Matter of Wegmans Food Mkts., Inc. v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State ofN.Y.
2017 NY Slip Op 08225 [155 AD3d 1352]
November 22, 2017
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, January 3, 2018


[*1]
 In the Matter of Wegmans Food Markets, Inc., Petitioner, v TaxAppeals Tribunal of the State of New York et al., Respondents.

Ward Greenberg Heller & Reidy LLP, Rochester (Jeffrey J. Harradine of counsel), forpetitioner.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Frederick A. Brodie of counsel), forCommissioner of Taxation and Finance, respondent.

Egan Jr., J.P. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuant to TaxLaw § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunaldenying petitioner's request for certain refunds of sales and use tax imposed under Tax Lawarticles 28 and 29.

Petitioner is a regional supermarket chain headquartered in the City of Rochester, MonroeCounty, which operates retail locations in several states, including approximately 50 locationsthroughout New York. As part of its business operations, petitioner monitors the retail pricescharged by its competitors in order to competitively price its products in accordance with itspricing strategy. Since 1995, petitioner has contracted with RetailData, LLC for the provision ofcompetitive price audits (hereinafter CPAs) or price checks in order to determine how much itscompetitors charge for certain specifically requested retail products. RetailData collects this rawdata and compiles it into a report, according to certain specifications provided by petitioner, thatpetitioner thereafter uses to inform its pricing strategies. In 2011, the Department of Taxation andFinance conducted an audit of petitioner's sales and use tax liability for the period between June2007 and February 2010. Following the audit, the Department determined that petitioner'spurchase of CPAs from RetailData, and the corresponding reports derived therefrom, constitutedthe purchase of taxable information services (see Tax Law § 1105 [c] [1])and issued a notice of determination imposing upon petitioner an additional tax amount due of$227,270.01 for the relevant time period. [*2]Petitioner thereafterfiled a petition in the Division of Tax Appeals challenging the determination and seeking aredetermination and refund of its sales tax liability. Following a hearing, an Administrative LawJudge (hereinafter ALJ) sustained the determination, concluding that the CPAs and writtenreports produced by RetailData and purchased by petitioner did not fall within the applicableexclusion from the imposition of sales tax because the information purchased was not, amongother things, personal and individual in nature to petitioner (see Tax Law§ 1105 [c] [1]). Petitioner filed an exception to the ALJ's determination and,following a hearing, respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal affirmed the ALJ's determination.Petitioner then commenced this proceeding, seeking to, among other things, annul the Tribunal'sdetermination.

This Court's review of the Tribunal's determination is limited. So long as the Tribunal'sdetermination is rationally based and is supported by substantial evidence, it must be confirmed,even where a different conclusion is reasonable (see Matter of American Food & Vending Corp. v New York State TaxAppeals Trib., 144 AD3d 1227, 1228 [2016]; Matter of Hwang v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 105 AD3d1151, 1152 [2013]). "Where the interpretation of a statute or its application involvesknowledge and understanding of underlying operational practices or entails an evaluation offactual data and inferences to be drawn therefrom," the courts are generally deferential "to thegovernmental agency charged with responsibility for administration of the statute" (Matter ofColt Indus. v New York City Dept. of Fin., 66 NY2d 466, 470-471 [1985] [internal quotationmarks, brackets and citation omitted]); however, if "the question is one of pure statutory readingand analysis, dependent only on accurate apprehension of legislative intent, there is little basis torely upon any special competence or expertise of the administrative agency and its interpretiveregulations are, therefore, to be accorded much less weight" (Matter of New York Life Ins.Co. v State Tax Commn., 80 AD2d 675, 676 [1981], affd 55 NY2d 758 [1981]). Theburden is on the taxpayer to establish that the determination being challenged clearly falls withinthe applicable exclusion (see Matter of677 New Loudon Corp. v State of N.Y. Tax Appeals Trib., 19 NY3d 1058, 1060 [2012],cert denied 571 US &mdash, 134 S Ct 422 [2013]; Matter of American Food &Vending Corp. v New York State Tax Appeals Trib., 144 AD3d at 1228). "Where thelanguage of a statute is clear and unambiguous, courts must give effect to its plain meaning" (Matter of Charter Dev. Co., L.L.C. v Cityof Buffalo, 6 NY3d 578, 581 [2006] [internal quotation marks, brackets and citationomitted]); however, in the event of ambiguity, "where, as here, an exclusion rather than anexemption is involved, the statute must be strictly construed in favor of the taxpayer" (Matterof New York Life Ins. Co. v State Tax Commn., 80 AD2d at 676; see Matter of Grace vNew York State Tax Commn., 37 NY2d 193, 196 [1975]; Matter of Towne-Oller &Assoc. v State Tax Commn., 120 AD2d 873, 874 n [1986]; Matter of Greco Bros.Amusement Co. v Chu, 113 AD2d 622, 624 [1986]; but see Matter of Mobil OilCorp. v Finance Adm'r of City of N.Y., 58 NY2d 95, 99 [1983]).[FN1]

[*3] Petitioner contends that the Tribunal erred as a matter of law by determining that itspurchase of pricing information from RetailData was not personal and individual in nature and,therefore, not subject to the tax exclusion provided by Tax Law § 1105 (c) (1). Asrelevant here, Tax Law § 1105 (c) (1) provides that sales tax may be imposed uponthe sale of the service of "furnishing . . . information by printed, mimeographed ormultigraphed matter or by duplicating written or printed matter in any other manner, includingthe services of collecting, compiling or analyzing information of any kind or nature andfurnishing reports thereof to other persons." Tax Law § 1105 (c) (1) excludes fromsales tax, however, "the furnishing of information which is personal or individual in nature andwhich is not or may not be substantially incorporated in reports furnished to other persons"(see Westwood Pharms. v Chu, 164 AD2d 462, 465 [1990], lv denied 77 NY2d807 [1991]; Matter of New York Life Ins. Co. v State Tax Commn., 80 AD2d at676).

There is no dispute that the CPAs and written reports that RetailData provided to petitionerqualify as an information service, as their primary purpose is to disseminate information (seeMatter of Towne-Oller & Assoc. v State Tax Commn., 120 AD2d at 873-874).Accordingly, as the Tribunal properly delineated, the primary issue to be determined is whetherthe information furnished in these CPAs and written reports "is personal or individual in natureand which is not or may not be substantially incorporated in reports furnished to other persons"(Tax Law § 1105 [c] [1]). Respondent Commissioner of Taxation and Financeargues that, inasmuch as the raw data that served as the basis for RetailData's CPAs and writtenreports consisted solely of pricing information obtained from products on the shelves ofsupermarkets that were open to the public, the information furnished was not personal orindividual in nature, as the data clearly derived from a common source or data repository.

While there is no question that the pricing information that RetailData collects on petitioner'sbehalf is information that is available to the public, we agree with petitioner that, under thecircumstances presented here, such information does not derive from a singular, widelyaccessible common source or database as that test has previously been applied and commonlyunderstood in determining the applicability of the subject tax exclusion (see Matter of ADPAutomotive Claims Servs. v Tax Appeals Trib., 188 AD2d 245, 246-247 [1993], lvdenied 82 NY2d 655 [1993] [information derived from database of autopart prices andestimate installation times]; Matter of Rich Prods. Corp. v Chu, 132 AD2d 175 [1987];Matter of Towne-Oller & Assoc. v State Tax Commn., 120 AD2d at 874[information derived from tapes from wholesalers and distributors identifying products andstores]; Allstate Ins. Co. v Tax Commn. of State of N.Y., 115 AD2d 831, 831-832[1985], affd 67 NY2d 999 [1986] [information derived from motor vehicle reportsaccessible in the Department of Motor Vehicles]). Here, based on its own unique andconfidential pricing strategy, petitioner provided RetailData with its collection criteria for theaudits to be performed, including the specific stores that it wanted RetailData to audit, thespecific pricing information that it wanted RetailData to collect and the frequency with which itwanted these audits to be conducted. Such requests routinely involved RetailData auditingmultiple competing supermarkets chains and multiple retail locations within each competingchain.[FN2] RetailDatawould then physically send data collectors to each individual [*4]location to manually record the requested pricing information. Tothe extent that the pricing information for each of petitioner's competitors regularly fluctuatedaccordingly to their own unique pricing strategies, there was no singular preexisting commonsource or data repository that RetailData could access to timely obtain the specific pricinginformation that petitioner had requested. The data requested, therefore, was not collected fromone general source (see Westwood Pharms. v Chu, 164 AD2d at 466-467).

Significantly, once the raw data or specified pricing information was collected, pursuant toRetailData's collection methodology, it was maintained as a separate and distinct workcomponent or database for RetailData's sole use in preparing its written report for petitioner. Thisinformation, therefore, was not maintained in a general database that was viewable or for use byany of RetailData's other clients,[FN3] there is no evidence that any such informationever was shared with other clients and, significantly, the contract between petitioner andRetailData contained a confidentiality provision that expressly prohibited RetailData fromproviding any such information to third parties. RetailData then analyzed and verified theinformation through its own propriety software according to specifications set forth by petitioner,and a written report was generated in a customized format pursuant to petitioner's specificationsthat was only compatible with petitioner's propriety price management system.[FN4] At all relevant times throughoutthe process, therefore, the information furnished to petitioner was uniquely tailored to petitioner'sspecifications and was related exclusively to implementation of its confidential pricing strategy.On the record before us, therefore, we find that the information services that petitioner purchasedfrom RetailData were personal or individual in nature and were not substantially incorporatedinto reports of others such that petitioner's purchase of these information services should havebeen excluded from taxation pursuant to Tax Law § 1105 (c) (1) (see WestwoodPharms. v Chu, 164 AD2d at 465-466; Matter of New York Life Ins. Co. v State TaxCommn., 80 AD2d at 677; see also NY St Dept of Taxation & Fin Advisory OpNo. TSB-A-17[12]S at 1-3; compare Matter of ADP Automotive Claims Servs. v TaxAppeals Trib., 188 AD2d at 246-248; Matter of Towne-Oller & Assoc. v State TaxCommn., 120 AD2d at 874).[FN5] In our view, to expand the interpretation of TaxLaw § 1105 (c) (1) to allow for the Tribunal's denial of the subject tax exclusionbased solely on the fact that the information ultimately furnished derived from a public sourcewould, under the circumstances presented, serve to defeat the purpose of the exclusion (seeMatter of New York Life Ins. Co. v State Tax Commn., 80 AD2d at 677-678).

Devine, Clark, Mulvey and Rumsey, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isannulled, without costs, and petition granted.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:Although we note that Matterof Mobil Oil Corp. v Finance Adm'r of City of N.Y. (58 NY2d 95, 99 [1983]) indicates thatexclusions are to be construed against the taxpayer, to the extent that the proposition inMobil relies upon precedent that refers to exemptions rather than exclusions (seeMatter of Young v Bragalini, 3 NY2d 602, 605-606 [1958]; Matter of Schwartzman,262 App Div 635, 636 [1941], affd 288 NY 568 [1942]), we find that, as this Courtpreviously held in Matter of Towne-Oller & Assoc. v State Tax Commn. (120 AD2dat 874 n), precedent indicates otherwise.

Footnote 2:In performing its CPAs,RetailData conducted either directed audits wherein petitioner would provide a specific "key itemlist" for certain retail products that it wanted RetailData to audit at certain specified retaillocations or it would conduct an undirected audit, wherein petitioner would request RetailData toaudit a whole category of products (i.e., dairy or cosmetics) at certain specified retail locations.

Footnote 3:Although it was certainlypossible that two of RetailData's customers could request the same pricing information for aparticular item at a particular retail location (compare Matter of Towne-Oller & Assoc. vState Tax Commn., 120 AD2d at 873-874), the evidence clearly indicated that, despite anysuch overlap, RetailData did not use data it collected for one client to complete a price audit foranother client.

Footnote 4:Specifically, RetailData wouldanalyze the raw data collected and, where appropriate, remove outlying information based uponpricing information that appeared to be historically inconsistent within a specified time frame orwas otherwise collected outside the requested time frame.

Footnote 5:Although the Tribunal did notmake an express finding regarding whether the information service that RetailData furnished topetitioner was not and could not be substantially incorporated into reports produced for otherpersons or entities (see Tax Law § 1105 [c] [1]), we find remittalunnecessary to the extent that our independent factual review of the record reveals ampleevidence in support of such finding (see CPLR 7804 [g]).


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.