| Matter of Theresa WW. v New York State Off. of Children& Family Servs. |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 08524 [123 AD3d 1174] |
| December 4, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Theresa WW. et al., Petitioners, v NewYork State Office of Children and Family Services,Respondent. |
Scoppetta Seiff Kretz & Abercrombie, New York City (Roland R. Acevedo ofcounsel), for petitioners.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Allyson B. Levine of counsel), forrespondent.
Egan Jr., J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court byorder of the Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination ofrespondent which partially denied petitioners' application to have a report maintained bythe Central Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment amended to be unfounded andsealed.
Petitioner Theresa WW. (hereinafter the foster mother) has been a certified fosterparent for 10 years and her husband, petitioner Walter WW. (hereinafter the fosterfather), has been a certified foster parent for nine years. In August 2011, petitioners hadsix foster children placed in their care, including—insofar as is relevanthere—a six-year-old girl and her nine-year-old brother. In October 2011, a reportwas filed with the Central Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment alleging, amongother things, that the foster mother pulled the arm of the six-year-old girl when the childwas reluctant to exit the foster mother's vehicle. An investigation ensued, during thecourse of which a child protective services caseworker spoke with five of the six fosterchildren residing in petitioners' home. As a result of those interviews, certain of theallegations of maltreatment against petitioners were deemed to be substantiated.Specifically, the allegation of inadequate guardianship against the foster mother wasindicated based upon her conduct in pulling the arm of the six-year-old girl and failing toprovide adequate supervision to all six foster children. Additionally, the allegation ofinadequate guardianship against the foster father was indicated based upon his conduct inslapping the girl's nine-year-old brother on the head on more than oneoccasion.[FN1]
Petitioners thereafter requested that the indicated report against them be amended tobe unfounded. Upon administrative review, that request was denied, and the matterproceeded to a hearing. At the conclusion of that hearing, at which petitioners and theircharacter witnesses were the sole witnesses to appear and testify, respondent foundinsufficient evidence to sustain the finding of inadequate guardianship based upon thefoster mother's failure to properly supervise all six foster children. Respondent did,however, find that the remaining allegations against petitioners were established by a fairpreponderance of the evidence and, hence, denied the balance of the requested relief.Petitioners then commenced this proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to challengerespondent's determination.
Although we find no merit to petitioners' various due process claims, we nonethelessare persuaded that the underlying determination must be annulled. In order to establishmaltreatment, the agency must demonstrate—by a fair preponderance of theevidence—that the child's "physical, mental or emotional condition has beenimpaired or is in imminent danger of becoming impaired as a result of the failure of his[or her caregiver] . . . to exercise a minimum degree of care . . .in providing [him or her] with proper supervision or guardianship" (Matter of Christine Y. vCarrion, 75 AD3d 831, 831 [2010] [internal quotation marks and citationomitted]; see 18 NYCRR 432.1 [b] [1] [ii]; Matter of Cheryl Z. v Carrion, 119 AD3d 1109, 1110[2014]). Upon review, this Court's inquiry is limited to ascertaining whether the agency'sdetermination is supported by substantial evidence, i.e., "whether reasonable minds couldadequately accept the conclusion based on the relevant proof" (Matter of John R. v State of N.Y.Off. of Children & Family Servs., 97 AD3d 958, 959 [2012] [internalquotation marks and citations omitted]; see Matter of Cheryl Z. v Carrion, 119AD3d at 1110).
Here, the evidence against petitioners consisted entirely of the investigation summaryand progress notes, the latter of which were prepared—in relevant part—bythe child protective services caseworker based upon interviews with five of the six fosterchildren, who ranged in age from 6 to 12 years old.[FN2] The authoring caseworker did nottestify. Petitioners denied the allegations of maltreatment and offered into evidence theresults of medical evaluations conducted with respect to each of the foster childrenshortly after the allegations of maltreatment surfaced. Those medical records, in turn,revealed that "[t]he children's exams [were] all normal," that the examining physician had"no independent concerns of maltreatment" and, notably, that the six-year-old girl whopurportedly accused the foster mother of grabbing her by the arm and pulling her from avehicle "denie[d] maltreatment" when questioned by the examining physician outside ofthe presence of the foster mother.
To be sure, an administrative determination may, under appropriate circumstances,"be based entirely upon hearsay evidence" (Matter of Doctor v New York State Off. of Alcoholism &Substance Abuse Servs., 112 AD3d 1020, 1022 [2013]), and there is noquestion that "hearsay is admissible in expungement hearings and, if sufficiently relevantand probative, may constitute substantial evidence to support the underlyingdetermination" (Matter of Ribya BB. v Wing, 243 AD2d 1013, 1014 [1997][internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; accord Matter of Nils TT. v NewYork State Dept. of Social Servs., 251 AD2d 779, 780 [1998], lv denied 92NY2d 810 [1998]; see Matter ofMarkman v Carrion, 120 AD3d 1580, 1581 [2014]). Under the particular factsof this case, however, we do not find the investigation summary and progress notesadmitted into evidence at the hearing to be "sufficiently reliable" (Matter of Doctor vNew York State Off. of Alcoholism & Substance Abuse Servs., 112 AD3d at1022 [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]) to constitute substantial evidenceof maltreatment—especially in view of the six-year-old girl's contradictorystatements in this regard. Accordingly, respondent's determination is annulled.
Lahtinen, J.P., Garry and Devine, JJ., concur.
Lynch, J. (dissenting). I respectfully dissent. The standards governing expungementhearings are correctly stated by the majority. I disagree in that it is my view that theevidence is sufficiently reliable to support the underlying determination. Respondentpresented the Central Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment report that was called inby one caseworker and the progress notes from the ensuing investigation, in whichanother caseworker separately interviewed the six children and other relevant partiesregarding the reported maltreatment. It is significant that five of the six childrencorroborated the arm pulling incident with the six-year-old girl, and three of the childrencorroborated the head slap incident involving her nine-year-old brother. That thesix-year-old denied any mistreatment when examined by a physician at the behest ofpetitioner Theresa WW. (hereinafter the foster mother) the day after the caseworkerinterviews does not diminish the corroborative statements of the other children. Nor isthe absence of any actual physical injury dispositive (compare Matter of Peters vMcCaffrey, 173 AD2d 934, 935 [1991]). Not to be overlooked is that petitionerseach testified and denied using any corporal punishment on the children. In so doing,however, the foster mother attributed the allegations to a vindictive caseworker and,upon being informed by the Administrative Law Judge that the investigation was actuallyperformed by another caseworker, the foster mother responded that that caseworker alsofabricated the story. In an instance, as here, "where there are two conflicting accounts ofevents, it is not within this Court's discretion to weigh conflicting testimony or substituteits own judgment for that of the administrative finder of fact, even if a contrary result isviable" (Matter of Ribya BB. v Wing, 243 AD2d 1013, 1014 [1997]; seeMatter of Kenneth VV. v Wing, 235 AD2d 1007, 1009-1010 [1997]; see alsoMatter of Berenhaus v Ward, 70 NY2d 436, 443-444 [1987]). Given thecaseworker's detailed investigation, juxtaposed against the foster mother's accusatoryexplanation, a reasoned basis exists for the Administrative Law Judge's finding thatneither petitioner was credible. In my view, the determination is supported by substantialevidence and should be confirmed and the petition dismissed (see Matter of Cheryl Z. vCarrion, 119 AD3d 1109, 1111-1112 [2014]).
Adjudged that the determination is annulled, without costs, and petition granted.
Footnote 1:As foster parents,petitioners were prohibited from utilizing corporal punishment as a method ofdisciplining their foster children (see 18 NYCRR 441.9 [c]).
Footnote 2:The remaining fosterchild was three years old at the time of the investigation and did not respond to thecaseworker's attempt to speak with her.