Matter of Duffy v New York State Dept. of Corr. &Community Supervision
2015 NY Slip Op 07891 [132 AD3d 1207]
October 29, 2015
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 9, 2015


[*1]
 In the Matter of John Duffy,Respondent,
v
New York State Department of Corrections and CommunitySupervision et al., Appellants.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Frank Brady of counsel), forappellants.

Cynthia H. Conti-Cook, Legal Aid Society, New York City, for respondent.

Lahtinen, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Mott, J.), enteredOctober 2, 2014 in Columbia County, which granted petitioner's application, in aproceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to, among other things, annul a determination ofrespondent Board of Parole denying petitioner's request for parole release.

In 1982, petitioner was sentenced to a prison term of 20 years to life upon hisconviction of murder in the second degree for killing a 15-year-old boy by repeatedlystabbing him. He was denied parole in August 2013 after his seventh appearance beforerespondent Board of Parole and thereafter commenced this proceeding. Supreme Courtgranted the petition and directed a de novo hearing after determining that the Board hadfailed to obtain and consider the sentencing minutes and accompanyingrecommendations by the sentencing judge when, in fact, such minutes were available.The court further directed the Board to "explicitly address[ ]" the "degree to which [thevictim impact statements] figure in the Board's decision." Respondents appeal.[FN*]

[*2] Inasmuch as the sentencingminutes—previously believed to have been lost—were located after theBoard's decision, directing a de novo hearing for the Board to consider such minutes wasnot error under these unique circumstances (see Matter of Smith v New York State Div. of Parole, 64 AD3d1030, 1031 [2009]; Matterof Lovell v New York State Div. of Parole, 40 AD3d 1166, 1167 [2007]; Matter of Standley v New YorkState Div. of Parole, 34 AD3d 1169, 1170-1171 [2006]). Although thesentencing minutes were available by the time Supreme Court decided the petition anddo not explicitly reference a parole recommendation, the sentencing judge nonethelessimplicitly addressed such issue by discussing in some detail his discomfort with therequired maximum range of the sentence (i.e., life in prison) and then imposing less thanthe maximum on the lower range where he had discretion. Such factors, together with thefailure to timely locate available sentencing minutes and the fact that the Board'sdetermination rested primarily upon the serious nature of the crime (see Matter ofJorge v Hammock, 84 AD2d 362, 364 [1982]), provide a narrow path fordistinguishing this case from those where we have found harmless the Board's failure toconsider the sentencing minutes (see e.g. Matter of Matos v New York State Bd. of Parole, 87AD3d 1193, 1194 [2011]; Matter of Ruiz v New York State Div. of Parole, 70 AD3d1162, 1163 [2010]).

Supreme Court's directive that the Board explicitly address the degree to which thevictim impact statements figured in its decision was improper. Among the many factorsthe Board is required by statute to consider are statements from crime victims or theirrepresentatives if they are deceased or incapacitated (see Executive Law§ 259-i [2] [c] [A]). While the Board's ultimate decision denying parolecannot be wholly conclusory, this does not mean that each statutory factor must bediscussed at length, as it is established that the Board "need not enumerate, give equalweight [to] or explicitly discuss every factor considered" (Matter of Leung v Evans, 120AD3d 1478, 1479 [2014], lv denied 24 NY3d 914 [2015] [internal quotationmarks and citations omitted]; see Matter of King v New York State Div. ofParole, 83 NY2d 788, 791 [1994]; Matter of Hamilton v New York State Div. of Parole, 119AD3d 1268, 1270-1271 [2014]; Matter of Montane v Evans, 116 AD3d 197, 203 [2014],lv granted 23 NY3d 903 [2014], appeal dismissed 24 NY3d 1052 [2014];Matter of Dalton v Evans,84 AD3d 1664, 1664 [2011]; Matter of Abdur-Raheem v New York State Bd. of Parole, 78AD3d 1412, 1413 [2010]). The Board cannot, however, rely on factors outside thescope of the statute in reaching its decision (see Matter of King v New York StateDiv. of Parole, 83 NY2d at 791).

In light of the brutal nature of petitioner's crime and the surrounding circumstances,it is not particularly surprising that the victim's family has remained vigilant and vocal inopposing parole. In doing so, some family members have publicly made certain factualallegations about petitioner—including in a self-published book—whichpetitioner adamantly denies. Moreover, some of the confidential submissions readilyreflect the raw emotions of a close-knit family traumatized by a depraved and senselessmurder. When the Legislature required the Board to consider victims' statements, itundoubtedly realized that these submissions would often be emotional and at times eventouch upon inappropriate matters. Such fact does not require the Board to expresslydisavow in its decision inappropriate matters interjected by victims or to somehowquantify the extent or degree to which it considered appropriate parts of victims'statements while disregarding other parts in its overall analysis of the statutory factors.Here, there is nothing in the Board's decision indicating that it was influenced by, placedweight upon, or relied upon any improper matter, whether in the victim's familystatements or otherwise.

[*3] Peters, P.J.and Lynch, J., concur.

McCarthy, J. (dissenting). I disagree with the majority's conclusion that thesentencing minutes contain a parole recommendation, and therefore, I respectfullydissent.[FN*]Appellate courts should be careful to permit sentencing courts to make a record of their"due consideration [of] . . . the crime charged, the particular circumstancesof the individual before the court and the purpose of a penal sanction, i.e., societalprotection, rehabilitation and deterrence," and should not construe such remarks as parolerecommendations merely because parole determinations require similar considerations(People v Farrar, 52 NY2d 302, 305 [1981]; accord People v Jones, 43 AD3d 1296, 1299 [2007], lvdenied 9 NY3d 991 [2007]; compare Executive Law § 259-i [2][c] [A]). The sentencing minutes here reveal that County Court (Kalinowski, J.) madesubstantive remarks regarding the senselessness of the crime, the difficulty of sentencingpetitioner due to his young age and the constraints that the law placed on the sentence tobe imposed. That court neither mentioned the word parole nor used words to a similareffect to describe a future determination regarding petitioner's release from prison. Thecomments that the court made are attributable to its due consideration of the propersentence for petitioner and, therefore, I cannot conclude that it intended to make a parolerecommendation. Accordingly, I find the failure to consider the sentencing minutes to beharmless (see Matter of Matos vNew York State Bd. of Parole, 87 AD3d 1193, 1194 [2011]; Matter of Motti v Alexander,54 AD3d 1114, 1115 [2008]).

Ordered that the judgment is modified, on the law, without costs, by reversing somuch thereof as directed respondent Board of Parole to explicitly address the degree towhich the statements of the victim's family figured in its decision, and, as so modified,affirmed.

Footnotes


Footnote *:Contrary to petitioner'scontention, Supreme Court's "decision/order" constituted an appealable final judgmentwithin the context of this CPLR article 78 proceeding.

Footnote *:I agree with themajority's conclusion regarding the victim impact statements.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.