2d at 1023; 20 NYCRR526.11 [b] [2]). In this regard, an important consideration is "petitioner's authority andresponsibility to exercise control over the corporation, not his [or her] actual assertion ofsuch authority" (Matter of Coppola v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 37AD3d at 903; accord Matter ofIppolito v Commissioner of N.Y. State Dept. of Taxation & Fin., 116 AD3d1176, 1177 [2014]; see Matter of Cohen v State Tax Commn., 128 AD2d at1023).
Here, it is undisputed that Luongo, not petitioner, controlled the day-to-dayoperations of Fifth Avenue. Petitioner did not sign checks, hire or fire employees, orassist in preparing tax returns. While petitioner's status as a shareholder, alone, may notbe sufficient to impose tax collection responsibility on her, petitioner had the authority,in her capacity as the sole shareholder of Fifth Avenue, to appoint the board ofdirectors and officers and, indeed, exercised that authority by appointing her husband asthe sole director. Petitioner also retained the [*3]authorityunder the corporate bylaws to remove her husband from such position. Further,petitioner, along with Luongo, signed an alcoholic beverage retail license application forthe restaurant and, perhaps most notably, petitioner alone signed an applicationfor registration as a sales tax vendor. In such application, petitioner was listed as the soleowner/officer of the corporation and falsely averred that no "responsible officer[ ],director[ ], partner[ ], or employee[ ] owe[s] New York State or local sales and use taxeson [her] behalf, on behalf of another person, or as vendor of property orservices."[FN4]
As also noted by the tribunal, petitioner reaped financial benefits from thecorporation, as Fifth Avenue was created to preserve the family's assets from the Rock 51bankruptcy and to produce income for petitioner and her husband. Under thesecircumstances, the tribunal's determination that petitioner was a responsible person andwas personally liable under Tax Law §§ 1131 (1) and 1133 (a) for theoutstanding sales and use taxes owed by the corporation is "rationally based upon andsupported by substantial evidence," despite the existence of record evidence that wouldsupport a contrary conclusion (Matter of Ippolito v Commissioner of N.Y. State Dept.of Taxation & Fin., 116 AD3d at 1178 [internal quotation marks and citationsomitted]; accord Matter of Inglev Tax Appeals Trib. of the Dept. of Taxation & Fin. of the State of N.Y., 110AD3d 1392, 1393 [2013]; see Matter of Hwang v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State of N.Y.,105 AD3d 1151, 1152 [2013]; Matter of Martin v Commissioner of Taxation& Fin., 162 AD2d 890, 891 [1990]). Therefore, we decline to disturb thatdetermination.
We also reject petitioner's contention that the tribunal erred by sustaining thepenalties imposed upon petitioner for underpayment of taxes. Although respondentCommissioner of Taxation and Finance has the authority to waive penalties, petitionerbears the burden of establishing that the failure to pay tax "was due to reasonable causeand not due to willful neglect" (Tax Law § 1145 [a] [1] [iii]; see Matterof Coppola v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 37 AD3d at 904; Matter ofCook v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 222 AD2d 962, 964 [1995]; Matterof MCI Telecom. Corp. v New York State Tax Appeals Trib., 193 AD2d 978, 979[1993]; 20 NYCRR 536.1 [c]). Here, petitioner's allegation that Fifth Avenueundercollected sales tax due to a computer programing error was unsupported by anydocumentary evidence, and petitioner failed to explain the other tax deficiencies thatwere unrelated to such alleged error. Accordingly, we find substantial evidence in therecord to support the tribunal's determination upholding the penalties and interest.Petitioner's remaining contentions have been considered and found to be withoutmerit.
McCarthy, Rose and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.
Footnote 1:Petitioner was a minorityshareholder of Toscorp.
Footnote 2:The audit also revealedthat Fifth Avenue underreported in other categories of taxes owed relating to capitalpurchases, expense purchases and tips not remitted to employees.
Footnote 3:Luongo was alsoassessed individually.
Footnote 4:By signing theregistration application on her own and failing to list Luongo, the Department was notmade aware that a corporate owner had outstanding tax liabilities in connection with hisformer corporations.