Matter of Fischer v Nyack Hosp.
2016 NY Slip Op 04283 [140 AD3d 1264]
June 2, 2016
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 3, 2016


[*1]
 In the Matter of Eva Fischer,Respondent-Petitioner,
v
Nyack Hospital, Appellant-Respondent, et al.,Respondent.

Nixon Peabody LLP, Albany (Jena R. Rotheim of counsel), forappellant-respondent.

O'Connell & Aronowitz, Albany (Caitlin Monjeau of counsel), forrespondent-petitioner.

Lahtinen, J.P. (1) Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Mott, J.), enteredDecember 3, 2014 in Albany County, which denied a motion by respondent NyackHospital to, among other things, convert the CPLR article 78 proceeding into a plenaryaction, and (2) proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by orderof the Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination ofrespondent Nyack Hospital denying petitioner medical privileges at that institution.

Petitioner, a surgeon, had medical privileges at respondent Nyack Hospital that wereset to expire in mid-2012. While her application to renew was pending, Nyack summarilysuspended her in May 2012 after learning that her privileges had recently been suspendedat another hospital. She met with Nyack's medical executive committee, whichrecommended that the suspension be upheld and her privileges not be renewed. After thisrecommendation was adopted by Nyack, she requested a hearing, which ensued before afour-member panel of physicians. The panel issued a detailed written decision finding,among other things, that petitioner had a pattern of inaccessibility to staff when on call,she repeatedly did not respond promptly to the emergency department when on call, shefailed to obtain coverage when unavailable because of illness, she left the operating roomand could not be located while her [*2]patients were insurgery and she failed to properly disclose her suspension at the other hospital asrequired by Nyack's bylaws. Based on these and other findings, the panel recommendedthat her application be denied. Nyack's board of trustees accepted the panel'srecommendation.

Pursuant to Public Health Law § 2801-b, petitioner filed a complaintwith respondent Public Health and Health Planning Council (hereinafter PHHPC)challenging Nyack's refusal to renew her privileges. PHHPC did not credit her complaintand informed her that Nyack's reasons for terminating her privileges were "focused onpatient care and welfare and were consistent with Public Health Law [§ ]2801-b." Petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding seeking to annulNyack's determination and reinstate her privileges.[FN1] Nyack answered, moved to convert theproceeding into a plenary action and, once converted, for summary judgment dismissingthe complaint. Supreme Court denied Nyack's motion and transferred the proceeding tothis Court pursuant to CPLR 7804 (g). Nyack appealed from the denial of itsmotion.[FN2]

Nyack's motion to convert the proceeding into an action for injunctive relief shouldhave been granted. Although at common law a private hospital had unfettered discretionin denying privileges to a physician, Public Health Law article 28 was enacted to temperthe harsh effect of the common law (see e.g. Matter of Cohoes Mem. Hosp. vDepartment of Health of State of N.Y., 48 NY2d 583, 588 [1979]; Guibor vManhattan Eye, Ear & Throat Hosp., 46 NY2d 736, 737 [1978]). Under thestatute, it is an improper practice for a hospital to deny privileges unless it gives reasonstherefor, and those reasons relate to "standards of patient care, patient welfare, theobjectives of the institution or the character or competency of the applicant" (PublicHealth Law § 2801-b [1]). An aggrieved physician generally must seekreview from PHHPC of a denial of privileges (see Public Health Law§ 2801-b [2]; Gelbard v Genesee Hosp., 87 NY2d 691, 696 [1996];see also Indemini v Beth IsraelMed. Ctr., 4 NY3d 63, 67 [2005]; cf. Hong Yin v North Shore LIJ HealthSys., 20 F Supp 3d 359, 367 [ED NY 2014] [noting two narrow exceptionsrecognized in federal courts]). Where the physician thereafter seeks reinstatement ofprivileges based upon allegations of improper practices by the hospital, the remedy is anaction for injunctive relief (see Public Health Law § 2801-c;Bhard-Waj v United Health Servs., Hosps., 303 AD2d 824, 825 [2003];Moallem v Jamaica Hosp., 264 AD2d 621, 622 [1999]; Matter ofChong-Hwan Wee v City of Rome, 233 AD2d 876, 877 [1996]; Matter of Nawazv University Hosp. of State Univ. of N.Y. at Stony Brook, 166 AD2d 593, 593[1990], lv denied 77 NY2d 805 [1991]; Matter of Moss v Albany Med. Ctr.Hosp., 61 AD2d 545, 548 [1978]; see generally Mason v Central Suffolk Hosp., 3 NY3d 343,348 [2004]).

Petitioner asserted improper practices and bylaw procedural violations by Nyack. Asto [*3]each cause of action, she relied in part on allegedviolations of Public Health Law § 2801-b. The primary relief that petitionerseeks is annulment of Nyack's decision and an order directing reinstatement of herprivileges at the hospital. Under such circumstances, Nyack's motion to convert theproceeding into an action should not have been denied, and we now grant such relief(CPLR 103 [c]; Matter of Moss v Albany Med. Ctr. Hosp., 61 AD2d at 548;see also Falk v Anesthesia Assoc. of Jamaica, 228 AD2d 326, 329-330 [1996],lv dismissed 89 NY2d 916 [1996]; Gelbard v Genesee Hosp., 211 AD2d159, 164 [1995], affd 87 NY2d 691 [1996]).

Judicial review of an alleged violation of Public Health Law § 2801-b(1) is "limited to 'whether the purported grounds were reasonably related to theinstitutional concerns set forth in the statute, whether they were based on the apparentfacts as reasonably perceived by the administrators, and whether they were assigned ingood faith' " (Bhard-Waj v United Health Servs., Hosps., 303 AD2d at825, quoting Fried v Straussman, 41 NY2d 376, 383 [1977]; see Matter of Tabrizi v Faxton-St.Luke's Health Care, 66 AD3d 1421, 1421 [2009], lv denied 13 NY3d717 [2010]). Here, the record reflects that petitioner received a fair hearing at which shewas represented by counsel, who cross-examined Nyack's witnesses and presented proofin support of her position. The grounds found by Nyack were reasonably related toinstitutional concerns and amply supported by proof, including, among other things,testimony of hospital personnel and physicians as well as hospital records. Althoughpetitioner alleges bad faith by Nyack, this conclusory allegation is unsupported by anyevidence. The fact that she was not subject to discipline by the Office of ProfessionalMedical Conduct is not evidence of bad faith by Nyack. Since petitioner failed to raisematerial issues of fact, Nyack's motion for summary judgment dismissing the nowconverted action is granted (see Matter of Tabrizi v Faxton-St. Luke's HealthCare, 66 AD3d at 1421-1422; Bhard-Waj v United Health Servs., Hosps.,303 AD2d at 825).

McCarthy, Garry, Rose and Aarons, JJ., concur. Ordered that the appeal from theorder is dismissed, without costs. Adjudged that respondent Nyack Hospital's motion toconvert the CPLR article 78 proceeding into a plenary action and then for summaryjudgment dismissing said action is granted, without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:Although PHHPC wasalso named a respondent, petitioner consented to a dismissal as to PHHPC.

Footnote 2:Nyack's appeal from thenonfinal order denying its motion must be dismissed as no appeal as of right lies from anonfinal order in a CPLR article 78 proceeding (see CPLR 5701 [b] [1]).However, the issues raised with respect to said order are reviewable within the context ofthe transferred proceeding (see Matter of Board of Educ. of Union-Endicott Cent.School Dist. v New York State Pub. Empl. Relations Bd., 250 AD2d 996, 996[1998]; Matter of Schultz v Roberts, 138 AD2d 980, 980 [1988]; Matter ofDesmone v Blum, 99 AD2d 170, 177 [1984]).


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.